Kamala Harris and Donald Trump want to spend a lot of money on us, as if they’re competing for the job of national Santa Claus. But if they’re going to spend money, they need to spend it well.
Money, as my father would say, with that exasperated paternal “Why don’t you kids understand this?” voice, which I found myself using when our eldest was about five and still use now that they’re all grown, because kids never do understand, does not grow on trees.
Where does our money go?
Will they spend it well? We have to earn it with hard work and we have to spend it on a lot of basically fixed but rising expenses, like housing, food, health care, gas, etc. And on taxes, which in total, from borough to county to state to nation, keep rising. We would like to keep more of it, not because we’re selfish but because we have good things to do with it.
As a non-economist, I’m willing to accept the argument that the nation can survive continual deficit spending because the economy will grow fast enough to cover it. But there has to be some limit, where the payment on the debt starts hurting the economy, and it’s hard to believe that with the massive increases in the national debt in the last few years — starting with Donald Trump — we haven’t passed that point. I’d be very happy to be wrong about that.
But even if the deficit hasn’t gotten too big, there is the obvious problem that ambitious politicians, like Ms. Harris and Mr. Trump, will use that idea to justify spending whatever money they need to spend to convince people to vote for them. What restrains them?
Do either of them ever ask how much money the government actually has and how best to spend it, which will include saying no to people — entire voting blocs — who want it spent on them? I have my doubts.
Read More
The budget must not feel real to national politicians. It’s just numbers. Look at the way Washington responds to demands.
Just give them money. What’s a few billion here or there? Or rather here and there. And there and there and there.
Harris’s $25,000 proposal
Harris is the latest to tell us what she wants to spend on us, and presumably will say more tomorrow night (I’m writing on Wednesday afternoon). I was interested in her proposal to give first time home buyers “on average” $25,000 to help with the down payment. It got a lot of attention, because a lot of people want homes but find the costs rising farther and farther out of reach.
In theory, it could help people I care about. Thinking of four young adult siblings I know, only one has been able to buy a home, and that was only with two incomes and getting an expensive house in a neighborhood with a high crime rate in a hard-to-get-to corner of the city. Who knows if the other three, all just as hard working, will ever be able to do even that.
I looked to the magazines Reason and Jacobin for their opinion, because it helps to hear from the people who aren’t part of the mainstream. Reason is libertarian, wanting as little government as possible, and Jacobin socialist, wanting as much government as possible, or at least a lot more than we have.
The New York Times’ Paul Krugman, representing the mainstream view, thinks the policy ok, but doesn’t address “the broader problem,” which is “zoning and regulation that blocks construction of new housing units.”
As you’d expect, Reason rejects Harris’s proposal. Associate editor Liz Wolfe, in an article titled “Harris’s economic illiteracy,” explains the problem this way: high interest rates keep many people from buying and when the rates start coming down, which she thinks will happen soon, more people will start buying. She ignores the problem that if the housing costs too much, low interests rates won’t help you.
As it happens, Jacobin doesn’t like the proposal either. “This is a bad idea,” says Matt Bruenig in an article titled “Our Verdict on Kamala Harris’s New Plans.” He argues that “it is unfair to people who, even with the subsidy, cannot afford to buy a home and those who prefer to rent.”
He also argues that “because it is a demand subsidy without any corresponding price controls, some of the money will also just get captured as higher home prices, negating the affordability goals of the policy.” In simpler language, because sellers will know that some buyers have extra money to spend, they’ll raise the prices. Probably not the whole $25,000, but a lot of it. People will still be left out of the market.
More money than we have
If Wolfe and Bruenig are right, and I think they are, the Harris administration will spend a lot of money that won’t do very well what it’s intended to do.
My own views, I should say, are closer to Jacobin’s than to Reason’s. But that doesn’t mean I want to see money spent badly.
We don’t need a national Santa Claus. We need candidates who recognize limits and spends wisely. But will they resist the temptation to lure voters with promises of money? Will the voters let them?
David Mills’ previous column was “What Donald Trump could learn from Robert F. Kennedy (Sr.).”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.