Kamala Harris and Donald Trump want to spend a lot of money on us, as if they’re competing for the job of national Santa Claus. But if they’re going to spend money, they need to spend it well.

Money, as my father would say, with that exasperated paternal “Why don’t you kids understand this?” voice, which I found myself using when our eldest was about five and still use now that they’re all grown, because kids never do understand, does not grow on trees.

Where does our money go?

Will they spend it well? We have to earn it with hard work and we have to spend it on a lot of ba­si­cally fixed but ris­ing ex­penses, like hous­ing, food, health care, gas, etc. And on taxes, which in to­tal, from bor­ough to county to state to na­tion, keep ris­ing. We would like to keep more of it, not be­cause we’re self­ish but be­cause we have good things to do with it.

As a non-econ­o­mist, I’m will­ing to ac­cept the ar­gu­ment that the na­tion can sur­vive con­tin­ual def­i­cit spend­ing be­cause the econ­omy will grow fast enough to cover it. But there has to be some limit, where the pay­ment on the debt starts hurt­ing the econ­omy, and it’s hard to be­lieve that with the mas­sive in­creases in the na­tional debt in the last few years — start­ing with Don­ald Trump — we ha­ven’t passed that point. I’d be very happy to be wrong about that.

Advertise with us

But even if the def­i­cit hasn’t got­ten too big, there is the ob­vi­ous prob­lem that am­bi­tious pol­i­ti­cians, like Ms. Har­ris and Mr. Trump, will use that idea to jus­tify spend­ing what­ever money they need to spend to convince peo­ple to vote for them. What re­strains them?

Do ei­ther of them ever ask how much money the gov­ern­ment ac­tu­ally has and how best to spend it, which will in­clude say­ing no to peo­ple — en­tire vot­ing blocs — who want it spent on them? I have my doubts.

The bud­get must not feel real to na­tional pol­i­ti­cians. It’s just numbers. Look at the way Wash­ing­ton re­sponds to demands.

Just give them money. What’s a few bil­lion here or there? Or rather here and there. And there and there and there.

Har­ris’s $25,000 pro­posal

Har­ris is the lat­est to tell us what she wants to spend on us, and pre­sum­ably will say more to­mor­row night (I’m writ­ing on Wed­nes­day af­ter­noon). I was in­ter­ested in her pro­posal to give first time home buy­ers “on av­er­age” $25,000 to help with the down pay­ment. It got a lot of at­ten­tion, be­cause a lot of peo­ple want homes but find the costs ris­ing far­ther and far­ther out of reach.

Advertise with us

In the­ory, it could help peo­ple I care about. Think­ing of four young adult sib­lings I know, only one has been able to buy a home, and that was only with two in­comes and get­ting an ex­pen­sive house in a neigh­bor­hood with a high crime rate in a hard-to-get-to cor­ner of the city. Who knows if the other three, all just as hard work­ing, will ever be able to do even that.

I looked to the mag­a­zines Rea­son and Jac­o­bin for their opin­ion, be­cause it helps to hear from the peo­ple who aren’t part of the main­stream. Rea­son is lib­er­tar­ian, want­ing as lit­tle gov­ern­ment as pos­si­ble, and Jac­o­bin so­cial­ist, want­ing as much gov­ern­ment as pos­si­ble, or at least a lot more than we have.

The New York Times’ Paul Krug­man, rep­re­sent­ing the main­stream view, thinks the pol­icy ok, but doesn’t ad­dress “the broader prob­lem,” which is “zon­ing and reg­u­la­tion that blocks con­struc­tion of new hous­ing units.”

As you’d ex­pect, Rea­son re­jects Har­ris’s pro­posal. As­so­ci­ate ed­i­tor Liz Wolfe, in an ar­ti­cle ti­tled “Har­ris’s eco­nomic il­lit­er­acy,” ex­plains the prob­lem this way: high in­ter­est rates keep many peo­ple from buy­ing and when the rates start com­ing down, which she thinks will hap­pen soon, more peo­ple will start buy­ing. She ig­nores the prob­lem that if the hous­ing costs too much, low in­ter­ests rates won’t help you.

As it hap­pens, Jac­o­bin doesn’t like the pro­posal ei­ther. “This is a bad idea,” says Matt Bru­enig in an ar­ti­cle ti­tled “Our Ver­dict on Kamala Har­ris’s New Plans.” He ar­gues that “it is un­fair to peo­ple who, even with the sub­sidy, can­not af­ford to buy a home and those who pre­fer to rent.”

Advertise with us

He also ar­gues that “be­cause it is a de­mand sub­sidy with­out any cor­re­spond­ing price con­trols, some of the money will also just get cap­tured as higher home prices, ne­gat­ing the af­ford­abil­ity goals of the pol­icy.” In sim­pler lan­guage, be­cause sell­ers will know that some buy­ers have ex­tra money to spend, they’ll raise the prices. Prob­a­bly not the whole $25,000, but a lot of it. People will still be left out of the mar­ket.

More money than we have

If Wolfe and Bru­enig are right, and I think they are, the Har­ris ad­min­is­tra­tion will spend a lot of money that won’t do very well what it’s in­tended to do.

My own views, I should say, are closer to Jac­o­bin’s than to Rea­son’s. But that doesn’t mean I want to see money spent badly.

We don’t need a na­tional Santa Claus. We need candidates who rec­og­nize lim­its and spends wisely. But will they resist the temptation to lure voters with promises of money? Will the vot­ers let them?

David Mills’ previous column was “What Donald Trump could learn from Robert F. Kennedy (Sr.).”