In the era of hot takes, It has to be somebody’s fault when things don’t go well for the home team.

But the Penguins, in a 3-0 series deficit to the Islanders, are proof that losing is almost always a team effort. So far, this has been a total meltdown by an entire organization, and the only good news is that it isn’t over yet. Though the chances are slim, there is still a chance they can turn it around and come back to win the series.

I wouldn’t bet against the Penguins to come back and win, given the pedigree of their stars, but it is far more likely they will get swept than it is they will win four games in a row.

The biggest difference between the Islanders and Penguins is easy to see: One team knows who it is and is comfortable with it, and the other has no identity.

Advertise with us

The Islanders play a structured, defensive style and are patient and don’t take many chances. They are content to play the hockey version of four corners and very rarely deviate from the plan. They have allowed the Penguins to take their chances and then capitalized on their mistakes.

The Penguins, well ... I have no idea what they are trying to accomplish, and I don’t think they do, either.

If you don’t think that’s fair, ask yourself this: Who are the Penguins? They aren’t an old team, but they aren’t a young team. They are a team with playoff experience, but they are also relying on a lot of players who weren’t a part of the Stanley Cup runs. They aren’t a fast team built on speed anymore, but they aren’t necessarily slow. They aren’t completely finesse and skill, but they aren’t really heavy and physical, either.

That speaks to a coach who doesn’t know how to put together these pieces he was handed. It speaks also to a coach who hasn’t allowed the pieces to play together enough to figure out if they fit.

It also speaks volumes about a team that was poorly conceived and poorly constructed. The Penguins either needed to sell out to be a fast, skilled team or recognize that age is catching up to some of the stars and commit to being a little more of a defensive-minded team.

Advertise with us

That doesn’t, however, mean all of the blame is on Mike Sullivan and Jim Rutherford. They have not gotten a lot of help from their players, especially many of the stars.

The Penguins have gotten almost no production from Sidney Crosby, Jake Guentzel, Jared McCann, Bryan Rust and Dominik Simon. Oli Maatta has not been good, nor has Jack Johnson, and Kris Letang and Evgeni Malkin have made enough mistakes and boneheaded plays and decisions to last a lifetime.

And while Matt Murray hasn’t been awful, he hasn’t been that elite-level goalie the Penguins need him to be to win in the playoffs. Murray needed to be the X-factor in the series and instead he has been outplayed by the Islanders’ Robin Lehner.

The Penguins aren’t dead yet, but time is clearly running out.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise