The news net­works spent al­most all their air time pro­vid­ing live cov­er­age of Trump’s civil fraud case tes­ti­mony, and that’s a prob­lem. Yes, they have a jour­nal­is­tic duty to re­port on events as sig­nifi­cant as a for­mer pres­i­dent’s le­gal per­ils.

On the other hand, the me­dia’s non­stop fo­cus on Trump’s rants and bom­bas­tic rhet­o­ric gives him the op­por­tu­nity he so des­per­ately craves for his self-serv­ing ver­sion of po­lit­i­cal the­atre.

Trump uses the me­dia

Trump is well-schooled in us­ing the me­dia to fur­ther his ends while vil­i­fy­ing it as part of the cor­rupt es­tab­lish­ment. He is an ex­pert at po­lit­i­ciz­ing le­gal pro­ceed­ings in par­tic­u­lar. He rec­og­nizes that the me­di­ated im­ages of his court­room be­hav­ior con­firm sto­ries he has re­cited be­fore about his en­e­mies and their de­based ways.

Advertise with us

Trump’s an­tics rep­resent a form of po­lit­i­cal the­ater of­ten uti­lized by au­thor­i­tar­ian lead­ers, one per­fectly suited for mod­ern me­dia. He ex­ploits me­dia at­ten­tion to cre­ate an epic drama in which he is a hero and those who op­pose him are vil­lains. The evil scape­goats re­spon­si­ble for his (and the coun­try’s) prob­lems must be sym­bol­i­cally (if not in some cases lit­er­ally) de­stroyed.

Trump’s drama, am­pli­fied through and by the me­dia, res­o­nates es­pe­cially with base sup­port­ers and some other vot­ers. They be­lieve that, as he and con­ser­va­tive me­dia have re­peated over and over, he is fight­ing for them against un­scru­pu­lous and trai­tor­ous “Deep State” at­tor­neys gen­er­als, pros­e­cu­tors, and judges — all of them, of course, un­leashed by Pres­i­dent Biden.

As Brett Ste­phens de­scribed Trump’s strat­egy in the New York Times, the in­dict­ments and the me­dia cov­er­age of them help Trump “be­cause they play to his out­law ap­peal. He wants to cast him­self as the Jo­sey Wales of Amer­i­can pol­i­tics. His en­tire ar­gu­ment is that ‘the sys­tem’ — par­tic­u­larly the Justice Depart­ment — is bro­ken, bi­ased and cor­rupt, so any­thing the sys­tem does against him is proof of its cor­rup­tion rather than of his. And tens of mil­lions of peo­ple agree with him.”

To in­crease rat­ings, the me­dia play into and even en­cour­age this dra­matic nar­ra­tive by pro­vid­ing sus­pense­ful news cov­er­age and by por­tray­ing po­lit­i­cal ac­tors as good or bad, de­pend­ing on the me­dia out­let.

Trump’s court­room ti­rades may ex­pand view­er­ship and hence tele­vi­sion rat­ings. How­ever, all they do is give ox­y­gen to Trump’s tem­per tan­trums and per­fectly con­trived, vi­cious court­room at­tacks.

Advertise with us

The con­se­quences

Trump’s highly pub­li­cized rants are not with­out tre­men­dous con­se­quences. Be­cause in any epic drama, good must be pre­served and evil purged, Trump’s court­room his­tri­on­ics, em­pha­sized by the me­dia, put court of­fi­cials in­clud­ing ju­ries at risk.

Indeed, we worry that, given their al­ready deep dis­trust in gov­ern­ment in­sti­tu­tions fo­mented by Trump, as well as the will­ing­ness of so many Trump fol­low­ers to ap­plaud or down­play the storm­ing of the US cap­i­tol on Jan­u­ary 6, his feigned out­rage and dark drama about Amer­ica could in­cite his sup­port­ers to greater vi­o­lence. As fel­low ac­tors in Trump’s (me­dia me­di­ated) drama, sup­port­ers may take the law into their own hands to rid the world of his tor­men­tors.

Po­lit­i­cal com­mu­ni­ca­tion schol­ars Dan Nimmo and James Combs once pointed out in their book “Me­di­ated Po­lit­i­cal Real­i­ties” that the me­dia trans­forms po­lit­i­cal re­al­ity into fan­tasy so that re­al­ity dis­ap­pears. If the me­dia are go­ing to cover Trump’s tri­als, they should do so crit­i­cally, fo­cus­ing on re­al­ity, with­out al­low­ing Trump to ma­nip­u­late them.

For ex­am­ple, they might con­cen­trate on the se­ri­ous­ness of the charges against Trump and the ve­rac­ity of his le­gal de­fenses. In ad­di­tion, the me­dia must an­a­lyze and cau­tion about the threats his me­di­ated drama poses to demo­cratic in­sti­tu­tions, the po­lit­i­cal pur­poses be­hind his dra­matic per­for­mances and how they eas­ily dupe peo­ple.

Advertise with us

Turn off the show

If Trump’s sor­did le­gal his­tory and re­cent ef­forts to over­turn de­moc­racy are any in­di­ca­tion, the me­dia should take noth­ing he does in court at face value.

The bot­tom line: We urge the me­dia to turn off the Trump show.

Richard Cherwitz is an emeritus professor at the University of Texas at Austin. Kenneth Zagacki is a professor of communication at North Carolina State University. Their previous article was “How presidents try to convince us to let them do what they want.”