Pittsburgh Public Schools police officers could soon sport body-worn cameras in the hallways of city schools.
School directors during a committee meeting Monday considered a new policy that would allow the cameras while also discussing usage guidelines and which situations ould call for recording in school settings.
“We know in the past students recorded everything anyways,” Superintendent Wayne Walters said after the meeting. “Anytime an issue came up, students recorded it. That is a part of the culture now to record and have evidence of what actually happened.”
Chief of School Safety Dena Young developed the idea for the policy. No specific incident sparked the request, Deputy Superintendent Theodore Thompson said after the meeting.
A similar proposal was pitched two years ago, without gaining much traction. School leaders chose to revisit the idea as they brainstormed additional tools officers could need.
December would be the earliest the board could vote on the policy.
Read More
The policy is intended to document law enforcement and school safety interactions, support investigations and court proceedings, present evidence, enhance officer and student safety, promote accountability and transparency and protect privacy of students, staff and safety.
The current iteration of the policy states that when situations are safe and practicable, officers should inform those involved in the interactions that it is being recorded.
Officers would be required to record in cases of arrests, foot pursuits, significant school safety incidents and officer use-of-force or critical incidents.
And there are times when recording could be left to an officer’s discretion, including if they feel it would be necessary for significant public safety, investigative, evidentiary or accountability purposes.
The document also acknowledges that school environments require heightened attention to student privacy. Given that, cameras would not convert ordinary school disciplinary matters into a law enforcement investigation, the policy states.
Officers would use the least intrusive recording method reasonably necessary, and would be required to use judgment when recording school-age children and when interacting with a student experiencing a behavioral health crisis or medical emergency.
If approved, officials would apply for a Pennsylvania Commission on Crime and Delinquency grant to pay for the cameras.
Several in Monday’s meeting raised a slew of concerns over the potential.
Director Yael Silk pointed to language she said is “difficult to consistently interpret,” including the activation section, which states cameras will be turned on “when reasonably safe and practicable.”
Assistant Chief of School Police Michael Boback suggested that during a fight or physical altercation, making it clear to involved parties that cameras are on may not be possible. But when engaging with the public or a student, officers could state they are recording.
Silk asked that examples be added to the policy for clarity.
Director Devon Taliaferro said among her main concerns were student privacy and the protection of their rights. Still, she noted that cameras could help support students during incidents when their rights might be challenged.
“It makes them able to kind of have a little bit of justice in that area,” Taliaferro said. She also urged the board not to “rush out and buy body-worn cameras.”
Instead, she encouraged the public to comment on and question the document.
“I think that’s really important is making sure that anything that we do,” Taliaferro said, “related to student and police interaction, that we’re protecting our students at all costs.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.