Since the pop­u­list surge that gave us Brexit and the rise of Don­ald Trump, pol­i­tics in the Western world has po­lar­ized into a dis­tinc­tive stale­mate — an in­con­clu­sive strug­gle be­tween a cre­den­tialed elite that keeps fail­ing at ba­sic tasks of gov­ern­ing and a pop­u­list re­bel­lion that’s too cha­otic and par­a­noid to be trusted with au­thor­ity in­stead.

The 2024 cam­paign in its wan­ing days is a grim il­lus­tra­tion of this dead­lock. We watched Kamala Har­ris, the av­a­tar of the lib­eral es­tab­lish­ment, smoothly out-de­bate Trump by goad­ing him into ex­press­ing pop­u­lism at its worst — griev­ance-ob­sessed, dem­a­gogic, na­kedly un­fit.

But her smooth­ness was it­self an eva­sion of the ac­tual record of the ad­min­is­tra­tion in which she serves.

Side­step­ping Har­ris

Har­ris of­fered her­self as the turn-the-page can­di­date while side­step­ping al­most ev­ery ques­tion about what the sup­posed adults in the room have wrought across the last four years.

Advertise with us

A his­toric surge in mi­gra­tion that hap­pened with­out any kind of leg­is­la­tion or de­bate. A his­toric surge in in­fla­tion that was caused by the pan­demic but al­most cer­tainly goosed by Biden ad­min­is­tra­tion def­i­cits.

A mis­man­aged with­drawal from Af­ghan­istan. A stale­mated proxy war in Eastern Europe with a loom­ing threat of es­ca­la­tion. An elite lurch into woke rad­i­cal­ism that had real-world as well as ivory-tower con­se­quences, in the form of bad pro­gres­sive pol­i­cy­mak­ing on crime and drugs and schools.

All of this and more the Har­ris cam­paign hopes that vot­ers for­give or just for­get while it claims the man­tle of change and in­sists that “we’re not go­ing back.”

Un­de­cided vot­ers in a po­lar­ized Amer­ica gen­er­ate a lot of ex­as­per­ated crit­i­cism from both sides of the par­ti­san di­vide. And no doubt it will ex­as­per­ate many read­ers when I sug­gest that the choices pre­sented in this elec­tion make in­de­ci­sion en­tirely un­der­stand­able.

But they re­ally do. The “ask” of the Demo­cratic Party in 2024 is not, as some anti-Trump writ­ers would have it, to merely com­pro­mise one’s con­vic­tions on this is­sue or that is­sue, to ac­cept a few pol­i­cies you dis­like in or­der to keep an in­de­cent and un­sta­ble pop­u­list out of of­fice.

Advertise with us

Rather, the “ask” is to rat­ify a record of sub­stan­tial pol­icy fail­ure and con­spic­u­ous ide­o­log­i­cal fa­nat­i­cism, dressed up for the mo­ment in a thin prom­ise that we won’t make those mis­takes again.

This is the con­stant pat­tern of the Western elite over the last gen­er­a­tion. A form of ag­gres­sive group­think takes hold among the best and bright­est, ide­ol­ogy gets laun­dered into sup­posed ex­per­tise or con­sen­sus, and the re­sult is post-9/​11 de­ba­cles in Iraq and Af­ghan­istan and Libya … or Da­vos-man na­iveté about the down­sides of glo­bal­iza­tion and the rise of China.

Or Euro­crat my­o­pia about the wis­dom of a com­mon cur­rency, the man­age­abil­ity of mass mi­gra­tion and the true cost of Rus­sian en­ergy … or the re­cent phase of pro­gres­sive ma­nia that closed schools, le­gal­ized hard drugs, wrecked ed­u­ca­tional stan­dards and warped cur­ric­ula, li­censed du­bi­ous med­i­cal ex­per­i­ments in the name of trans­gen­der rights and turned the U.S. im­mi­gra­tion sys­tem into a di­sas­ter area.

Un­fit Trump

Then the bill comes due; the elites back­pedal and ob­fus­cate and con­ve­niently for­get. (What do you mean, Kamala Har­ris en­dorsed pub­licly funded gen­der re­as­sign­ment sur­gery for il­le­gal aliens? Sounds like Fox News non­sense!).

The un­happy swing voter is in­formed that no real price can be ex­acted for any of this folly, be­cause the pop­u­list al­ter­na­tive isn’t fit for power.

Advertise with us

And, sure enough, the great leader of Amer­i­can pop­u­lism is cur­rently hang­ing out with far-right-in­flu­encer Laura Loomer, who’s so man­i­festly big­oted and con­spir­a­to­rial that she gives other far-right in­flu­encers hives. He’s cur­rently lit­i­gat­ing the Biden-Har­ris im­mi­gra­tion record via Face­book ru­mors and anti-Hai­tian an­i­mus.

His smart­est sup­port­ers prem­ise their loy­alty on the idea that he’s a huge BS art­ist who prob­a­bly won’t ac­tu­ally fol­low through on all his prom­ises, even as his most de­vout sup­port­ers stand ready to ex­cuse ex­cess, cor­rup­tion and con­sti­tu­tional brink­man­ship.

But this un­fit man was al­ready pres­i­dent for four years, and for three of them, his per­sonal chaos co­ex­isted with de­cent out­comes in are­nas — for­eign pol­icy, in­fla­tion and im­mi­gra­tion — where things have been much worse un­der the rule of the se­ri­ous peo­ple, the good mer­i­to­crats, the smooth and re­spect­able elites.

And even when COVID over­mas­tered his ad­min­is­tra­tion, his flail­ing was matched by pro­gres­siv­ism’s pe­riod of ma­nia, and his White House still man­aged to keep the mid­dle class sol­vent and the stock mar­ket high, and de­liv­ered a COVID vac­cine faster than al­most any­one ex­pected.

A close elec­tion

All of this is more than enough to ex­plain why this elec­tion is close and why vot­ers might not rub­ber-stamp the sud­den trans­for­ma­tion of Har­ris, ap­pa­ra­tchik of pro­gres­siv­ism, into Har­ris, steady hand and rea­son­able mod­er­ate.

Advertise with us

To the un­de­cided voter, this isn’t a sim­ple choice be­tween sta­bil­ity and peril. It’s a choice be­tween two can­di­dates and co­a­li­tions that for dif­fer­ent rea­sons don’t merit pub­lic con­fi­dence.

And in a de­moc­racy, if you keep of­fer­ing vot­ers two bad op­tions, you shouldn’t be sur­prised that they will of­ten choose the one you are sure is worse.

Ross Douthat is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “Why Donald Trump will win.”