My friend Holly likes to say, “Voting is not getting married. Voting is catching a bus.” I’ve been thinking about that all year, and about how it applies to the 2024 election.

When you catch a bus, you don’t control where the bus goes. The transit company decided that. You don’t get to pick the ride you’d like. All you can do is pick the right bus out of a few bad choices.

What’s the right bus? It’s the bus that goes closest to your house. It wouldn’t make any sense to refuse to get on any bus and walk all the way home — or to throw a tantrum and get on the worst possible bus, and end up further from home than ever.

At the bus stop

Being in America before a big election often feels like sitting at a bus stop with eight other people.

Advertise with us

Two of them are normal folks who know which bus to take because it’s the one that gets them the closest to home. Two of them are weirdos who are determined to hold the bus driver hostage, force him to drive you to the worst neighborhood in town, and strand you at a bedbug-infested hotel with lurid stains on the ceiling and no smoke alarms.

Two more keep politely shrugging their shoulders and saying they don’t pay attention to buses and don’t really know whether the bus’s destination makes a difference. And the last two aren’t going to get on a bus at all.

Here in my hometown of Steubenville, Ohio, just under an hour from the heart of Pittsburgh, it’s easy to feel that which bus I get on doesn’t matter. We’re not a great big city in a swing state like Pittsburgh is. We’re a small city amid some tiny towns on the eastern edge of a red state. But we’re like a lot of cities and towns in America and how people here feel about politics may say something about places other than eastern Ohio.

Still, this year, I get two chances to catch a bus instead of just one. Steubenville is in the middle of Ohio’s sixth congressional district, which runs from Youngstown all the way south to Belpre, about 90 miles southwest of Wheeling.

The district had a special election on June 11 to replace the former member of Congress, who resigned to become a university president, for a few months. We’ll get to vote again in November for that seat in the House, as well as a senator and a president.

Advertise with us

But first we got to be the center of attention in June. District Six is considered a safe Republican district, but with a small possibility of flipping. The election was seen as a hint to what will happen in November in Ohio and the parts of the country like us.

The Republican won, but by only 10 percentage points, rather than the 35 the previous incumbent got. Even the winner downplayed the effect of party and explained his election by saying he is “really good at retail politics.” He told the AP: “This is a blue-collar district. This is Bruce Springsteen, the forgotten man, ‘Joe Bag of Donuts.’ They don’t trust the Democrats and Republicans, and they look at the individual.”

Turnout was low, but maybe people weren’t paying attention to the special election and will come out with bells on in in November. But they might not.

Less zeal for Trump

I must say I’m a little surprised at the lack of enthusiasm all over this part of the state, considering that this is an election year. I have learned to measure my neighbors’ zeal for candidates by counting the signs in their yards. It’s more reliable than you’d think.

In 2016, I was already seeing signs supporting Trump dotting the neighborhood at this point in the year. He didn’t have a running mate yet, so one neighbor found a photo of him holding a baby to put on her porch.

Advertise with us

In 2020, there were signs all over town promoting Trump, starting as early as April. By summer, we had even more eye-catching displays: people drove around with enormous flags praising Trump fluttering in the backs of their pickup trucks. I was always afraid one was going to fall off and hit the windshield of the guy behind them.

There’s nothing like that kind of support just yet. A few people even still have their DeSantis signs out, as if they’re ashamed of the bus they ended up catching in the primary.

Another thing that has surprised me is the support for Robert Kennedy’s third-party candidacy. I’ve started counting those yard signs, which tend to pop up in the wealthier neighborhoods.

I would have been surprised to see even one Kennedy sign in those parts of town, since it’s been assumed he’d attract Democrats and leach votes from their candidate. But in 2020, the conservatives in town were vocally anxious about the race to develop COVID vaccines, and I wonder if the vaccine conspiracy theorist Kennedy might now be hurting the Republicans here.

Does this mean I think that Steubenville and the small towns up and down the Ohio are suddenly going to flip blue? No, but they may become less red, and that may be the beginning of a longterm change. Is this a barometer for Republican enthusiasm all over the country? It could be, as Republican as this area is, because that Republicanism may not go as deep as it seems.

Advertise with us

One reliable place to get information about local politics is the comment sections on the news. I don’t trust the local TV news stories themselves when they report on politics. But scroll down the page and you find people excited to give their opinion. Often, the commentators get riled up and there’s a brawl.

Anemic support

One thing the comment section tells me is that whenever something goes wrong in this part of Northern Appalachia, most people blame the Democrats. I don’t expect that to change any time soon.

Still, the support for the Republican party seems a bit anemic in this blood-red district. It’s not that people don’t comment “Vote for Trump” anymore, it’s all the laugh-reactions those comments get, and the people who show up in the replies arguing back. You didn’t used to get that around here.

So, what bus is my home city and district going to catch this year? Probaby the red one. In 2020, Donald Trump won the counties that make up the district with three-quarters of the vote.

Kamala Harris may be a little more popular than Biden, because of her enthusiastic charisma, or a little less popular, because my practical Appalachian neighbors find her enthusiasm annoying. Down-to-Earth Walz may play well among Appalachians, who certainly resent the snooty fake hillbilly Vance. But will that make enough of a difference?

Advertise with us

What bus will the country catch? I don’t know. I do know that there will be just two buses (and maybe a few small vans) and they’ll follow their route, and that neither is going to take me all the way home.

Mary Pezzulo is a writer in Steubenville, Ohio.