As a doctor in Philadelphia, I had a sinking feeling which way the election was headed. Now many of my patients will have to grapple with the consequences of the choice they made.
Having talked to patients over the past 10 years in the traditionally liberal bastions of Pittsburgh and Philly, I’ve felt a seismic shift in politics. As I’ve seen hundreds of patients on the wards over the past weeks, I’ve observed an increasing preponderance of Fox News on display early in the morning.
No status quo
This included some of my Black and Latino patients, who would watch Fox News with zeal, even as Trump ranted against immigrants. As a white man, I made the racist assumption that my Black patients would overwhelmingly vote for the first Black female president. The multiple MAGA hats in the clinic proved me wrong.
Voters by and large dismissed the lofty, abstract Democratic talking points like diversity and protecting democracy. They also increasingly rejected identity politics, with Trump winning record numbers of Black and Latino men.
Voters by and large came out for Trump as a rejection of the economic status quo, frustrated by rampant inflation, and a fear of losing their jobs to migrants or other countries. Trump doubled down on his unique flavor of populism in a time of record discontent.
Meanwhile, Harris came off as much of the same. As with Clinton in 2016, the Democrats stifled their primary and suppressed populist voices (like Sanders) to prop up their establishment candidate, who simply didn’t strike a chord with the nation.
Read More
U.S. healthcare perfectly encapsulated this economic and political turmoil. Increasing monopolization of healthcare systems, record profits for pharmaceutical and insurance companies, and COVID have all driven healthcare prices up, leading to increasing voter dissatisfaction.
Broken healthcare
I’ve seen increasing numbers of patients who end up in the hospital, and accumulate tens of thousands of dollars of medical debt, because they couldn’t afford the cost of their meds and ran out. The Biden administration had started on the right path, signing legislation for Medicare to negotiate with drug companies to lower prices for select medicines, but it was too little, too late.
Voters (of all races and genders) have recognized healthcare is broken, and voted for nebulous but radical change. (Or, as Trump put it, “concepts of a plan.”)
I worry about the repercussions this Republican victory will have for my patients. With Republicans likely to control all three branches of government, they may seize on the opportunity to try to reform healthcare. Unfortunately, many have promised to gut the Affordable Care Act, which provides subsidies to lower-income households to buy insurance and protections for those with pre-existing conditions.
Millions fewer people would have insurance and access to preventive healthcare, contributing to millions of life-years and dollars lost to chronic disease, making our current crisis worse. Due to lack of support for prevention, Americans already spend the most on healthcare but suffer among the lowest life expectancy in the developed world.
Populist answer
I hope both parties capitalize on the growing discontent with the status quo to push for meaningful reform. The answers to today’s problems may indeed have some basis in populism: such as increasing support for unions and regulations on profits for pharmaceuticals, insurances, and “not-for-profit” health systems that pay their administrators tens of millions.
Unfortunately, I fear that Trump’s unique flavor of populism will only make these issues worse. He has impressively duped many voters into conflating the “liberal elite” with the multinational corporations truly exploiting them.
Democrats ought to learn from Trump and propose the radical economic reforms needed to protect consumers and workers from the growing oppression of corporations, and meaningfully invest in safety-nets and prevention. Only then will my patients get the radical reprieve they voted for.
Adam Barsouk is a resident-physician and oncology researcher at Penn Medicine and author of “Better than Cure: Why We Get Cancer and How to Prevent It.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.