More than $3.5 million in fines and emergency repairs for September’s Liberty Bridge fire likely will come out of contractor Joseph B. Fay Co.’s profit on the $80 million bridge rehabilitation.
The federal Occupational Health and Safety Administration last week added another $11,224 to the West Deer contractor’s fees when it issued a citation for not conducting an appropriate fire watch before the Sept. 2 blaze. Hot slag from a steel cutting operation on the upper deck of the bridge dropped to a construction platform below and ignited plastic ventilation pipe that had been stored there improperly, the agency said.
The fire buckled a key support chord on the bridge and caused PennDOT to close it for 24 days because of concern the 88-year-old structure could collapse.
That assessment comes on top of $3,033,200 the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation will deduct from Fay’s final payment for liquidated damages as a result of the bridge and a ramp being closed for 24 days for emergency repairs. Dan Cessna, PennDOT’s District 11 executive, said the agency also expects to deduct more than $500,000 in additional damages for the cost of emergency and still-to-come permanent repairs to the bridge, as well as the cost of assembling a 16-member team of national experts to assess, monitor and design the repairs.
And the Pittsburgh Bureau of Fire issued a $1,000 fine for Fay’s failure to obtain a permit to conduct so-called “hot work” such as cutting steel with a torch.
The OSHA fine and other penalties likely will come from the contractor’s expected profit on the project and aren’t covered by insurance, said Jim Leatzow, a Three Lakes, Wis., agent with 39 years of experience in contractor insurance. Mr. Leatzow said no insurer would cover a contractor’s performance on a construction project.
Read More
“If a contractor has no risk, no skin in the game, it takes away from the quality of their performance,” Mr. Leatzow said. “There is no way to insure for damages for errors by the general contractor.”
Any loss as a result of construction errors would be covered by the company’s expected profit on a project, he said. On a small project, the profit might be 8 to 10 percent of the cost, he said, but on an $80 million project the profit probably would be less than 5 percent.
Fay declined to comment on the OSHA fine or any other aspect of the bridge incident.
“All information related to any OSHA citation is of public record. We have nothing additional to add,” said Katie Spear, marketing director for i+iconUSA, a Pittsburgh-based group of companies that includes Fay.
Christopher Robinson, OSHA’s area director, said Wednesday the agency’s investigation determined the contractor made a “serious” mistake, but the incident wasn’t a deliberate disregard for safety and the company doesn’t have a history of safety problems. As a result, the fine issued last week is near the maximum amount of $12,471 for a company in that situation, he said.
“We didn’t determine or prove there was any willful misconduct by the contractor,” Mr. Robinson said. “A very obvious and serious hazardous condition took place, but we weren’t able to determine if there was any willful intent.”
The OSHA citation claims the contractor didn’t do an adequate job of protecting the pipe and its employee on fire watch duty above “did not adequately protect all areas where potential fire hazards existed.”
Mr. Cessna said PennDOT officials went through a step-by-step safety review with Fay immediately after the fire and agreed with the OSHA findings. Mr. Cessna and OSHA said the deficiency was corrected immediately after the fire.
PennDOT and the contractor still are working on the final design for the permanent repair to the bridge, Mr. Cessna said. That work could be done before reconstruction resumes on the bridge in the spring, but it hasn’t been determined whether the bridge will have to be closed during that time.
Fay has notified PennDOT that it is challenging the amount of liquidated damages and the agency will hold hearings to hear those challenges.
The two-year reconstruction project is expected to be done by the end of the year.
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1470.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.