Several weeks ago, a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing examined the impact of the end of Roe v. Wade. Sen. Josh Hawley and UC Berkeley School of Law Professor Khiara Bridges had a memorable exchange when Hawley questioned Bridge's use of the phrases "pregnant people" and "people with uteruses.” When she explained that transgender men and nonbinary folks can get pregnant too, Hawley countered by asking Bridges if that meant abortion isn't a "women's rights issue."
Mr. Hawley was not asking this question in good faith. Still, the answer is, "Yes, this is a women's rights issue and an issue for anyone else with a uterus who doesn't fit into our society's narrow idea of accepted gendered behavior.”
Simone de Beauvoir's landmark book from 1949, "The Second Sex," posited that women, not men, are gendered beings because men are the default. Over 70 years later, we must evolve and recognize that this two-gender framework is outdated, too.
It was only in 2014 when Laverne Cox graced the cover of Time Magazine with the headline, "The Transgender Tipping Point." While transgender folks, nonbinary folks, and genderqueer folks have been around forever, the explosion of this expansive language as a mainstream discussion is relatively new.
The erasure of queer and trans folks from these parenting and pregnancy discussions is born from the same rigid thinking that sees "acceptable" womanhood from a narrow viewpoint: a woman who tries to control her fertility through birth control or abortion is going against the true nature of femininity; a transman carrying and giving birth to a child himself is not what men are “supposed” to do.
But while those who craft the laws that control "women's" bodies may not have considered the effects of those laws on trans or nonbinary folks, there are, in fact, men and nonbinary people with uteruses out there. And they deserve to be acknowledged.
Read More
This isn't about erasing the experiences of AFAB (assigned female at birth) women. But the fact is, until recently, our shared language didn't acknowledge a whole swath of people who are also experiencing the dangers of pregnancy.
This reminds me of the popular meme: "Equal rights for others does not mean fewer rights for you. It's not pie." Including trans and nonbinary folks in our discussion about pregnant people doesn't erase women. It acknowledges that this issue doesn't only affect women. As our understanding of gender has widened, naturally, so should our terminology.
We're debating the wrong thing. A national discussion about pregnancy and parenting in the United States is crucial. Should the focus be on whether or not trans-inclusive language harms AFAB women? The answer is a resounding no. Especially when you consider that even before this language conversation went mainstream, pregnancy in the US was hazardous. Health advocates have called the US the "Most Dangerous Developed Nation In Which To Give Birth."
When it comes to infant mortality rates in the US, we're nearly dead last out of almost 40 countries. Outcomes for Black women are even worse; they are three times more likely to die of a pregnancy-related cause than white women. Part of this is due to a lack of access to affordable quality healthcare, both pre and post-natal, and a shortage of pregnancy care providers across the country.
Over half of our maternal mortality deaths happen after birth. We are the only high-income country that doesn't guarantee paid leave. After the leaked SCOTUS decision overturning Roe hit the press, Nurx, an online pharmaceutical company that prescribes birth control, reported a 300% increase in requested prescriptions. Folks are reasonably afraid of having high-risk pregnancies and fear that they may be putting their lives in danger without the chance to abort, even if the pregnant person's life is at risk.
Pregnant women. Pregnant people. People capable of becoming pregnant. Regardless of the language we use, pregnancy in the U.S. is dangerous, and focusing the conversation on anything else won't change these outcomes.
Jessica Semler is an Etna Borough councilwoman and reproductive freedom activist.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.