Here and there, in political reporting’s nooks and crannies, are theories that, given Kamala Harris’s strides, and Donald Trump’s stumbles, Democrats’ Harris-Walz presidential ticket could — could, maybe, might — capture Ohio in November.
That’s beyond unlikely, even considering the flak the Ohioan who’s Trump’s vice-presidential running mate, Sen. JD Vance, a Cincinnati Republican, and Middletown native, has been drawing.
True, Harris and her running mate Tim Walz have stoked enormous enthusiasm nationally among Democrats, and Democrat-leaning independents, who’d been terrified that Biden’s demonstrable weaknesses would usher Trump back into the White House.
Public opinion surveys nationwide suggest that — at least at the moment a given poll was taken — the ticket is briskly competitive with, and in some instances, leads, Republicans’ Trump-Vance ticket.
The key words are “at the moment.”
70-odd days away
The election is 70-odd days away. And the Democratic National Convention could finish up just as easily illustrating Democratic divisions — over, say, the Israeli-Palestinian war — as party unity.
Read More
It may be telling, incidentally, that Sen. Sherrod Brown, a Cleveland Democrat who’s being challenged for re-election this year by Republican Bernie Moreno, a Greater Cleveland entrepreneur, won’t attend the Democrats’ Chicago convention.
True, since World War II, Democratic presidential nominees have carried Ohio in 1948, 1964, 1976, 1992, 1996, 2008, and 2012: Harry Truman, Lyndon Johnson, Jimmy Carter, and, twice each, Bill Clinton and Barack Obama.
Given this campaign year’s specifics, and the likely closeness of November’s national tally, any Democratic victory in Ohio — again, however unlikely — would almost certainly be as razor-close as Harry Truman’s victorious Ohio margin in 1948, and Jimmy Carter’s in 1976.
Truman and Carter
In 1948, Truman — who sometimes seems like the last authentic human being to have served as president — carried Ohio by only about 7,100 votes statewide, besting GOP presidential nominee Thomas E. Dewey and Dewey’s vice-presidential running mate, future Chief Justice Earl Warren.
Truman carried a number of Ohio’s Appalachian and Corn Belt counties, and suburban Cincinnati’s Butler County, JD Vance’s home county.
Today, Butler is so far to the right that one of its state senators, West Chester Republican George F. Lang, drew worldwide attention for saying last month at a Vance rally, “I’m afraid if we lose this one, it’s going to take a civil war to save the country.” After drawing searing criticism, Lang said he regretted his remarks. In any case, no way will the Harris-Walz ticket do what Harry Truman did.
As for Carter’s 1976 Ohio victory, he carried the state by just slightly more than 11,000 votes over Republican President Gerald R. Ford, in large part by winning Appalachian counties that Democratic presidential tickets seldom captured.
Then-Ohio House Speaker Vernal G. Riffe, a Scioto County Democrat, later said he’d left the 1976 Democratic National Convention with a spring in his step because he believed Carter, with his Southern and Baptist heritage, would draw votes in parts of Ohio where Democratic presidential candidates had often faltered.
Once Carter’s, now Trump’s
Riffe was correct: Carter carried a number of Ohio’s Appalachian counties, helping them clinch Ohio. Carter’s 1976 margin in those counties was about 12,700 votes, or 115% of his statewide edge.
Now, though, consider what Donald Trump’s 2020 presidential vote share was in those pro-Carter Appalachian counties: Perry, 74%; Hocking, 70%; Vinton, 77%; Meigs and Jackson, 76% each; Pike 74%; Lawrence, 53%; Brown, 54%; Adams, 51%; and Scioto, 71%.
Is anything like that probable in the Ohio of 2024? The answer is obvious. That’s why the main goals of Ohio Democrats — to have any hope of besting Trump and Vance here — should be to boost voter turnout among Black Ohioans (which Harris’ candidacy will likely help) and in suburban Ohio, especially around booming Columbus.
Short of that, Ohio will be this November what the state seems like it is today, if a bit less enthusiastically than in 2020: Trump Country.
Thomas Suddes is a member of the Cleveland.com editorial board.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.