The 27-year-old woman had her baby on the side of a country highway, delivered by a paramedic, because her local hospital had closed its maternity care branch. Penn Highlands shuttered the unit in St. Mary’s in May, and in June reported an operating loss of $36.4 million.
The nearest hospital with a maternity ward was 29 miles away from her home. It’s a terrifying situation for pregnant women, who may have to give birth without appropriate, and possibly life-saving, medical care.
Services lost
This is a common problem. In fact, a six-county area of Pennsylvania, about the size of Delaware, completely lacks hospital-based maternity care.
The closure of maternity care units throughout Pennsylvania is closely tied to an ongoing trend: the purchase of small, local hospitals by larger hospital systems or for-profit companies. Maternity care is not the only service being lost. Communities are losing access to emergency care, trauma care, specialists and much more.
Over 112 hospitals in Pennsylvania have been acquired or merged with others in the last decade alone. A recent article in an industry publication, Beckers Hospital Review, called Pennsylvania the “hottest market” for hospital mergers and acquisitions.
Local hospitals acquired by bigger firms often close down or drastically reduce the healthcare services they provide.
Read More
The most recent analysis by Pennsylvania Health Access Network, which I direct, found that one in three hospital mergers and acquisitions leads to a hospital closure or service reduction. Rural hospitals are particularly at risk of either, according to two nationwide studies.
Yet when mergers and acquisitions are proposed, the purchasing hospital or company typically promises that the purchase will actually make access to healthcare in the local area better, not worse. That doesn’t always happen.
Broken promises
In 2017, when UPMC proposed to purchase local hospitals in Lock Haven and in Sunbury, UPMC Susquehanna’s president Steven Johnson said, “We are excited to extend our tradition of high-quality, compassionate care to the Lock Haven and Sunbury communities. Bringing these hospitals into our family allows us to reinvest in both facilities to improve access, enhance care and grow existing services.”
Just two years later, UPMC Susquehanna Sunbury permanently closed its doors, and in 2023, Lock Haven ended inpatient services, losing its hospital status.
This story has repeated many times. In 2020, Fayette Holdings proposed to acquire Berwick Hospital. At the time, vice president Annmarie Poslock said, “FHI is focused on enhancing and growing quality care and services to meet community needs, and Berwick Hospital Center will continue providing quality local care to patients.”
Two years later, Berwick Hospital was closed, leaving Columbia County without a local hospital or emergency room.
These broken promises are devastating, not just for young families, but for entire communities who rely on the local hospital for care, employment, and as drivers of the nearby economy.
The process of mergers, acquisitions, and community disruptions continues in Pennsylvania; 2024 is on track to be one of the busiest years yet for hospital acquisitions, with three large system acquisitions already completed and eight hospital acquisitions in process. While some acquisitions may have positive effects on local communities, or at least be neutral in their effects, it is impossible to know since firms currently operate with very little transparency.
Fortunately, lawmakers in Harrisburg have proposed a measure that would establish much-needed public review and oversight for hospital mergers and acquisitions.
A necessary bill
HB1344 would empower the state Attorney General to gather the facts about proposed hospital mergers and acquisitions, hear from community members about their concerns, commission an independent analysis of how the deal would affect the community, and take legal action to protect communities from the serious negative impacts of hospital consolidation when needed.
The legislation would also empower the Attorney General to track the promises made during an acquisition and take action when those promises are not kept. The Pennsylvania House of Representatives already passed the bill, with support from both sides of aisle.
It’s now before the Pennsylvania Senate, which must act before the legislative session ends — before more pregnant women are forced to give birth on the side of the road instead of in maternity units, and before more communities lose access to lifesaving care.
Antoinette Kraus is the executive director of the Pennsylvania Health Access Network.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.