There has been an undercurrent of resentment and contempt among some Muslims in this country and across the world against anyone who does not subscribe to their interpretation of Islam. As a practicing Muslim, I often find myself at odds with some Muslims who think they alone have a corner on religious interpretation. These people are usually on the far right of the religious spectrum.
Recently the minister for higher education in the Taliban-run Afghanistan banned university education for women. He said that Islam does not allow the education of women, and he compared universities to places of prostitution. To this marginally educated man women’s role in society is to serve their husbands and produce children.
When Americans withdrew from Afghanistan in 2021, it was speculated that the Taliban would not roll back human rights, including education for women. Whether it was wishful thinking on the part of the U.S. leadership or behind the scenes assurances given to departing Americans, is hard to know. At the time many pundits said that these Taliban were of a different mind-set than their predecessors who ruled the nation from 1996 to 2001. However, policies and attitudes of the new Taliban regime prove that they are cut from the same old cloth.
The Taliban minister’s statements raise some interesting questions. Does Islam deny women the right to education? And if we accept such stance as a religious dictate then why do a great majority of Muslims worldwide educate their girls?
The Taliban rose from the ashes of the six-year-old civil war that began with the humiliating defeat and withdrawal of Soviet forces from Afghanistan in 1989. The Taliban stepped into the political vacuum, and by 1996 had most of the country under their control. Much to their credit, they did bring peace and stability to the war-torn country. But they also implemented a much harsher interpretation of Islamic law. The cheering Afghan crowds that had welcomed the Taliban when they entered Kabul soon receded in the shadows.
In 2000, I visited Afghanistan during the Taliban rule to report for The Block News Alliance and to gather information and material for my book on the Taliban. I met a few ministers and some high-ranking officials. I soon realized that they were all steeped in Islamic seminary or madrassa education and none had any nonreligious education. Their source of knowledge was mostly based on age-old tribal traditions. They were oblivious and ignorant of the world beyond their immediate borders. They practiced tribal traditions camouflaged in religious garb.
Read More
Islam does not discourage education. In fact, there are repeated references in the Qur’an that encourage the faithful to seek knowledge, think, and contemplate about the world around them.
There are also prophetic sayings that makes it mandatory for followers to seek knowledge. One oft-quoted saying advises people to seek knowledge even if they have to travel to the farthest points of the world. Another religious saying state that the ink of a scholar’s pen is more sacred than the blood of a martyr. It is worth noting that the advice to seek knowledge is directed towards both men and women. Nowhere in the religious sacred literature are women excluded from seeking knowledge and getting educated.
A cursory look at the Muslim countries around the world shows that they do not find any ambiguity in the religious dictates about knowledge and education. Most of those countries have compulsory education for both boys and girls.
As a result, Muslim women became head of the state, presidents of the universities, served with distinction in the armed forces, and became pre-eminent scientists in the world. In Pakistan almost half the students in the universities are women. At my alma mater Khyber Medical College boys and girls compete for admission, and the girls always outnumber boys in the freshmen class.
Maurice Maeterlinck, the Belgian playwright, a philosopher, and the 1911 Nobel Laureate in literature, had famously said that on every crossroad that leads to the future, tradition has placed 10,000 men to guard the past.
Whereas almost all Muslims follow the religious dictates about knowledge and education, Taliban are still posting the proverbial 10,000 men of Maeterlinck to block the road to the future for their women.
By denying education to women, the Taliban are in direct conflict with the teachings of Islam.
S. Amjad Hussain is an emeritus professor of surgery and humanities at the University of Toledo. This article is taken from The Blade of Toledo, where his column runs every other week. Contact him at: aghaji3@icloud.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.