How would you define a political party whose platform: supports regenerative farming practices and opposed gmo crops and confined animal operations (factory farming); calls for a living wage and family leave; insists job-creation and investment in critical infrastructure “must be a federal priority”; calls for adequate funding for public schools, free four-year community colleges, and student debt relief;.

And further, declares that “no one who needs a medicine or treatment prescribed by a doctor should be denied such due to their personal financial limitations”; wants corporations to pay their fair share of taxes; and believes that “each woman should have the right to decide [on abortion] based on her own conscience.”

And at the same time the platform: calls for a balanced federal budget; holds to a strict reading of the Tenth Amendment and federalism; supports families’ right to alternative schooling; speaks of mitigating “the possible effects of climate change”; calls “protecting our  borders” a federal duty; supports right-to-work laws; and supports “the right of citizens to own and to carry firearms for personal defense and for sport.”

A unique political party

It’s an unexpected mixture of left and right, as far as I know unique among organized American political parties. The party is in fact by several decades the oldest third party in America, having been formed in 1869.

Advertise with us

It is called, and I don’t think many of you will have seen this coming (I wouldn’t have), the Prohibition Party. Not surprisingly, the section on “alcohol, tobacco, and recreational drug abuse” is by far the longest in their platform and says what you’d expect.

This year, most Americans who care a lot about politics strongly support one candidate or the other, and tend to despise the one they don’t support. As I wrote a couple months ago, the only kind of swing voter that makes sense in this elec­tion isn’t one who hasn’t chosen a candidate. It’s one who’s wa­ver­ing be­tween vot­ing for his pre­ferred can­di­date and not vot­ing or voting for a third party.

So what about third parties? The one we know from recent elections is that they don’t change anything in the national races. Democrats currently fret that independent candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. will take votes from Biden, though some political experts think he’ll take more votes from Trump, which makes more sense to me.

How the third parties did in Pa.

In Pennsylvania, in 2020, the Libertarian party, the only third party on the ballot, took 1.1% of the vote. That wasn’t quite enough to give Trump the state, even if they all voted for him. Which they wouldn’t, as they seem to think both parties inadequately committed to freedom, if in different ways. Forced to vote at gunpoint, some would vote for the Democrat and some for the Republican, depending on which liberties they held most dear.

In 2016 we had the Libertarians, who took 2.38% of the vote, and the Greens (.81%) and Constitution (.35%) parties as well. Even though Trump beat Clinton by just .72% of the vote, I don’t think these parties made a difference.

Advertise with us

The Greens represent that part of the left that thinks the Democrats and Republicans are on the same side, the Constitutionists represented disgruntled conservatives who didn’t like Trump, and the Libertarians would have voted as I described. Many of these voters wouldn’t have voted at all without their third party.

There’s a reason almost third party remains a very marginal third party (or to be accurate a fourth or fifth or twentieth party). They only work when they represent clear and strong existing interests, recognizable economic interests especially, not just ideas.

For example, England’s Labour party succeeded a century ago in overcoming the Liberal party because it focussed the working class’s interests in better wages, protection from exploitative employers , etc., in the political party they needed. The typical American third party, a group of people who just don’t fit in either party and gather around shared beliefs, doesn’t represent the real interests from which viable political parties arise.

I appreciate the Prohibition party’s political eccentricity, but it’s never going to get anywhere. The odds are much against the Libertarians, the Greens and all the others getting anywhere either.

Third party or main party?

There are two possibilities for those who vote: You believe you must vote for a candidate you really can support, however little chance he has of winning, in the hope of promoting a different kind of politics or (playing the long game) building a new party, or simply witnessing to a different way of thinking. Or you believe you must vote for one of the two candidates who can be elected, if only to keep the other candidate out.

Advertise with us

The people who think the first have a reasonable and principled position. I don’t blame them for following their conscience and voting that way. We need more people who live by their principles and say no to the system. And maybe if enough vote that way, they will force the major parties to change a little.

I think the second, though, for now, because we have to do what good we can in the world and prevent what evil we can, even if the choices are bad. The difference between the candidates may be small, you may intensely dislike your own candidate, but even small differences in a country as big as ours can make big differences in human happiness.

David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “How much is Caitlin Clark worth?”.