Free parking isn’t the way to revitalize Downtown. The Downtown Neighbors Alliance hopes doing that will encourage more shoppers and diners to patronize downtown establishments. John Valentine, the Alliance’s executive director, cites a survey indicating the two main barriers to potential customers are crime and the cost of parking.

The pandemic took a dramatic toll on every downtown, and Pittsburgh is no exception. Though the numbers are rising, not enough people are coming to work or visiting to sustain the businesses and other enterprises the downtown needs to flourish.

There are better approaches to getting more people to come Downtown than simply offering “free” parking. I write as a former president of the International Downtown Association who has served on three local expert advisory panels and a parking consultant for cities in the US and Canada.

First, there is no such thing as “free parking.” Someone must build parking structures, pave streets, provide lighting, remove snow, and manage the use of parking spaces. The Alliance plan acknowledges this, and proposes sharing these costs between the Public Parking Authority, the merchants and the Alliance, which, I presume, will solicit additional support from its members.

Advertise with us

Second, as one parking expert said, “No one comes downtown because it’s a great place to park.” If downtown wants to compete effectively with suburban malls, it must do so by offering a superior experience, and that means not just better goods, but a more enjoyable time.

Downtown should be a place where something is always happening. Baltimore’s Downtown Partnership created a Cappella quartets composed of BID (Business Improvement District) ambassadors with singing experience. My first day in Downtown D.C. began when I exited the Farragut North Metro station and was greeted by an elderly gentleman playing a saxophone. I felt like I was a cast member in a movie.

Third, if Downtown wants to attract new customers or persuade former customers to return, if must understand the implications of the “She-conomy.” Women make or influence more than 80% of retail and dining decisions, residential decisions, and healthcare decisions.

In 2018, a survey of more than 130 prominent women leaders asked what they hated most about coming downtown. By a large majority, their answer was “parking.” How can a downtown improve parking? The answer is to do more than just make it free.

Some women were very specific in their criticism. Many cited parking garages as their number one complaint. One woman called garages “dull, dirty, dark and dangerous.” Garage attendants should be visible, trained in customer service, and equipped with backpacks or fannypacks with maps, event schedules, special promotions.

Advertise with us

But the experience begins with well-designed way-finding and signage programs. Drivers should know where the parking garages and lots are and how to get to them.

Finding a place to park on the street was also frequently mentioned. Fear of being ticketed or towed and dealing with multi-space meters merited lots of criticisms. Women found the lenses on parking meters impossible to read because of glare, and instructions that were confusing at best.

Pay-by-credit card and pay-by-phone eliminated the need to carry purses or pockets full of quarters, but the electronic payment programs can be annoying when they simply don’t work. Suppose you’ve driven around for 20 minutes and finally found a spot, and then the meter doesn’t work? Risk a ticket, or give up that precious space? The Parking Authority must make sure their system works, which requires continual monitoring, and a way for visitors to report when it doesn't work.

The Parking Authority should change its policies regarding enforcement. One small, easy improvement would change parking violation tickets to “invoices.” That doesn’t imply someone has broken the law, but that they just used a bit more time.

One other big complaint women expressed about downtowns was the lack of clean, safe public restrooms. Women often are accompanied by children or elderly parents and relatives. And it’s a truism that kids and old folks need to use the bathroom more frequently than your average adult. Bryant Park in New York City seems to have solved this problem with remarkable restrooms, and that is one reason the park and the businesses around it have thrived.

Advertise with us

The answer to the problem of Pittsburgh’s Downtown not getting enough visitors is not to give away parking. The answer is to understand better the needs and concerns of downtown’s most important demographic — women — and design experiences that provide safe, welcoming, and exciting environments for women.

Free parking may be a gimmick that works for short time, but the real answer for reviving downtown is creating enjoyable, memorable experiences, and doing so with women in mind. If these efforts are successful, men will follow.

David M. Feehan, a former Pittsburgh resident, is author of the textbook “Making Business Districts Work” and co-author of “Design Downtown for Women — Men Will Follow.”