Despite the Supreme Court’s decision to ban affirmative action, much can still be done to maintain and increase diversity even with race neutral admissions. Let me offer one viable approach.

However, first we must assess how well administrators did in producing a diverse class of students using the previously legal tools of affirmative action. While progress was made, African Americans and Hispanics remain significantly underrepresented among recipients of doctoral degrees.

These two groups comprise a smaller percentage of doctoral degrees than their portion of all U.S. citizens in the age range of Ph.D. candidates. Without more persons of color earning doctoral degrees, there will remain an inadequate supply of underrepresented minority faculty.

The effects of under-representation

Advertise with us

Why is this significant? Many under-represented minority students prefer attending colleges and universities with faculty who look like them and share similar experiences.

A lack of such faculty may discourage minority students from choosing to enter college. This not only perpetuates a lack of diversity in the student bodies but reduces the number of minority students who might apply for doctoral programs.

Less than 25% of applicants to graduate school are Hispanic, African-American, or Native American. At my own institution, the University of Texas at Austin, graduate applicants for the summer and fall were especially low. (The data are taken from 2022 but representative of ongoing trends.)

Hispanic applications constituted 7.82% of all applicants, Black or African American comprised only 2.57%, Black or African American, two or more excluding Hispanic were 0.30% and combined were 10.69%.

So why do talented minority students choose not to attend graduate school? Many don’t give serious thought to pursuing graduate degrees, preferring instead to enter law, medicine or business, not only for the usual reasons of money and prestige, but also out of their awareness of the societal impact of these pursuits.

Advertise with us

Students from a minority community, or those who are the first in their family to attend college, may, as Washington Post columnist William Raspberry wrote, “perceive withdrawal from the rough and tumble of everyday problems as dereliction.” Minority and first-generation students are very intelligent and capable of learning at the highest levels, yet feel the tug of social responsibility.

Intellectual entrepreneurship

But graduate education need not be devoid of social relevance. At the University of Texas at Austin from 1997-2019, Intellectual Entrepreneurship (IE) offered an innovative vision and model of education that challenged students to be citizen-scholars. (I was the founding director of the university’s Intellectual Entrepreneurship Consortium and served for 25 years.)

The program was designed to engage students in community projects where they discovered and put knowledge to work, as well as requiring them to identify and adapt to audiences for whom their research matters. That work showed the enormous value to society of graduate study.

What does intellectual entrepreneurship have to do with increasing diversity? The program began in 1997 as a way to increase the value of graduate education for all students. Yet we discovered that 20% of students enrolled in IE were under-represented minorities, while this same group comprised only 9% of our total graduate student population.

Advertise with us

Minority students reported that, by rigorously exploring how to succeed, IE helped demystify graduate school. More importantly, they noted that IE provided one of the few opportunities to contemplate in a genuine entrepreneurial fashion how to use their intellectual capital to give back to the community — a desire that motivated many of them.

IE’s potential to increase diversity in graduate school was best documented by its Pre-Graduate School Internship. From 2003 to 2019, this initiative paired undergraduates with faculty and graduate student mentors. Interns worked with their mentors on research projects, observed graduate classes, shadowed graduate student teaching and research assistants, participated in disciplinary activities and explored their futures.

Each year, about 65% of these interns came from under-represented minorities, first-generation, or economically disadvantaged students. Over half of them went on to pursue a graduate degree.

Let me offer one example. Of the spring 2018 undergraduate IE cohort of 150 students, one-third were Hispanic, compared to a university-wide percentage of less than one-fifth. Similarly, although only 4.5% of our students identified as African-American, 18% of IE students were African-American.

Creating space

Advertise with us

Interns reported that, for the first time in their undergraduate careers, a space existed to reflect upon the role education plays in meeting their goals. IE empowered them to view academic disciplines not as artificial containers for students, but as lenses through which to clarify their visions and as tools to realize their goals.

The lesson learned from this is clear. To increase diversity in a race-neutral era, we must find innovative ways to expand the undergraduate and graduate applicant pool. One way to do that is to enable students to see the connections between their professional aspirations and education — something at the core of IE’s approach to education.

In short, there is hope for increasing diversity following the Supreme Court’s decision to eliminate affirmative action.

Richard Cherwitz is an emeritus professor at the University of Texas at Austin. His previous article was “Turn off the Trump show,” written with Kenneth Zagacki.