For many years, in defiance of national trends, our Downtown church has kept its doors open throughout the day.
When the Vatican-educated head of a nonprofit called Partners for Sacred Places visited First Presbyterian Church of Pittsburgh a few years ago, our unchained doors and warm, well-lit sanctuary moved him to tears. It was indeed a “sanctuary” for anyone who entered, and many did, workers and wanderers, every day.
Two weeks ago, we put an abrupt end to this practice. What tipped the scales was a crazed assault on one of our employees, who was simply asking people to leave, as usual, at 4 p.m.
Our closure is temporary, until new security arrangements are in place. Like businesses and individuals throughout the city, escalating crime — whether brazen or deranged — is reshaping our behavior and budgets.
The heightened potential of criminal activity is not limited to the city. Tragic shootings happen at suburban big-box stores, schools and malls all over the country. As a city-dweller who regularly runs errands in the suburbs, I see a new, post-pandemic level of anger and aggression that keeps me on alert.
But the concentration of desperate, often drug-addled vagrants Downtown increases the likelihood of crime and spikes everyone’s tension levels.
Read More
I know to avoid eye contact and to ignore a stranger’s approach — or appear to ignore it, while staying aware of any suspicious movement in my peripheral vision. It’s a sad way to walk this beloved city’s streets.
It isn’t just me. My husband Andy is a big guy. In fact, that’s what others used to call him as he walked from his Heinz Hall workplace to our Deutschtown home. “Hi, big guy” was the salutation of late-night regulars he passed in the Allegheny Commons along Cedar Avenue — site of last October’s mass shooting and triple homicide.
The night-time walks ceased a few years ago, but just days after the attack at our church, Andy was accosted as he crossed the Cultural District’s Katz Plaza.
With the dramatic Louise Bourgeois fountain and “eyeball” seats, the plaza is where throngs of people wait for buses throughout the day, but it’s also where a throng of drug dealers and users has been carousing ‘round the clock. It was one of them who approached Andy and hissed, “Hey, what are you lookin’ at?” The menacing continued as Andy walked on.
Last Monday we noticed half the plaza is now chained off, preventing the mass loitering. And Monday was when dear friends told me their son, who works Downtown, urged them not to walk anywhere except to and from their car when they attend a city venue.
Such anecdotes bode ill for the health of the city and its most crucial institutions.
In fact, I think civilization itself is at stake. We are more than just machines that eat and work. The art we create and take part in is absolutely essential, and the arts we can enjoy only in group settings are the most vulnerable.
Churches like mine are also works of art; the worship is art; and the ministries we provide are critical to the well-being, ironically, of those who sometimes seem to threaten them. If some are a “threat,” though, it is to a certain extent our fault.
Chronically homeless people invariably struggle with mental illness and/or substance abuse. As a society we choose to ignore the causes, preferring to address the results by opening shelters or tossing a few bucks at beggars.
Necessary reform at the federal level will be a long time coming, but locally, creative thinking and commitment can spark change.
My husband suggests we imitate 7-Eleven stores nationwide in playing classical music to disperse loiterers. (Order and beauty tend to repel criminals.)
Downtown’s new emergency shelter was full almost as soon as it opened. Another should already be in the works.
More police are crucial. Besides new hires, the higher-ups should assign every task possible to “civilians” and free more officers to work our streets.
Progressives’ anti-policing approach has decimated police ranks, demoralized those who remain and eviscerated their effectiveness.
Last but very important, the Gainey administration must support our worried Downtown businesses, churches and cultural organizations with real leadership. The city’s future depends on it.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.