A psychotherapist could have a field day with the last month of America’s presidential election. From fixation on Ohio Sen. JD Vance’s past remarks about “childless cat ladies” — followed by inquiries into his own relationship with his children — to anointing Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz as “America’s Midwestern dad,” anxieties about parents, parenting and their political meaning have come to dominate discourse about the 2024 campaign.
In fact, it’s increasingly clear that many American voters are looking for surrogate parents in their political leaders. And they’re seeing in the candidates, or projecting onto them, the qualities they admire or deplore in their own parents, and in parents generally.
In a moment of high anxiety about the future of democracy, it’s a remarkable reversion to non-democratic political psychology: the leader as the father (or mother) of the nation, offering not just leadership but nurturing, affection and psychological stability. And it’s symptomatic of a society where families and communities have frayed — especially the bonds of mutual affection that are meant to tie one generation to the next — leaving politics to fill the void.
Surrogate fatherhood
Mr. Walz’s meticulously curated image as a cool, caring and competent Minnesota dad has become a staple of Democratic messaging, especially on social media. This has prompted innumerable memes, commentaries and fantasies that portray Mr. Walz as something like a Midwestern Andy Griffith meets MacGyver, adept at fixing and optimizing all manner of contraptions — and people.
Eight years ago, the comedian John Oliver referred to Virginia senator and vice-presidential nominee Tim Kaine as “America’s stepdad,” but that was a one-off tongue-in-cheek gag. The Walz phenomenon is far more pervasive, and far more politically and emotionally resonant. Mr. Walz isn’t just a humorous representation of modern Midwestern fatherhood: He’s the dad many Americans wish they had.
For instance, one of the most popular posts on X (it’s been viewed by nearly 10 million people) describing liberal Walz-mania connects it directly to the “loss” many adult children with left-of-center views have felt as their own fathers embraced Mr. Trump. This has led to further meta-commentaries arguing whether this phenomenon, which is undoubtedly real, represents fathers generally breaking with their grown children, or grown children breaking with their fathers.
Read More
It’s clear that the political psychodramas that have unfolded in millions of American families are now merging with the national political drama. And that’s only further raising the emotional and political stakes of this election.
Take the remarkably hostile treatment of Mr. Vance, which has gone much deeper than questioning his policies or even his principles: It has questioned his parenting.
Now, Mr. Vance’s willingness to deploy family structure in a politically aggressive way — “childless cat ladies,” fanciful proposals to reward parents with extra votes, and so on — have clearly made him vulnerable. But his fixation on family itself only further demonstrates the merger of the personal and the political.
Leaders and parents
The best example of this was the apoplectic reaction to a clip of Mr. Vance describing the phone call during which Mr. Trump offered him the running-mate job. In this particular telling he said, in what was clearly a glib exaggeration, that when his 6-year-old son interrupted the Trump call he responded, “Shut the hell up, kid.”
This generated waves of aggrieved suggestions that Mr. Vance is a cruel and possibly abusive father. Besides revealing what is to me a very odd theory of parenting — children do not have the right to interrupt adult conversations — this reaction also demonstrated just how many adults identified with the little boy and not with the parent.
Mr. Vance’s apparent failure to be a nurturing father represented his failure to be a nurturing political leader.
This is a stunningly paternalistic view of political leadership, and one that’s ultimately incompatible with a free society. A people that wants to be parented by its leaders, rather than simply led by them, has given up on democracy.
That’s because democracy is about more than elections and procedures. It requires, as liberals of previous centuries argued over and over, certain political habits and virtues that can’t be legislated or regulated, but can only be developed in organic human communities. In other words, democracy requires a substrate of civil society that gives citizens what politics cannot: nurturing, rootedness, meaning, purpose.
Political paternalism
When civil society has atrophied to the point that a critical mass of citizens are explicitly seeking their politicians to fill the role of parents, who fix all their problems and tell them everything will be alright, the habit of democracy has already been lost. The only question is what brand of political paternalism, gentle or strict, will replace it.
Maybe Tim Walz really is every bit the perfect Midwestern dad his communications staff has concocted. Maybe he really could change your tire while talking you through your breakup. Maybe he really could grill a brat while teaching you the nickel package.
Maybe he could. But he won’t. Because you’re not his child, but a citizen. Until you’re a subject.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “From globetrotting to navel-gazing: The weird alliance that beat Bill Peduto is smothering Pittsburgh.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.