Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lonnie Shelton and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Koen, @FluerySSBU: (this question has been on my mind for over a year) What transpired to have the Pens go away from the "Speed Kills!" playstyle & mantra that brought them such success and could an unceremonious first round exit make them return to the speed & skill concept?

Starkey: Great question, Koen. And there isn’t one easy answer.

It is a combination of the following …

Advertise with us

• Teams adjusted, as teams always do. The Penguins could no longer take them by surprise as they did in 2016. I’ll give you an example: When was the last time you saw Bryan Rust on a breakaway? (When was the last time you saw Bryan Rust, period?). He used to get one every other playoff game, it seemed. Teams adjust. The Penguins used to have that aerial game, too, throwing pucks to open ice to create foot races. Remember? They used the long stretch pass successfully, remember? Opponents won’t allow that forever.

• Teams copied the champ, as teams always do, and when the other guys get faster, you don’t look as fast compared to them. Look at Carolina’s defense right now. Look at the Islanders’ D. See many slow guys?

• Most of the Penguins’ core players are three years older, and while none has morphed into Steve McKenna, age rarely makes you faster.

• General manager Jim Rutherford made moves that nobody would put in the category of, “That made us faster!”

Some were obvious: He traded one of the swiftest players in the league in Carl Hagelin, a player who disrupts what other teams do at playoff time. Hagelin would be very useful in this series. I can tell you that. Rutherford also committed $16.25 million and five years to Jack Johnson, who is nobody’s definition of fast.

Advertise with us

Other moves were move subtle – and I’m not saying I disagreed with all of them. Ben Lovejoy, Trevor Daley and Conor Sheary left. Ryan Reaves arrived. Johnson arrived. Olli Maatta’s skating issues have not been solved.

No doubt, Rutherford has gotten away from a speed-wins philosophy. The question is, what has he replaced it with? The Penguins are basically a UFO at the moment. You look at them and say, “What is that?” They have no clear identity.

But I would argue that even in their second Cup win under Mike Sullivan, it wasn’t like the Penguins were dominating with speed. People forget that Marc-Andre Fleury stole the Capitals series, a large portion of which the Penguins spent in rope-a-dope mode, blocking shots and scoring timely goals and basically hanging on for dear life.

So this isn’t new.

Connie McGinley, @StanceLey: Would the Pens be able to have success with a similar “defense first” game plan as the NYI? If so, why not employ that?

Advertise with us

Starkey: The Islanders system begins with two defensemen back at all times, Connie. They rarely pinch in the offensive zone. They rarely take chances. Certainly, the Penguins could be less risky on defense. Sullivan could institute a “no-pinching rule,” for sure.

But in terms of overall philosophy, a no-risk, team-defense philosophy takes time to instill and develop. And nobody, least of all the folks shelling out big money for tickets, wants to see the Penguins play such a style all season.

Could they suddenly spring a trap or some surprising tactic, the way the 1992 Penguins did against Washington (going to a 1-4 delay in the middle of a series)? I suppose — but that move was in response to a Capitals team whose defensemen were jumping into plays all over the place. Their defensemen had basically become forwards. That isn't the case here. The next big risk the Islanders take will be their first.

The Kevin Constantine Penguins also used a surprise tactic to upset the top-seeded New Jersey Devils. They went to a center-lock, and suddenly defensemen who had not pinched all season were pinching. Maybe these Penguins could do the opposite and try to bore the Islanders to death.

It’s a conundrum. But the Penguins could start by not making so many dumb decisions on defense. Live to fight another day.

Advertise with us

unknonlincoln, @unknownlincoln: You recently wrote about Kasparaitis...what athlete (non super star) was the best to cover?

Starkey: Kasparaitis.

Dac, @Dac00272734: When will Pirates starting pitchers fall apart?

Starkey: They won’t, Dac. Jameson Taillon and Trevor Williams were very good last season. Chris Archer has a history of success and has expanded his repertoire here. Joe Musgrove has all the stuff to be an excellent starter (he also has a 0.00 ERA, which is kind of tough to maintain). Jordan Lyles has been the biggest surprise. Who knows where that will go?

I honestly believe this is the best rotation in the NL Central. I believe it has lasting power. And if Musgrove surprises the way A.J. Burnett did, the way Edinson Volquez did, the way Francisco Liriano and J.A. Happ once did — which is to say, became very good instead of just good or average — the Pirates might win this division.

Advertise with us

Either way, this rotation is for real.

klaugh56, @klaugh56: Would you bet $85k on the Pens to win 4 in a row if the pay off was a billion?

Starkey: If I had Mullsy money, yes (not that I think it will happen, but the simple economics of that bet, if I were filthy rich, would make sense).

DC Pitt Fan, @hailtopitt2005: Last we chatted in your mailbag, we both liked the Pens to go deep. What the heck happened? Knew the Isles would be a tough draw, but a possible sweep? Any chance they come back tonight?

Starkey: Yes, they will win tonight, Mr. DC PItt Fan (keep in mind, however, that I am 0-3 in the series, just the like the Penguins).

Advertise with us

What happened?

Let’s start with a series of horrendous decisions by the defense. One after another. Kris Letang went 1-on-3 in overtime in Game 1. That was notable. He’s had plenty of company. Brian Dumoulin, coming off an injury, never plays this poorly. Every single player back there has had at least one monumentally hideous play. That cannot happen in a series where every mistake is magnified. If the Penguins defense just plays a simple game, the Islanders aren’t getting so many odd-man breaks.

The Penguins have not taken advantage of their power-play opportunities. The stars have not found a way to create offense. Perhaps the point of attack should be behind the goal line instead of continuously trying the low-to-high game.

And the Islanders are better than most of us anticipated. At last count, there are two teams on the ice.

If I were to identify a key sequence in the series, it would be late in the second period of Game 1. The Penguins had just tied it 2-2. They were swarming. Phil Kessel then missed an open net and Robin Lehner made his best save of the series, stopping Evgeni Malkin after Jared McCann made a great pass.

Advertise with us

Instead of playing with a lead after two periods, something the Penguins do very well under Mike Sullivan, it was anybody’s ballgame. And then the Islanders nearly converted a high-risk Jake Guentzel pass into the winning goal late in regulation. And then Letang went 1-on-3.

Ashley Stouffer, @anarchyangel846: Do you think that the Pens are still trying to play a fast game even though they got rid of all the speed? Do you think Hagelin could’ve made a difference? (Maybe a revamped HBK line- Hags/Bjugstad/Kessel?) By the way, I love the show!

Starkey: I addressed this earlier, Ashley, but I’ll say this about Hagelin: The Penguins miss him. They apparently tried to re-acquire him at the deadline but were still paying a portion of his salary, which made them ineligible to re-acquire him in the same season. I’d love to know the whole story there. Were they not aware of the rule?

Anyway, I couldn’t care less about Hagelin not scoring goals. He’s a playoff force in so many ways. You’ll see if you tune into a Capitals game.

“The All Mighty” Jonathan Burton, @JonBurton32: Why do we park in a driveway and drive on a parkway?

Advertise with us

Starkey: God’s plan.

Thank you, kiddies. Send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).