Here and there, in political reporting’s nooks and crannies, are theories that, given Kamala Harris’s strides, and Donald Trump’s stumbles, Democrats’ Harris-Walz presidential ticket could — could, maybe, might — capture Ohio in November.

That’s be­yond un­likely, even con­sid­er­ing the flak the Ohioan who’s Trump’s vice-pres­i­den­tial run­ning mate, Sen. JD Vance, a Cin­cin­nati Re­pub­li­can, and Mid­dle­town na­tive, has been draw­ing.

True, Har­ris and her run­ning mate Tim Walz have stoked enor­mous en­thu­si­asm na­tion­ally among Dem­o­crats, and Dem­o­crat-lean­ing in­de­pen­dents, who’d been ter­ri­fied that Biden’s demon­stra­ble weak­nesses would usher Trump back into the White House.

Pub­lic opin­ion sur­veys na­tion­wide sug­gest that — at least at the mo­ment a given poll was taken — the ticket is briskly com­pet­i­tive with, and in some in­stances, leads, Re­pub­li­cans’ Trump-Vance ticket.

Advertise with us

The key words are “at the mo­ment.”

70-odd days away

The elec­tion is 70-odd days away. And the Demo­cratic Na­tional Con­ven­tion could fin­ish up just as eas­ily il­lus­trat­ing Demo­cratic di­vi­sions — over, say, the Is­raeli-Pal­es­tin­ian war — as party unity.

It may be tell­ing, in­ci­den­tally, that Sen. Sher­rod Brown, a Cleve­land Dem­o­crat who’s be­ing chal­lenged for re-elec­tion this year by Re­pub­li­can Ber­nie Moreno, a Greater Cleve­land en­tre­pre­neur, won’t at­tend the Dem­o­crats’ Chi­cago con­ven­tion.

True, since World War II, Demo­cratic pres­i­den­tial nom­i­nees have car­ried Ohio in 1948, 1964, 1976, 1992, 1996, 2008, and 2012: Harry Tru­man, Lyn­don John­son, Jimmy Carter, and, twice each, Bill Clin­ton and Barack Obama.

Given this cam­paign year’s spe­cif­ics, and the likely close­ness of No­vem­ber’s na­tional tally, any Demo­cratic vic­tory in Ohio — again, how­ever un­likely — would al­most cer­tainly be as ra­zor-close as Harry Tru­man’s vic­to­ri­ous Ohio mar­gin in 1948, and Jimmy Carter’s in 1976.

Advertise with us

Tru­man and Carter

In 1948, Tru­man — who some­times seems like the last au­then­tic hu­man be­ing to have served as pres­i­dent — car­ried Ohio by only about 7,100 votes state­wide, best­ing GOP pres­i­den­tial nom­i­nee Tho­mas E. Dewey and Dewey’s vice-pres­i­den­tial run­ning mate, fu­ture Chief Justice Earl War­ren.

Tru­man car­ried a num­ber of Ohio’s Ap­pa­la­chian and Corn Belt coun­ties, and sub­ur­ban Cin­cin­nati’s But­ler County, JD Vance’s home county.

To­day, But­ler is so far to the right that one of its state sen­a­tors, West Chester Re­pub­li­can George F. Lang, drew world­wide at­ten­tion for say­ing last month at a Vance rally, “I’m afraid if we lose this one, it’s go­ing to take a civil war to save the coun­try.” After draw­ing sear­ing crit­i­cism, Lang said he re­gret­ted his re­marks. In any case, no way will the Har­ris-Walz ticket do what Harry Tru­man did.

As for Carter’s 1976 Ohio vic­tory, he car­ried the state by just slightly more than 11,000 votes over Re­pub­li­can Pres­i­dent Ger­ald R. Ford, in large part by win­ning Ap­pa­la­chian coun­ties that Demo­cratic pres­i­den­tial tick­ets sel­dom cap­tured.

Then-Ohio House Speaker Ver­nal G. Riffe, a Sci­oto County Dem­o­crat, later said he’d left the 1976 Demo­cratic Na­tional Con­ven­tion with a spring in his step be­cause he be­lieved Carter, with his South­ern and Bap­tist her­i­tage, would draw votes in parts of Ohio where Demo­cratic pres­i­den­tial can­di­dates had of­ten fal­tered.

Advertise with us

Once Carter’s, now Trump’s

Riffe was cor­rect: Carter car­ried a num­ber of Ohio’s Ap­pa­la­chian coun­ties, help­ing them clinch Ohio. Carter’s 1976 mar­gin in those coun­ties was about 12,700 votes, or 115% of his state­wide edge.

Now, though, con­sider what Don­ald Trump’s 2020 pres­i­den­tial vote share was in those pro-Carter Ap­pa­la­chian coun­ties: Perry, 74%; Hock­ing, 70%; Vin­ton, 77%; Meigs and Jack­son, 76% each; Pike 74%; Law­rence, 53%; Brown, 54%; Adams, 51%; and Sci­oto, 71%.

Is any­thing like that prob­a­ble in the Ohio of 2024? The an­swer is ob­vi­ous. That’s why the main goals of Ohio Dem­o­crats — to have any hope of best­ing Trump and Vance here — should be to boost voter turn­out among Black Ohio­ans (which Har­ris’ can­di­dacy will likely help) and in sub­ur­ban Ohio, es­pe­cially around boom­ing Co­lum­bus.

Short of that, Ohio will be this No­vem­ber what the state seems like it is to­day, if a bit less en­thu­si­as­ti­cally than in 2020: Trump Coun­try.

Tho­mas Sud­des is a mem­ber of the Cleve­land.com ed­i­to­rial board.