I am in downtown Pittsburgh several times a week, in the cultural district. People are concerned, some scared, and many fed up.
I spoke with a merchant this week. I asked him if it is getting any better. "Better?" he asked.
Yeah, safer, more secure? Is there more police presence? "You see them sometimes," he said. "Then you don't see them."
So far, not much seems to have changed.
The violence and disruption of recent months hovers over downtown like bad dreams and no one seems to feel we are waking yet.The cops lack both clear direction and adequate numbers.
The homeless seem to be multiplying. A new shelter is full though it has just opened. And though fledgling efforts to address the mental health crisis where it now is most acute — the streets — are being made, it seems like way too little, too late.
Read More
One has the sense of a complex and multifaceted problem — guns, crime, youth violence, homelessness, mental health — outpacing the ability of city leaders to comprehend it, let alone deal with it.
A downtown lawyer tells the same story so many other professionals in downtown tell: Employees, especially females, are followed, hassled and accosted. More and more employees are attempting to adapt by parking closer or staying in for lunch. And almost every employer downtown has difficulty hiring and retaining employees.
The merchant I mentioned said: "I say a prayer when I come to work and another prayer when I leave. I want to get my son through college. Then I'm done. I don't want to do this any more."
Not a healthy human situation. And surely not a good sign for social life downtown or an increased residential presence.
How do we respond without hysteria but also without the usual denial and lethargy?
Well, first, we have to be honest and admit the scope and depth of the problem. Mayor Ed Gainey is doing that, and several members of City Council are, too. But they are going to need help.
Yes, we need more cops. As Mr. Gainey says, that's easier said than done. You have to recruit them and you have to train them. But then you have to empower them. The police have to know that they can arrest people and those same people will not be back on the street tomorrow.
That's all hard, hard as hell, to implement. But it is remedial.
Beyond safety, we must tackle mental health. Even tougher.
One way would be to help downtown churches with their outreach programs. And one small, practical way to do that would be to create two or three adult day centers where underhoused and homeless people could find shelter, a hot cup of coffee, counseling if they want it, and centralized direction toward housing and job programs and counseling.
The problems downtown, at root, are ones of mental health, housing and joblessness. But much of the current population is not currently employable. They need both healing and training.
That makes housing problematic. An apartment in the suburbs is not the answer. A "tiny house" might be, one day. A group home can be. A shelter cannot be forever.
Many American cities are in trouble right now. Crime is up everywhere. Youth gun violence has increased markedly since the pandemic. Homelessness is an epidemic in some cities.
Our cities are simmering. And our response must be calm, intelligent and comprehensive.
Hunkering down in the burbs is not an option. Neither is denial.
Our cities are bearing the brunt of several national problems: poverty programs that are abandoned before they are really tried, or that are chronically underfunded, or that infantilize; a housing shortage of as many of six million units and average rents that make people poor; the gun contagion; the mental health crisis.
Nevertheless cities cannot wait for the perfect storm to gather. Pittsburgh cannot let the downtown problem get worse.
We have to invest in the police and help them, even as we hold them to high standards. We should help the churches, for they walk with the poor. Our foundations have the wherewithal to do that.
We have to give the poor and people living rough on the streets, places to be; penultimately, places to work; and, ultimately, hope.
Again, much, much easier said than done. But we must begin. And, as with any human crisis or natural disaster, one step at a time.
As we move the ground rules must be: Admit the scope of our problems; admit the interrelatedness and complexity of our problems; don't let the scope or complexity keep us from taking small, practical steps. Innovate; don't demonize. And don't be discouraged. Keep at it.
Our cities cradle our culture and drive our economy. We have to not only save them but renew them.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (burriscolumn@gmail.com). His previous article was “We need to 'Agnew' Donald Trump.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.