Last week, Mayor Ed Gainey announced a proposal to rework Pittsburgh’s zoning code to address the city’s affordable housing challenges. It’s a good plan, and, if executed with care, could even be great.

The big problem to tackle is, of course, the housing crisis. It's a complicated story, but at the center of it are long-standing legal limitations on new housing construction — especially on the construction of multi-family housing in popular neighborhoods and regions. More people compete for fewer homes, so prices rise.

Not enough new housing

Although it may seem like construction is happening all over the place all the time, not nearly enough homes have been built to address the shortage.

Lower-income renters feel the strain the most, as higher rents siphon precious cash away from other parts of life, like food, transportation, childcare, and leisure. Many cope either by living in parts of the city where it’s cheaper because of disinvestment and deteriorated conditions, or leaving the city for decent housing but pricier and lengthier commutes.

Advertise with us

How does Mayor Gainey aim to address the problem? The short-term plan includes several components: allow accessory dwelling units by right (think small separate units on a property that a relative or friend could live in); remove costly parking requirements for new housing developments; allow and encourage more housing near transit; remove or reduce minimum lot size requirements in certain areas; and expand “inclusionary zoning.”

The plan attacks the problem of insufficient or inaccessible housing supply from several angles. Most of the components would make the housing development process cheaper, and therefore easier for developers large and small to create more homes.

It’s not just a gift to developers, then; it will help make housing more plentiful, and thus more affordable, in parts of the city rich in jobs and amenities where people have been pushed out by limited homes and rising prices.

But one part of Mayor Gainey’s plan might give us a mixed bag of results: expanding “inclusionary zoning.”

To oversimplify a bit, this component would condition the approval of new apartment buildings on the developer reserving 10% of the new individual apartments at a rent price accessible to people below the median income. The goal is a good one — make a way for lower-income people to live in homes, and even neighborhoods, that would otherwise be inaccessible. Given that lower-income people are exiting the city in response to rising prices, inclusionary zoning could make a lot of sense.

Advertise with us

But an effective inclusionary zoning policy must be carefully crafted, because inclusionary zoning brings costs along with its benefits. Research suggests that inclusionary zoning can raise average housing costs across a metropolitan area. Why?

It costs developers to cap the rent for a portion of their apartments. They might respond in one of two ways: either raise the rent of the other apartments in the project to try to cover some of the losses, or scratch the project entirely and build in another city where profits promise to be higher.

A double-edged sword

Inclusionary zoning is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it quite effectively secures good housing options for a limited number of lower-income residents. On the other hand, it could make housing more expensive on a broader scale, at least compared to allowing large-scale housing construction without conditions.

If that’s true, then how do we know whether inclusionary zoning will help us reach our affordable housing goals overall?

Inclusionary zoning’s benefits are more likely to outweigh its drawbacks in locations where demand for housing is highest. In other words, it will be more successful in more popular and expensive neighborhoods. Those are the places where developers stand to make the most profit from housing construction.

Advertise with us

If profits are thin, even the slightest tilting of the scale towards making the development process more costly could discourage developers from building at all. But if profits are large, that concern begins to fade.

Inclusionary zoning could therefore work well in some Pittsburgh neighborhoods. Housing demand and prices are high enough in neighborhoods like Lawrenceville, Squirrel Hill, and Shadyside that developers perhaps could make significant profits despite the additional costs the inclusionary zoning requirement would present.

But these neighborhoods’ housing challenges are different from the challenges of others — the ones that most need help. In some neighborhoods, as the City’s Housing Needs Assessment explains, lower-income residents are leaving not simply because of rising costs, but because of poor living conditions.

Those areas deserve investment, but inclusionary zoning repels developers who could provide that investment.

Plan hits the mark

Overall, Mayor Gainey’s plan hits the mark. It focuses on building the city’s housing supply, especially in high-demand areas.

Advertise with us

But the plan could be truly great if city leaders take care to target inclusionary zoning to the specific areas where it will work best for our affordable housing goals.

Brian M. Miller is assistant professor of law at Duquesne University’s Thomas R. Kline School of Law.