Imagine walking home and seeing your house gone — in fact, your entire neighborhood has just vanished. You start to panic. Your friend, who has been with you through thick and thin since your family left 15 years ago, is missing.
The people with whom you built a home, who stood by you through freezing nights and chaotic days, who protected you from the evils of the world — disappeared. Where do you go? You have worked so hard and come so far, only to be slammed back down to the ground.
On June 28, the Supreme Court of the United States turned this fictional horror story into plausible reality. In the case of City of Grants Pass, Oregon v. Johnson, the court upheld the city’s right to impose fines and even imprison those sleeping outside.
It concluded that these penalties do not qualify as cruel and unusual punishment and therefore do not violate the Eighth Amendment, and that since the law applied to everyone, it was not illegally targeted at the homeless in particular. For over 250,000 Americans that sleep without shelter on any given night, their right to life is threatened now more than ever.
Housing protects health
As medical students, we study not only the biological causes of diseases, but also the environmental and lifestyle factors that contribute to them. Stable housing is one of the most protective components of physical and mental health.
For example, the unhoused showed more than twice the rate of head injuries and nearly 50% greater rate of bone fractures compared to the general population, according to a study of health conditions in 54,000 unhoused individuals conducted by the U.S Department of Health and Human Services.
Read More
Other problems are less obvious. The unhoused generally lack support from family and regular access to healthcare practitioners. Health concerns often linger unaddressed for years, until what should be preventable becomes a health emergency. For the unhoused, these events increase reliance on emergency medicine.
A 2010 study by doctors at Thomas Jefferson University calculated over 550,000 emergency department visits by those living on the streets annually. These were more likely to be repeat encounters and lead to hospitalization compared to visits from patients with stable housing.
During our medical education, we learn strategies to address chronic diseases, like diabetes, including regular monitoring, accurate medication management, dietary modifications, and exercise. While doing our rounds on the street, as part of Street Medicine at Pitt, we learn about a different set of guidelines governing healthcare — guidelines based solely on survival rather than rigorous scientific evidence and randomized controlled trials.
A man we greet on rounds gratefully accepts fruit snacks, chips, and a pre-wrapped sandwich while describing his struggle to obtain life-saving insulin. Denied a refill because of insurance difficulties, he has been forced to inject the insulin he has left with used needles. This increases his already significantly heightened risk of infection from living with chronic diabetes.
Many unhoused people we meet struggle to walk due to chronic infections or wounds on their feet, and the man asks our nursing lead if she can “put his feet back together” at her foot clinic in Second Avenue Commons. In cases of unmanaged diabetes, these infections can progress and necessitate the amputation of toes, feet, or legs.
A caring community
Beyond affecting rough sleepers, the court’s decision affects service organizations that have spent years uplifting and building trust within this community. In Pittsburgh, organizations such as Pittsburgh Mercy’s Operation Safety Net, Bridge Beyond, Allegheny Health Network, Central Outreach Wellness Center and Street Medicine at Pitt bring together healthcare professionals, social workers, volunteers, and students to connect with the over 1,000 individuals experiencing homelessness across the city.
Pittsburgh, unlike Grants Pass, has not instituted fines or jail time for those sleeping outside. However, the city has recently outlined hard grounds for encampment removal. In March, the city dismantled the site on Fort Pitt Boulevard, necessitating swift relocation of many by outreach workers.
Street outreach services rely heavily on knowing where encampments are located and who lives within them. As Jim Withers, founder of Operation Safety Net and a respected leader of the street medicine initiative, urges, “go to the people.” This becomes increasingly difficult when we don’t know where the people are.
Encampments are ways for those experiencing homelessness to build a stable, close-knit community. Often, people distribute food and supplies to their friends and partners who are absent during street rounds. This support is critical in the extreme summer heat and winter cold.
Forced removal of homeless encampments increases overdose deaths, hospitalizations, and mortality, found a study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association. For those who have nowhere else to go, is dismantling their communities, lowering their quality of life and health, and instilling a constant fear for their lives not cruel and unusual?
The tiny homes proposal, a project aimed at constructing small house villages for those experiencing homelessness, has been in the spotlight lately. If approved, it would provide more humane living conditions. While this is seemingly a great initiative, it poses issues in the context of existing policy. When a city constructs new communities, existing encampments may be perceived as illegal. In effect, this removes autonomy and promotes criminalization of homelessness.
Solutions, like tiny homes, must work flexibly with both policymakers and city planning executives while centering the perspective of affected individuals to provide options for the homeless community — not dictate where unhoused individuals can and cannot be.
Our responsibility
In the conclusion of their majority opinion, the Supreme Court states, “As we have stressed, cities and states are not bound to adopt public-camping laws ... Nor can a handful of federal judges begin to ‘match’ the collective wisdom the American people possess in deciding ‘how best to handle’ a pressing social question like homelessness.”
The unhoused members of our Pittsburgh community are parents, children, and siblings whose well-being is already at risk. The court has placed the responsibility on us to determine how we will treat our neighbors, and we must use our “collective wisdom” not to punish vulnerable Pittsburghers, but to promote a better, healthier future.
Sohan Rao is an MD and MPH candidate at the University of Pittsburgh Schools of Medicine and Public Health. Josh Morgenlander is an MD candidate at the university’s School of Medicine. Both are board members of Street Medicine at Pitt.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.