As Allegheny County wades through its housing dilemma, its Department of Human Services (DHS) is trying to address a severe lack of ongoing mental health funding for individuals with complex mental health needs who need a place to live.

This effort has been marred by a lack of transparency, accountability, and partnership, leaving providers in the dark about the implementation of community residential rehabilitation (CRR) programs, which provide community homes for individuals with mental health and substance use needs.

Providers have further been instructed not to communicate any known aspect of the plan with clients, families, staff or other providers, and the clients themselves are unaware of the county’s intentions, even as the initiative moves forward.

A minimal response

Despite efforts to engage county leaders and advocates, the response has been minimal, with promises to “do better as the initiative moves forward.” The situation stems from a lack of county-based mental health funding, which saw no increases for over a decade, and was reduced by 10% in 2012.

Advertise with us

Allegheny County DHS is now cutting critical program components for vulnerable populations to fit an arbitrary budget of $25,000 per client per year, risking the progress these individuals have made through the CRR programs. In some cases, it may cost twice that projected budget number depending on the needs and services of the individual.

When the state closed down Mayview State Hospital, it made a promise to the county and community that these individuals would be cared for and their complex needs addressed. These vulnerable individuals suffer from a complex array of psychiatric, physical and emotional conditions that can result in violent crisis-related behaviors, suffering and homelessness, which only exacerbates the county’s housing dilemma.

How in good faith can we remove critical supports like the oversight of medication distribution, assistance with daily tasks, behavioral health treatment and crisis management?

A devastating impact

Dismantling this safety net is not only a promise broken. It will have a devastating impact that can result in increased homelessness and safety concerns for our communities. It is unconscionable to spring this on the most deeply affected without hearing their voice and without notice.

This initiative initially promised collaboration. It was supposed to bring systems partners to the table to share their expertise so that the county could develop a program that would ensure the safety and treatment of individuals with complex mental health needs, and compliance with regulatory requirements. However, it became technical sessions to outline a program that had already been developed around a price tag.

Advertise with us

Repeated questions to the county about whether the current support system can manage the potential outcomes of these service changes have gone unanswered. For an initiative so focused and predicated on cost, what will happen when this bridge to independence collapses?

What will the price be when there is a need for a higher, costlier level of care? Where will these funds come from? Lastly, where will these victims go when removed from their residences, psychiatric facilities, emergency rooms, homeless shelters or jail? These county resources are already diminished.

Halt the rollout

Allegheny County must halt this rollout and engage all stakeholders to create a vision that addresses both fiscal shortfalls and the need to foster transitional independence and compassionate care for these complex individuals.

The plan must meet the needs of all stakeholders. Elected officials must remember that these individuals are part of their communities, having trusted them to serve. Immediate action is essential.

If necessary, a public hearing will be requested, but the hope is that the county will reengage with stakeholders to design a program that truly reflects the needs and voices of those most deserving of compassionate care.

Jim Sharp is COO and Director of Mental Health, Behavioral Health Division, at the Rehabilitation and Community Providers Association.