When Joe Biden pulled American troops from Afghanistan, he made the right decision, one that the U.S. should have taken two decades earlier. Last August’s inglorious scramble out of Kabul showed that Presidents, generals, rights groups and journalists, who for years had touted the American invasion’s “progress,” were clueless, deluded, deceitful, or mercenary.
Long before Donald Trump opened negotiations with the Taliban, it was clear that the U.S. could never win the war and that the toll in blood and money was unconscionable. Secret documents released in 2019 reveal that top government and military officials knew this, and knew how corrupt their Afghan clients were. Yet they kept sending American soldiers to fight and die.
The costs of defeat include over 6,000 American soldiers and contractors killed; over 74,000 Afghan and allied forces killed; multiples more wounded; hundreds of thousands of Afghan civilians killed or injured, many by U.S. forces; and almost 6 million people displaced.
Our government squandered over $8 trillion of taxpayer money on Afghanistan and related post-9/11 wars — but weapons producers, military contractors and top Afghan officials now living in luxury in the Persian Gulf region made out handily.
Nor was there a good national security reason for invading Afghanistan, one of the world’s poorest and most remote countries. The United States could have dealt with the threat of terrorism in far less extreme and more effective ways. It never made sense to conquer a country that had not attacked us even if, like in many other nations, terrorists dwelled within Afghanistan’s borders.
For all these reasons, Mr. Biden was correct to finally remove America’s occupying forces.
Read More
But to his shame, he then implemented harsh economic sanctions and, along with other countries, barred the Central Bank of Afghanistan from the international banking system. Nominally targeting Taliban leaders, these policies have gravely hurt Afghanistan’s exhausted and impoverished population of 41 million.
In February, in a legally questionable national emergency de-cree, Mr. Biden declared that Afghanistan’s dire humanitarian situation constituted an “extraordinary threat to the national security and foreign policy” — of the United States. On that dubious basis, he issued an executive order that seized $7 billion in foreign currency reserves the Central Bank of Afghanistan held in U.S. banks. The bank’s total foreign exchange is estimated to be $9 billion.
The seizure nullified all Afghan government contracts, including those for purchases of food and medicine and for provision of aid. It prevented any future use of bank monies, even individual and business deposits, except as licensed by the U.S. government.
Unsurprisingly, these policies make economic activity and aid delivery extremely difficult in Afghanistan. Humanitarian groups worry about inadvertently violating vague American rules. They have trouble paying local employees. Foreign banks and companies do not want to risk doing business with Afghans. The country’s economic, health and food systems are near collapse, according to a recent Human Rights Watch report.
While the Biden administration has granted some licenses for agencies to distribute aid and pledged $780 million for relief operations, the complexities, ambiguities and penalties of the sanctions and executive order leave enormous unmet needs. This week, after the U.S. drone strike killing al-Qaeda’s Ayman al-Zawahiri in Kabul, the U.S. forbade any distribution of the Central Bank’s money even for humanitarian purposes.
Afghan women and children suffer most — another predictable result, given the deadly record of past sanctions. In 1999, Secretary of State Madeleine Albright infamously proclaimed the excess deaths of 500,000 Iraqi children from the effects of U.S. sanctions “worth it” as pressure, albeit futile, on Saddam Hussein.
The Biden administration justifies its measures by invoking human rights and counterterrorism. Indeed, the Taliban’s human rights record is poor, particularly on girls’ education and women’s employment.
Yet many Afghan women and independent women’s organizations have long opposed the U.S. war, whether waged by military or economic weapons. They argue that international pressure undermines their national struggle against the Taliban and devastates the lives of civilians, few of whom are terrorists.
The World Food Programme estimates that almost half of Afghanistan’s population, 18.9 million people, are suffering acute food insecurity, with 3.9 million children malnourished and another 4.7 million at risk of malnutrition. In Senate testimony, David Miliband, head of the International Rescue Committee, predicted that Afghanistan’s “starvation crisis” could “kill more Afghans than the past 20 years of war.”
Current U.S. policies are not the only reason for the crisis. Also contributing are two decades of war sparked by the U.S. invasion, cutoffs of foreign payments and salaries on which American-occupied Afghanistan depended, Taliban mismanagement and corruption, and natural disasters. But today’s sanctions and seizures contribute mightily to Afghanistan’s misery.
They also give the Taliban cover to blame the outside world for the country’s plight. Over the long term, they are likely to generate popular anger toward the U.S.
On the one-year anniversary of the Taliban’s re-taking of Kabul, most Americans seem to have forgotten Afghanistan. None of the political, military and journalistic cheerleaders of 20 years of bloody waste have faced public censure. Many still hold plum positions from which they egg the U.S. on to more wars.
Already the Afghanistan defeat, like so many of America’s foreign policy failures, is remembered only fitfully, often to engage in pointless “who lost Afghanistan?” finger-pointing. It should not need to be said: Afghanistan belongs to the Afghans. It was never America’s to lose.
Still, the U.S. government claims to care about the Afghan people. If true, the best way to commemorate last year’s troop withdrawal would be for Mr. Biden to issue another executive order reversing the seizure of the Afghan national bank’s assets, restoring its access to the international financial system and ending the sanctions that are so harmful to the country’s innocent and long suffering population.
Clifford Bob, Ph.D., is a professor and chair of the Department of Political Science at Duquesne University.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.