A critical development site in Pittsburgh’s Downtown has become an eyesore, with boarded-up windows laced with graffiti and empty storefronts reeking of urine.
“It’s all about the experience,” states the mantra of Cleveland-based Stark Enterprises, which purchased the vacant, seven-story building at 441 Smithfield Street six years ago, with plans to convert it to office and retail space. Covering the block between Forbes and Fifth Avenues, this potential jewel for redevelopment has, instead, become a drag to surrounding businesses and residents.
It’s time for City Council and the administration of Mayor Ed Gainey to pull whatever levers of influence, or legal authority, they have to get Stark Enterprises to rehab the property, or sell it to someone who will. This section of Downtown is at a tipping point. A redeveloped Kaufmann building sits across the street from the Smithfield Street property. Continuing to let the Smithfield building rot will have ripple effects the city can’t afford.
The ability to negotiate with developers is part of the skill-set of any effective urban mayor. Stark Enterprises has submitted applications for remodeling that were deemed incomplete. To get renovations started, the Gainey Administration could help Stark secure permits for promising projects.
Persuasion and deal-making are not the only tools available to the city. Mr. Gainey should ask city attorneys whether they have legal options. In an article Monday by Mark Belko of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, a frustrated John Valentine, executive director of the Downtown Neighbors Alliance, raised the possibility of seizing the property, with fair compensation, through eminent domain.
As a legal strategy, that’s unlikely to work. Government generally needs a narrowly defined public purpose, such as building a road, to take over private property. Still, it’s an option worth exploring. And the city might have other legal ways to regulate, by ordinance, the use or ownership of vacant property.
Read More
In 2017, Stark Enterprises paid $10.4 million for the building, which housed the Frank & Seder department store from 1918 to 1954. Three years later, the developer tried to sell the property for $22 million, double its purchase price. Stark’s plans for the property have focused on retail, apartments and office space
Developers who invest in properties, and then let them sit, plague cities nationwide. Mr. Valentine said he can’t get a return phone call from Stark Enterprises concerning its plans for the building. That reflects an unhealthy arrogance and indifference to local sentiment. The mayor’s office or City Council should at least be able to get the developer’s attention.
Shame on city government if it allows an out-of-town company to undermine the redevelopment of Downtown — without at least raising the roof.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.