Many, if not most, predictions of who will be elected president hinge on the behavior of a legendary segment of the electorate: the “swing voter.” They are a subset of a much larger group of inconsistent voters, and the composition of that group can vary enormously depending on how it is defined.

This poorly defined voter type is, for example, often maddeningly confounded with the “independent,” which is a different category encompassing many more voters. Most people who identify as “independents” — who make up around 40% of the voting public — are actually quite loyal to one party and consistently vote Democratic or Republican.

Three-quarters express a leaning to a major party. The other one-quarter, the “pure Independents” that actually swing their preferences from one party to another, typically make up a little less than 10% of the electorate and have often been found to be among the least politically engaged and politically knowledgeable voters.

Undecided swingers

Pure Independents are, however, just one kind of voter who does not reliably vote for one party inside the broad group called inconsistent voters. Some always vote for the same party but only turn out intermittently and others switch their preference from one party to another. Yet others vote for third parties, often swinging between the major parties and a third party or between third parties.

Advertise with us

Some commentators speak about swing voters when what they mean is undecided voters, those who have not formed a particular preference within a given election.

There tend to be fewer undecideds in presidential elections than voters who change preferences from one election to another. In recent years, when polled close to election day, undecideds only accounted for about 8% of the electorate.

Even voters who have long-term potential for inconsistency tend to develop stable short-term preferences. That means that across two or more elections, we can see quite a bit of electoral volatility, but relatively little in any one election.

The group that is generally politically uninvolved and lacking in political knowledge often exhibits both long- and short-term inconsistency. They are also more likely to be tipped one way or another by sensational appeals such as “October surprise” tactics.

Rarely decisive

In fact, close elections in which the choices of the swing voter is decisive are not all that common. They’re most important in tight presidential races whose outcome depends on a few swing states, where shifts in votes may give one candidate the state’s Electoral College votes. Joe Biden won Pennsylvania in 2020 by just 82,000 votes of the almost 7 million cast.

Advertise with us

Swing voters are rarely important in other races. Well over 90% of incumbents in U.S. House of Representatives and over 80% in the U.S. Senate are re-elected. And due in part to gerrymandering, only 16% of the 2024 races for House seats are even considered competitive by experts at the Cook Political Report. In many districts, around 35 in the last election, House candidates ran unopposed.

The inconsistent voter is a real thing. But these voters are rarely game-changers. In very close elections their votes may — especially with the Electoral College — make a difference. But their preferences are so unaccountable and difficult to interpret, that if you want to predict who will be elected on the basis of swing voters, you might as well spin a roulette wheel.

Arthur Beckman is an advertising copywriter and political scientist studying the intersection of marketing and politics. He has taught at George Washington University and The City University of New York.