Propaganda is central to modern politics. That’s why campaigns cost so much: political ads. These ads are not arguments, or even promises.
They are reflex tests. Aggregated slogans. Constructed and transmutable realities. They must be repeated, endlessly, hypnotically.
The process is programming, not persuasion. Brain washing, not brain stimulation. They create an ideological political vocabulary and much of what we think we think.
But we are not thinking.
Not thinking, reacting
We are reacting — getting our tickets punched.
The left reacts with what is these days called wokism and used to be called political correctness — the tendency to quickly see the motives of those they disagree with as racist or misogynist. The tendency to equate any form of conservatism with anger and contempt. The tendency to equate a Daniel Patrick Moynihan with a George Wallace.
Read More
Trumpists react with a series of memorized memes: Biden heads a crime family. Obama ran the Biden Administration. The economy is tanking. The country is doomed. Immigrants are dangerous and taking our jobs. A Trumper told me last week that illegal immigrants are better treated in this country today than veterans.
We have a hard time telling propaganda from reality, slogans and slanders from facts.
Well, Kamala Harris, who has found her voice and picked a running mate who never lost his, and who offers the nation fresh air, is about to get the propaganda treatment.
She is about to be “othered.” We will be flooded with negative ads meant to persuade us that Kamala Harris is a scary fraud.
It has already started: She is a leftist, maybe some kind of communist. She is a diversity hire, exploiting her Blackness. She will continue the wrecking of the economy (where inflation is moving toward 2% and unemployment is the lowest it has been since good records have been kept). Oh, and if she wants to control price gouging, that is “big government” and can never work.
Above all: She is dangerous.
The cynical assumption is that if you keep the lies, big and small, coming, she will eventually be sullied. It usually works. Remember Willie Horton? And the Swift Boating of John Kerry?
Pushing back
Ms. Harris is going to have to push back. She is going to have to try to maintain her positivity and, at the same time, call out the lies. Not an easy balancing act.
And more Americans are going to have to willfully resist others doing our thinking for us. Turn the ads off. Look for facts and arguments. And then, look for values.
When Ms. Harris frames her campaign in terms of freedom and neighborliness, she challenges Donald Trump to tell us what his political values are. And I see only one value: Strong men should rule.
I cannot tell you that Kamala Harris will be a good president. No one knows that. But I think she will try to serve and help. She will try to make the country more fair and humane.
It strikes me that lower prescription drug costs, expanded Medicare benefits and taxing the rich to save Social Security are the kinds of things the government exists to do. There is nothing “left” about using government well.
Albeit, government has not always been used well. The welfare state has sometimes perpetuated a poverty culture rather than helped to end it. And we have a cancerous federal debt. But we surely do need a National Park Service and an EPA, just as surely as we need an Army and a Navy.
We know that Donald Trump was not a president who tried to serve and help. We’ve seen this flick. It started as a farce and ended as a horror movie. And we know that dismantling the government (his 2025 plan) won’t make life better for the many.
Look, conventions are coronations. And, in the GOP case this year, a cult rally. And I could live without greatest hits from the Clintons and Obamas and without some of the pro-abortion zealotry. But Ms. Harris and Mr. Walz are on to something: Joyful engagement and love of country, optimism, and politics as a human art.
Exhibit A: Mr. Walz. Exhibit B: The second gentleman, Doug Emhoff. Both just talked to us at the convention. Both suggest a political party that decent and reasonable people might actually want to join. A party for both the Al Smith Democrat and the AOC Democrat.
Momala and the Coach
Ms. Harris is Momala and Mr. Walz is The Coach. She would be as firm with Netanyahu as she is with hecklers. But she is nurturing. He makes progressivism seem as wholesome as high school football. Their respective convention speeches worked because they were from the heart and contained actual thoughts.
I saw a picture of Mr. Walz speaking, and the vice president and her husband standing behind him listening, alongside two young black men. Everyone was smiling.
Knock not the politics of joy.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers: burriscolumn@gmail.com. His previous article was “Those in the know were wrong about FDR and Truman, and now they're wrong about Kamala Harris.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.