In the wake of E. Jean Carroll’s recent claim that a famous Manhattan real estate developer raped her in the early 1990s, at least two realities exasperate many Americans who do not concede powerful men’s right to rape. Both state of affairs center on the accuser’s reported rapist, New York City confidence man turned president of the United States Donald John Trump.
First, 20 credible reports of sexual misconduct against Mr. Trump have occasioned neither his failure to ascend to the presidency nor his removal from it. Second, there appear to be no consequences whatsoever (at least thus far) for Mr. Trump boldly boasting of criminal sexual misconduct, an action from which no similarly accused and exposed man could publicly emerge unscathed.
Even President Bill Clinton, who enjoyed immense popularity at the time of his administration, faced the music for his sexual peccadillos with White House intern Monica Lewinsky. After weeks of denying the sexual relationship with the staffer, the president eventually admitted in the summer of 1998 sole responsibility for “inappropriate intimate contact” with her. The discovery of the lady’s dark blue Gap dress soiled with the presidential DNA of William Jefferson Clinton communicated the truth.
On Nov. 12, 1998, the U.S. House of Representatives impeached the 42nd president for perjury before a grand jury and obstruction of justice, only the second time Congress has voted to impeach a president. The booming peacetime economy, raging stock market, resulting immense Clinton popularity and a national “it’s only sex” mentality conspired against a Clinton conviction. On Feb. 12, 1999, he was acquitted in the U.S. Senate.
Now, 20 years later another dark dress — this time a black Donna Karan — surfaces prominently in a case of reported presidential carnal misconduct. In her new book, the noted author Ms. Carroll recounts details of her alleged rape by Mr. Trump in a Bergdorf Goodman store dressing room, steps from Trump Tower.
Mr. Clinton dodged a removal-by-impeachment bullet; Mr. Trump is in danger of one, as 78 congressmen favor invocation of Article II of the Constitution. Still, the cases of these two amorous chief executives differ significantly.
Read More
The cited charges against Mr. Clinton centered exclusively around sex. The cited transgressions of 45 — Russia, emoluments, power usurpation, etc. — seemingly encompass everything but sex.
But Ms. Carroll’s account, excerpted in New York magazine’s June 24 cover story, describes the author wearing the Karan dress while being raped by Mr. Trump, hanging it in her closet after arriving home and neither cleaning it nor wearing it thereafter. The latter two facts could form the basis of justice for the advice columnist ... and for America.
Of the 20 women who have accused Mr. Trump of sex offenses — all of which he has denied in his characteristic style, including a defense citing the women’s unsuitable-for-rape looks — only Ms. Carroll reported being raped by Donald Trump
If Mr. Trump’s DNA resides on and/or in the Karan dress — reposing undisturbed for more than two decades — it would be unassailable evidence of criminality, in corroboration with Ms. Carroll’s shocking written description of the events.

A justice-seeking Manhattan district attorney should be positioned to act, as New York may bring charges of forcible rape unconstrained by a crippling statue of limitations, which was eliminated years ago for such crimes in the Empire State.
One friend, who, like other Americans and me, is exasperated by powerful, above-the-law, serial sex offenders, wondered whether the Manhattan DA was smart enough to put it all together. I replied, “Smart enough, but uncorrupted enough is another matter.”
Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance, Jr.’s prosecutors, according to a Columbia University Law School report, prepared fraud charges against Ivanka Trump and Donald Trump, Jr. The father-like-son/daughter offspring were targeted for reported fraudulent condo-sales that involved their daddy’s Trump Soho project in 2012. After Trump lawyers contributed to Mr. Vance’s campaign, the pending charges against the Trump-lite duo vanished like a gambler’s lucky streak.
But if the Manhattan district attorney finds the strength to subpoena the Donna Karan garment, it could betray biological proof of Donald John Trump’s contact with the dress and end the exasperatingly criminal career of Teflon Don.
Robert Hill is a Pittsburgh-based communications consultant.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.