I am an older trans non-binary woman who has only accepted themselves late in life. As a child, the gender I identified with was a girl, not a boy. I participated in everything a young girl does. My entire being was a girl. I was happy until I became painfully aware that my family and neighbors were not OK with who I expressed as a child.
We now have a word to describe those experiences: “transphobia.” The word didn’t exist while I was growing up, but what it names did. I was called stigmatizing names, bullied, and developed painful internalized stigma/transphobia from external family and societal transphobia/stigma, which began my lifelong trauma and mental health challenges of my gender incongruence.
Most importantly, I was unable to be who I am. A girl. I have lived with a gender male expression and attempts at being a male for nearly six decades. No more.
I have been both a victim and survivor of early childhood sexual assault and later experienced sexual assault and rape as an adult. I have experienced and survived domestic violence. If I find I need to access a shelter to feel safe from the trauma I experience, the only place I wish to be with is in a women’s space.
Why should that be considered a problem? To have cisgender people say, based on their personal belief system, that I am a threat to other women in a women’s shelter does immense potential physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual damage to me. I would be at risk for physical violence, bullying, name-calling, and potential morbidity.
Matt Sharp, senior counsel with the Alliance Defending Freedom, is an example of one of those cis-gender people. Writing in the Post-Gazette, he claimed that people like me pose an “emotional, psychological and physical risk” to the “vulnerable women” in the shelters, as an argument against PA House Bill 300. The fairness act adds to the state’s anti-discrimination law “sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression.”
Read More
His pitting one life against another has no bearing on what PA House Bill 300 represents. He does not understand what it means to be trans.
Being transgender means to have gender incongruence, not identifying with gender assigned at birth. This is based on a binary system of assigning sex at birth based on body parts. Gender is on a spectrum.
We have both male and female characteristics associated with gender roles. I am neither male nor female, I am both. It’s my gender identity. I have female gender expression (how I appear) and experience my life on a spectrum. No one gets to define my trans identity other than me. This is my reality and world view. It works for me. I am finally happy to be me.
In my daily life and my different communities, I encounter many types of people. I make connections with all people including those who don’t agree or believe in my reality. It’s ok. The only respectful thing I desire is to be called by my full name, Shekinah Rose, and to use whatever pronoun suits. I am she/her, he/him, they/them, ze/zir, etc. There are no wrong pronouns.
I know who I am and am comfortable with the pronouns people choose. When people use the pronouns “he/him” whilst viewing my female gender expression, this does not mean that it is used as a weapon to shame, bully, insight hate towards me. I am not affected. I am trans non-binary.
That’s me. My response is only about my gender identity. Every Trans person has their own experience. We are a rainbow within the rainbow. (As you may have noticed, I have left out my sexual orientation. Like being asked if I have a vagina, unless we are engaged in a sexual experience, my sexual orientation is no one’s business.)
People like Matt Sharp believe they get to define someone else’s experience, including experiences they don’t understand and apparently haven’t tried to understand. I question if he (or many people like him) has ever known or spoken firsthand to a trans person.
Pennsylvanians are a fair and just people. Let’s stick to the facts, not personal opinions and belief systems. Trans women are women.
Shekinah Rose is a trans non-binary woman (all pronouns) living in the Pittsburgh area.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.