A couple of months after the New York Islanders lost star center John Tavares in free agency, Barry Trotz admitted his new team would look different. That didn’t mean he thought they’d be worse.

“One of the easiest things to correct, if there’s a commitment and a buy-in, is keeping the puck out of your net,” the coach told the Athletic’s New York site in August. “We’ll need a bigger buy-in, we’ll put some structure, we’ll make sure the details are there and we’ll make players accountable.”

Jeez, Barry, you sure made the biggest defensive turnaround in NHL history sound easy.

The star-studded Penguins have drawn an irritating first-round playoff opponent in the Islanders, who this season became the league’s first-ever team to go from worst to first in goals against.

Advertise with us

In 2017-18, the Islanders surrendered 293 goals. This season, their first under Trotz, they gave up 102 fewer and had the league’s fifth-best record, making Trotz a favorite for the Jack Adams Award.

“The Islanders will be a tough opponent,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “They’re a real good team. They’ve had a great year. And we’ve had some really hard-fought battles against them.”

The Islanders frustrated the Penguins a month into the season. They won in Pittsburgh, chasing Matt Murray with four goals on nine shots. Two nights later, they beat them in Brooklyn after Thomas Greiss sprawled to poke the puck away on a Sidney Crosby breakaway to send it to a shootout.

The Penguins bounced back in December to defeat the Islanders in each of their final two regular-season meetings, the last one a 2-1 shootout win on Dec. 10 at Nassau Coliseum. The first-round playoff series will open there on Long Island on Wednesday with Game 2 taking place two nights later.

“The type of hockey they play is a playoff style. It’s tight. They don’t give up a lot,” Crosby said. “You look at the games we played against them, you’ve got to earn the space you create out there. They’re defensive-minded, but they can score, too. They have depth. So it will be a good challenge.”

Advertise with us

The Islanders this season posted 11 shutouts and allowed one goal or fewer 28 times.

How did they do it? A lot of it comes back to Trotz and his stingy defensive system.

Just like the Washington Capitals team that Trotz coached to a Stanley Cup last season, the Islanders build a wall along their blue line. Sometimes, it looks like a 1-1-3 alignment in the neutral zone, other times a 2-3 or a 1-3-1. The key number there is 3, as in the number of defenders on their blue line.

Afforded time to set up, the Islanders can cause problems for a skill-based team like the Penguins, whose players prefer to carry the puck into the zone instead of lobbing it into one of the corners.

“It’s about recognizing where the ice is to play on,” Sullivan said of the dump-and-chase game, adding, “If we just try to carry the puck in all the time when there’s not a lot of time and space or puck support, we might be able to create a lot of chances. But what are we giving up on the other side?”

Advertise with us

Those “high-risk” plays at the blue line often lead to an odd-man rush the other way. There was a bunch of those Saturday, when the Penguins played a little too loose in a 4-3 overtime loss to the New York Rangers.

“We know we need to tighten up in the playoffs. There's some odd-man rushes we need to clean up and whatnot,” Jake Guentzel said. “But we like where our game is going heading into the playoffs.”

Sullivan said he has “always been a strong believer” that the best teams create offensive a few different ways. If the Penguins have a chance to counterattack against the Islanders, he wants them to go, go, go. But if there are few opportunities on the rush, don’t forget about the “grind game,” guys.

The Islanders make things difficult inside the zone, too. Trotz likes to pack all five skaters in front of the net so they can pick off back-door passes, block shots and whack away any juicy rebounds.

By allowing an NHL-low 191 goals, the Islanders earned goalies Greiss and Robin Lehner the William M. Jennings Trophy. Lehner, who opened up before the season about his bipolar diagnosis and battles with addiction, is expected to be in net for the Islanders. He has a .930 save percentage.

Advertise with us

Of course, you can’t win a game without putting the puck in the other team’s net at least once. The Islanders don’t quite have the offensive arsenal that Trotz had at his disposal in D.C. with Alex Ovechkin, Evgeny Kuznetsov and everyone else. Their 223 goals were second-lowest among playoff teams.

But there is balance there that will put pressure on all four Pittsburgh lines. New York had eight players with at least 16 goals, led by Anders Lee, who buried 28. Young center Mathew Barzal, who clicked with Crosby and Kris Letang at this year’s NHL All-Star Game, paced the Islanders with 62 points.

“They've got Barzal, who's a great player. Their top line is really good,” Murray said. “They just seem like a well-rounded group, a group that plays well defensively and doesn't give you a whole lot.”

The stacked Penguins, despite starting the series on the road, are widely considered the favorites to win the series. But they must be careful against this pesky, playoff-ready team coached by Trotz.

“We’re going to have to make sure that we have an element of patience with our game,” Sullivan said. “We’ve got to take what they give us. We’re going to have to compete every bit as hard and we’re going to have to make sure we have a discipline to our game, that we play within some structure.”

Matt Vensel: mvensel@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mattvensel.