She’s not my type.” Many people must have done a double-take when they heard President Donald Trump’s first defense against writer E. Jean Carroll’s claim that he assaulted her in a department store dressing room in the 1990s.
His words are startling for two reasons: One, because the kind of sexual assault Ms. Carroll alleges has nothing to do with attraction and everything to do with power; and two, because an American president has used this defense before.
The New York Times’ article on the latest Trump scandal carried this headline: “’She’s Not My Type’: Accused Again of Sexual Assault, Trump Resorts to Old Insult’.”
But this “old insult” — very significantly — pre-dates Donald Trump. Those of us who remember the 1990s know, courtesy of the Starr Report, that President Bill Clinton used the same logic to dismiss Kathleen Willey’s claim he assaulted her near the Oval Office. According to Monica Lewinsky, the 22-year-old intern with whom he was having an affair, he said the allegation “was ludicrous because he would never approach a small-breasted woman like Ms. Willey.”
I’m confused: Is there one type of woman men seduce and another type they assault? Is there still a type of man out there who thinks “seduce” and “assault” are synonyms?
While The Times omitted this not-so-distant history, history may help explain why Mr. Trump seems — so far — to be impervious to yet another troubling accusation. He has been immunized twice: by the infamous “Access Hollywood” tape and by Bill Clinton.
Read More
Just before the October 2016 presidential debate, a recording surfaced, made en route to a taping of a TV show, of Mr. Trump speaking in blunt, gross terms of how aggressively he would approach women. He survived the ensuing uproar and, four weeks later, defeated whom?
Hillary Clinton, the woman who notoriously derided and sneered at the women who accused her husband of similar conduct.
Back in the ‘90s, though, public opinion eventually moved in Mr. Clinton’s favor. Voters knew of his behavior, thanks to tabloids and “60 Minutes,” before electing him. After years of scandal — the Lewinsky affair, Paula Jones’s lawsuit, Juanita Broaddrick’s accusation of rape and, finally, impeachment — Mr. Clinton left office with approval ratings as high as ever.
Is Mr. Trump following a similar path? Voters knew about his sexual history before the 2016 election and put him in office anyway. He’s never been as popular as Mr. Clinton, and his style could hardly be more different, but do his supporters look at the newest allegation, after years of attack, as just more piling on?
Are we all suffering from scandal fatigue? #MeToo overload?
As Elle’s longtime advice columnist, Ms. Carroll is droll, unpredictable and pretty fierce — the only “must-read” in any women’s magazine. The incident she alleges with Mr. Trump in the mid-’90s is not just assault, it’s rape. In some ways, she is Mr. Trump’s Juanita Broaddrick — strong and credible, though silent for years.
It’s significant, though, that when Ms. Broaddrick did come forward, NBC News investigated her claim, gathered much corroborating testimony and then quashed the story for weeks — until after Mr. Clinton had been impeached and acquitted.
These are different times — and this president fronts a different political party, of course.
Mr. Trump’s denials sound confident — though as jarring as all his utterances. And there are Ms. Carroll’s flaky moments even in friendly interviews, plus the fact that she’s speaking out only as she launches a new book.
What are we to think?
Waves of history are colliding here. How the Clinton and Trump presidencies are judged will largely depend on the politics of those judging. How their lives are judged depends on forces one unleashed and the other must navigate.
Two men born just two months apart have woven stories so sordid that we must weigh the worst that could be said of them. This rough justice may be all anyone in these sad stories gets.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.