Absentee landlords and rapacious developers — not to mention enormous non-profits — get the most negative attention among city landowners from activists and city officials. But the most negligent landowner in Pittsburgh is city government itself.

Blight remediation challenges most cities with significant population loss. There are no easy, pre-packaged solutions. Still, Pittsburgh’s city government has been unusually incompetent, eroding public health and safety in neighborhoods that can least afford it.

City government should be only a stopover for blighted properties; for the long haul, Grant Street simply doesn’t have the resources to properly maintain its 5,000 empty homes and lots.

The city should pursue two complementary strategies to lighten its real estate portfolio: revamp the city’s land bank so that it can effectively get parcels back on the tax rolls, and allow community organizations to revitalize properties the city can’t.

Advertise with us

Pockmarked city

Pittsburgh may not be Detroit, where entire neighborhoods have returned to nature and one-third of the city is empty, but many Pittsburgh neighborhoods are laced with empty homes and lots. Besides attracting crime and vermin, these properties are symbols of economic and social despair, discouraging residents and potential development.

Of the roughly 5,000 abandoned properties owned by the city, around one in five have incurred code violations, whether for health concerns or structural integrity. More than 300 of those properties have been condemned, but remain dangerous neighborhood nuisances.

Not surprisingly, the lion’s share of these properties are in poor and Black communities. In Homewood, 165 of 817 city-owned properties have code violations. Go across the East Busway and Penn Avenue to Point Breeze, and the city owns five properties — all in decent condition.

Direct deposits

Advertise with us

City government had good intentions when it began scooping up derelict properties: Other cities, like Flint, Mich., and Toledo, Ohio, have effectively fought blight through a combination of demolition and land banks, which allow for tax liens to be cleared so parcels can be put back on the market — and the tax rolls.

But Pittsburgh never executed its plan. Demolitions have slowed, with only 200 mostly privately owned buildings torn down in the past three years. Meanwhile, using federal stimulus money and other grants, Toledo is razing 1,000 structures and Flint, 2,000.

By contrast, city government never positioned Pittsburgh’s land bank to succeed. A land bank requires extensive financial, legal and political expertise to manage effectively. Pittsburgh threw a few hundred thousand dollars at consultants and didn’t hire a full-time executive director until 2021. It has acquired two properties, and is actively marketing one of them.

From the Mon Valley to Genesee County in Michigan, competently run land banks have proven their worth, time and again. Mayor Ed Gainey and city council need to establish substantial and sustainable funding for the land bank, and council should stop requiring that it has to approve every property transfer from the city to the bank. It’s inefficient and unnecessary. Finally, Mr. Gainey should set a realistic goal, such as moving 20 properties before the end of his term, that can get the bank moving in the right direction.

Help needed

Advertise with us

Perhaps most frustrating of all, the city is fighting tooth and nail against community leaders who want to help revitalize city-owned properties. Pennsylvania’s Abandoned and Blighted Property Conservatorship Act allows community groups to take over the management, though not the ownership, of seriously neglected properties. They can remediate code violations, upgrade residences or tear them down — all improvements the city has proven unable to make.

Several groups around the city are trying to deploy this law, for the first time, against a public landowner — the city of Pittsburgh — instead of a private one. The city’s arguments against this use of conservatorship are specious and territorial. There’s no risk, for instance, of a developer abusing conservatorships, because they are overseen by the courts. And the idea that the threat of court-ordered conservatorship “places a new financial burden” on the city is ridiculous: The city took that burden on itself when it bought the properties. Community groups are trying to help them to bear that burden.

Mr. Gainey’s office should look at conservatorship as an opportunity, not a threat. In a spirt of collaboration with community groups, the city could finally make progress toward clearing its portfolio of blighted properties — and clearing its reputation as a negligent, absentee landowner.