Sidney Crosby talks about what it will take to come back from a 3-0 deficit

Mike Sullivan said he might watch “Game of Thrones” and take his two black labs, Hank and Stanley, for a long walk. Justin Schultz, who’s generally acknowledged as the Penguins’ best golfer, planned on watching more Masters coverage. Matt Murray expected a “normal night” with maybe a few friends over, while Sidney Crosby figured he’d probably wind up watching hockey.

A day before their season could come to a sudden, screeching halt, Penguins players and their coach splintered throughout Cranberry and Sewickley, plus a few more Downtown, to get their minds off the issue at hand. By Tuesday night, however, with the prospect of getting swept out of the playoffs looming large, the Penguins knew they’d have be on the same page.

With taking fewer risks. With navigating the Islanders’ strong defensive structure. With actually scoring consecutive goals, something they’ve yet to do against the Islanders, and generally figuring out a way to find something to feel good about.

“You can say a lot of different things,” Crosby said. “But at the end of the day, it’s going out there [Tuesday] and finding a way to win a hockey game.”

Advertise with us

Crosby is right. Ditto for Murray, Schultz, Brian Dumoulin and Sullivan, who took turns entering and exiting the media room at UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex, the result of Sullivan’s decision to suddenly sack practice.

Such a move was somewhat strategic, Sullivan admitted, but it also didn’t hurt that the Penguins had skated eight days in a row. Even had they been ahead at this juncture, one would think Sullivan might’ve given his players a day off.

But facing a 3-0 deficit and nearly insurmountable odds — only four teams have ever come back from a 3-0 deficit, including one (the 1942 Maple Leafs) that did so before 70-year-old general manager Jim Rutherford was born — Sullivan figured that shocking the collective system might work, too.

In his comments, Sullivan drew a parallel to the team’s final, extended road trip of the regular season, a four-gamer through Raleigh, Nashville, Dallas and Manhattan, when they took seven of a possible eight points despite not having a single practice mixed in there.

This, Sullivan apparently figured, will be sort of the same thing.

Advertise with us

“Our team responded really well when we didn’t skate the day before, had morning skates and played,” Sullivan said. “We have some history there to draw on.”

As for history climbing out of their current canyon-like circumstance, there’s hardly any precedent for this sort of thing. Anywhere.

The last NHL team to do it was the 2014 Los Angeles Kings. Before that, the 2010 Flyers. There’s a Pittsburgh tie here, too, with the New York Islanders storming back to beat the Penguins in the 1975 NHL quarterfinals, but that’s it.

While some might look at that and say the odds are slim to none, with slim making his way out of town, Crosby has seemingly taken a different approach.

Having won the Stanley Cup three times, and with pretty much every meaningful accolade a player of his stature can earn, here’s something Crosby has not done: erase a 3-0 deficit.

Advertise with us

“It’s not the position you want to be in,” Crosby said. “But that being said, I’d love to be a part of a team that comes back from [a 3-0 deficit]. We believe that it starts with just winning one game.”

A fine point by Crosby, because as Islanders coach Barry Trotz adroitly put it on the morning of Game 2: “You can’t win four without winning two.”

Math aside, the Penguins have enough to worry about when it comes to Trotz, who is being called their playoff kryptonite if you have had the nerve to log onto social media the past two days.

They need to figure out a way to penetrate his sit-back-and-frustrate philosophy, developed with the Capitals last year and perfected by the Islanders this postseason. Those squads have driven much of Pittsburgh batty because they’ve basically allowed the Penguins to beat themselves.

It’s also time, should the Penguins care to extend their postseason stay into a second week, for their star players to do something. Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel have a goal apiece in the series, but the Penguins have gotten goose eggs from Crosby, Jake Guentzel, Patric Hornqvist and Kris Letang, who combined for 109 goals during the regular season.

Advertise with us

“We have to be able to create offense different ways,” Sullivan said. “That’s been the challenge. That will continue to be the challenge moving forward.”

How quickly the Penguins solve that challenge could determine how long this particular march lasts. It could be 60 more minutes, one game, a loss triggering an offseason of change.

Or the Penguins could start heeding their coach’s advice, play a more responsible brand of hockey and start asserting themselves the way they’re capable.

If they do that on Tuesday, it’ll force a Game 5 on Thursday on Long Island. Win that one, and maybe the Islanders — with one series win since 1993 — start to get tight.

But as these guys repeated over and over before venturing out into gloomy and chilly weather more befitting of a December funk than a Stanley Cup run, the situation now is best-distilled down into one game.

Advertise with us

Or maybe less than that.

“Of course it would be great [to come back from a 3-0 deficit], but we're focused on one game at a time,” Murray said. “We can't do anything more than that. All we have in front of us is one game. Before that we have a morning skate we have to prepare for and get ourselves feeling good about [Tuesday] night. That's all we can do.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.