Something I don’t get to say as often as I’d like these days is, “I’m too young to remember that.” But with this weekend’s commemoration of the historic Apollo 11 flight, I can.

I’d just finished first grade when American astronauts set foot on the moon. My parents were diligent news consumers; we subscribed to both the morning and afternoon Kansas City papers and ended dinner each night by turning on the television for the national news, but I have no memory of the “giant leap” itself — nor of any controversies surrounding it.

At Harry S. Truman Elementary School, as we memorized the planets of the solar system, we were learning about the Apollo mission and the “space race” against the Soviets.

I am fairly certain, though, that our tornado drills were just tornado drills. In the Great Plains, people were legitimately more worried about severe weather than Soviet missiles. What good would it do to huddle under your desk in the event of a nuclear blast anyway? But if my cohort was not old enough to closely follow the first moon landing, we soon came to be proud of the fact that our country had caught up to and then surpassed the communists.

Advertise with us

It wasn’t until the 1990s, while interviewing members of another city’s most historic black church, that I encountered fellow citizens who off-handedly mentioned they thought the moon landing had been faked. I was dumbfounded. I’d heard vaguely of this phenomenon but never witnessed it — a straightforward, even cheerful, belief that NASA had staged the whole thing.

I didn’t argue or even disagree; I just listened. It was another sober reminder that not all Americans had as much confidence in the federal government — or in representative democracy, period — as I did.

Searing experiences that create mistrust do not exist only along racial fault lines, though; they also appear along generational divides. My 20-something children are considerably less optimistic and trusting than my generation, but, ironically, they have witnessed the rise of technologies that make faked moon landings a digital piece of cake.

They haven’t just witnessed these technologies. They are addicted to them. Electronic pings measure their days. Because they came of age in a lackluster economy while being force-fed endless political scandal, what little trust they have resides more in Silicon Valley than on Capitol Hill.

Perhaps neither place is worthy of our ultimate confidence. Some astronauts had their own ideas about this, but the public expression of those ideas inspired litigation that dragged on through the Apollo mission’s last years.

Advertise with us

On Christmas Eve 1968, as Apollo 8 orbited the moon, the crew read aloud the Genesis account of creation and then wished a Merry Christmas to “all of you on the good Earth.” It was the most-watched television broadcast yet in history. Famed atheist Madalyn Murray O’Hair soon sued the U.S. government for thus violating her freedom of religion.

The case was still pending in July 1969, so the only religious observance on Apollo 11 was private. After the lunar module settled — “The Eagle has landed” — Buzz Aldrin celebrated communion by himself with bread and wine from Houston’s Webster Presbyterian (dubbed “Church of the Astronauts” because so many from NASA attended it). Then, after Neil Armstrong, he stepped onto the moon.

Despite Mr. Aldrin’s discretion, Apollo 11 was included in O’Hair’s lawsuit, which zig-zagged through the courts. The U.S. Supreme Court dismissed it “for want of jurisdiction.” I so wanted there to be another phrase added to SCOTUS’ single sentence — “lack of jurisdiction … because it’s outer space” — but humor gets tricky any time you gore someone’s sacred cow.

Irreligion can be a religion. So can democracy, technology, success, fine food, etc. It’s fascinating to learn, 50 years later, that science wasn’t sufficient for these astronauts. For them, questioning and faith went hand in hand, and they weren’t afraid to say so. Maybe we could hold that tension too.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com

Advertise with us