Pittsburgh is a safe city and Downtown is even safer.
You wouldn’t think so by reading and hearing all the hype on dangers Downtown, and perceptions can become reality. If people avoid the Cultural District because they’re afraid of getting hassled, robbed or assaulted, then local businesses, theaters, halls and landlords will suffer.
So far, the restaurants and businesses I patronize in the Cultural District tell me business is good and getting better. Sidewalks are jammed. I’ve had to push through crowds around Heinz Hall, Theater Square, the Benedum Center, August Wilson African American Cultural Center, or headed to Con Alma for drinks and jazz or any of the other densely interconnected restaurants, shops and cultural attractions.
Most of these people, I’m sure, feel safe. And they should. Downtowns nationwide are generally safe. People in poor neighborhoods might wait for more than an hour after calling 911, but downtowns are typically locked down.
A city website tracking violence in Pittsburgh reports that only one of the city’s 51 homicides in 2021 occurred in the so-called Golden Triangle, the downtown and central business districts. Only two of the city’s 179 non-fatal shoots occurred there. On both counts, that’s less than 2%. (Totals for 2022, when 71 homicides occurred citywide, aren’t yet posted.)
“Safe” is a relative adjective, and downtown Pittsburgh does appear rowdier and riskier these days. Downtown landlords worry about losing tenants (like me). Still, I’ve never felt shaky anywhere in Pittsburgh, even walking a mile home from work every night, often near midnight, down West General Robinson and over the Ninth Street Bridge.
Read More
I have a concealed-carry license and a Kimber 9mm semi-automatic handgun, but I’ve never packed in Pittsburgh. I don’t feel the need. There’s even a certain warmth downtown that you don’t find in, say, Edgeworth or Bradford Woods. A stranger might call you “brother” or tell you to “be blessed.”
Unreasonable fears
Cities everywhere trigger unreasonable fears — and, no doubt, some reasonable ones, too. Some people in suburban Detroit won’t set foot in the city, even now, when downtown Detroit is as safe as any suburb. Heading down the Lodge Freeway to watch the Tigers or Lions, drivers would rather stay stuck in traffic than veer off the freeway and take a side street. Maybe they think rooftop snipers are waiting to pick them off.
Part of the unease people feel in cities — I’m not saying all of it — stems from mixing with people unlike themselves. Homeless people and panhandlers are generally harmless, but they put some people on edge. In my decades as an urban dweller, I’ve gotten hit up by thousands of panhandlers. A few were aggressive but none have threatened or menaced me. Some of the terrifying lack of empathy in our country stems from people insulating themselves from people who don’t look, talk or act like them. But all of us must share the diversity of public spaces, and that’s a good thing.
To quell rising fears, Allegheny County police officers might be deployed downtown. This week, Mayor Ed Gainey proposed tripling the number of city cops there. In addition, unarmed “public safety ambassadors,” he said, will help with “non-criminal nuisances.” But the police department is already understaffed. With violent crime rising elsewhere in Pittsburgh, diverting more cops downtown might not be wise.
Don’t stay away
That’s not to minimize the pain people feel when they’re robbed, assaulted or even hassled downtown. We all see the wide world through the narrow lens of our personal experience. When bad things happen to us, the statistics and big picture don’t matter. Still, consider the vast multitude of people, interactions and encounters in downtown every day. Compare that to the number of bad experiences. People are more likely to get hurt driving downtown than being downtown.
It’s hard to separate imaginary fears from legitimate ones. I spent six weeks in Ukraine last spring. Photographer Stephen Zenner and I avoided combat zones and, even with air raid sirens wailing every night, I never felt endangered. If I hadn’t gone, I would have missed a great experience.
Pittsburgh is a relatively small city, but it offers an extraordinary number of diverse cultural and entertainment venues. Don’t let inflated fears keep you away.
Pulitzer Prize winner Jeffery Gerritt is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.