Pittsburgh’s Office of Municipal Investigations has found that credit card payments to a former employee did not violate city code, according to a report released Wednesday, but an investigation by the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office remains active and agents served a related search warrant Tuesday.

Deputy Mayor Jake Pawlak, who also oversees the city’s budget office, said that while “honest mistakes” were made in the use of the credit cards — referred to as “p-cards” — OMI found no widespread misuse.

The payments in question were made to Mario Ashkar, a former contractor working with the city’s farmers markets, which are part of the city Parks and Recreation Department. The Post-Gazette reported in May that City Controller Rachael Heisler was concerned that the payments were improper and contrary to city policy.

Mr. Pawlak said p-card policy dictates that they can’t be used to pay for “professional services.” He said the OMI investigation determined Ashkar’s work did not constitute a professional service, and the report even quotes the Black’s Law Dictionary definition of professional: “One engaged in one of learned professions or in an occupation requiring a high level of training and proficiency.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Heisler, in a letter to City Council in May raising her initial concerns, noted Ashkar had been paid more than $18,000 through the p-card system, including about $6,000 this year up to the point when the city parted ways with Ashkar. The system uses PayPal to pay employees and vendors.

Mr. Pawlak said other city policies had been violated, but no one — namely parks director Kathy Vargas — would be terminated as a result.

“The Gainey administration believes that hard-working exemplary employees who make honest mistakes should be allowed to learn from those mistakes and have an opportunity to do better,” Mr. Pawlak said.

Officials had planned to release the report publicly “before the end of the month,” Mr. Pawlak said, but the city hastened that timeline after investigators from the district attorney’s office served a search warrant Tuesday for records related OMI’s investigative file and the report it issued.

“It’s not entirely clear to us why they are investigating, but we are happy to comply,” Mr. Pawlak said, adding that it appeared to be another instance of “the DA’s office pursuing an issue that has received coverage in the media.”

Advertise with us

He said the DA had requested those documents on numerous occasions, but city officials claimed the records were not public because they concerned personnel matters.

DA investigators stymied

Indeed, the search warrant lays out frustrations by DA detectives as they continued to run into barriers to information they said OMI had no problems turning over in the past.

The search warrant, served specifically on the solicitor’s office, seemed to paint city lawyers as intentionally obtuse.

The DA’s office initiated its investigation May 22, about a week after the suspected p-card mishandling came to light. DA investigators sent a letter to Ms. Heisler requesting records related to the city’s use of p-cards.

The controller’s office provided the records it had been able to obtain by that point. Those records included its own May 28 letter from Ms. Heisler to City Council that indicated she’d requested but not received Ashkar’s employment file, a list of p-card users, training dates for those authorized to use the system, and copies of communications between Ashkar and the parks department.

Advertise with us

Deputy District Attorney Jon Pittman first requested the OMI investigative file Aug. 6, according to the search warrant. OMI Manager Erin Bruni, though, said the DA’s office would have to seek permission from city solicitor Krysia Kubiak.

The search warrant noted in the probable cause section that it “is not standard procedure for OMI to require the solicitor to sign off on” turning over an investigative file.

A voicemail left for Ms. Kubiak by detectives that same day went unreturned, wrote Detective Kevin P. Flanigan, the DA’s investigator who authored the search warrant. Detective Flanigan and Mr. Pittman went to Ms. Kubiak’s office four times in the next week, but she was unavailable each time, the search warrant says.

On the fifth visit, Aug. 19, Ms. Kubiak told the investigators that the OMI file was a personnel matter and thus could not be released.

The search warrant notes that Ms. Kubiak questioned the investigators “multiple times” about who filed a complaint with the DA’s office and why law enforcement was not involved.

Advertise with us

“[She] explained that if something was illegal, law enforcement would turn over the information to the District Attorney’s Office,” Detective Flanigan wrote in the search warrant, noting that he explained to her “that the District Attorney’s Office is law enforcement and has the same powers as police officers.”

Ms. Kubiak, according to the search warrant, told investigators she would not turn over the file unless presented with a subpoena or search warrant. She also told them she didn’t know where the file was at the time.

The search warrant was signed by Common Pleas Judge Jennifer Satler about 10 a.m. Tuesday. It was executed about 20 minutes later.

Other city policies violated; controller has more questions

Mr. Pawlak said that while the p-card policy had not been violated, investigators did find that Ms. Vargas, who hired Ashkar, had violated two unrelated city policies: the “mid-year position request policy” and “exemptions from competitive process” policy.

The OMI report stated that the former policy was violated because Ms. Vargas had approved payments in excess of $10,000 to Ashkar in 2023. The latter was because she did not discuss Ashkar’s employment with the city’s human resources, law, or office of management and budget — in order to create a job description, salary and other information about his work.

Advertise with us

The report determined that Ms. Vargas likely should have created a position for Ashkar, given the extent of the payments, Mr. Pawlak said.

“Director Vargas has readily accepted responsibility for her actions and has already undergone the required p-card retraining on the proper usage and filing of p-card transactions,” Mr. Pawlak said.

Additional oversight of p-card approvals would be put in place for one year, he said, and the results of the OMI investigation would be placed in Ms. Vargas’ personnel file. He said the investigation did not find evidence that would provide grounds for Ms. Vargas’ termination.

The OMI report acknowledged that the entire issue of the p-card payments would likely have never come to light had Ashkar not been charged with alleged ethnic intimidation and other crimes in connection with an incident April 19. Ashkar is accused of tearing down an Israeli flag outside a home on the city’s North Side. Ashkar was fired April 23 once police identified Ashkar as a possible suspect.

Following a court hearing earlier this month, Ashkar and the victims agreed to a deal that Ashkar would complete Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition, a program for first-time offenders. Additionally, Ashkar would have to complete 20 hours of community service at a Jewish nonprofit organization and be on probation for a year with the ability to end early for good behavior. The agreement is contingent upon a judge’s approval.

Advertise with us

Ms. Heisler said in a statement that while her office appreciated OMI’s investigation, there were many unanswered questions.

“Our office continues to have serious concerns about the lack of documentation for these payments, including the lack of any written agreement between parties as to the commencement or termination of the vendor’s engagement with the City,” she wrote. “We also remain very curious about the altered invoice (and subsequent approval) for work allegedly completed in April 2024.”

Preliminary findings have also raised confusion about what “professional services” means within the Parks and Recreation Department, and across other city departments and agencies, Ms. Heisler wrote.

“This is further clouded by the assertion that the contractor in question was approached about full-time work, which we believe demonstrates that the services provided were, in fact, ‘professional,’” she wrote.

City Councilman Bob Charland, who previously said he would not approve any p-card payments until better safeguards were in place, criticized the administration’s failure to notify council members about the investigation or any proposed changes.

Advertise with us

“I have doubts about whether the Office of Municipal Investigations (OMI) can conduct an impartial investigation to the office to which they report, as OMI directly reports to the Office of Management and Budget’s Chief Operating Officer and Administrative Officer,” Mr. Charland said in a prepared statement. He added that the district attorney’s investigation is a necessary next step.

Council members voted to delete a $1,200 payment to Ashkar in May for services performed in April. City Council members said then that they were uncomfortable with the p-card system and wanted a more thorough review. Until then, council had been approving p-card transactions at committee meetings each week.

City officials said later that week that the payments violated city policy but not state ethics law, an issue that Ms. Heisler had initially raised in her letter to council. Maria Montano, then the city’s communications director, said the city solicitor’s office did not believe ethics laws were violated because multiple technical standards involving post-employment activity and other areas were not met.

Ms. Heisler has said that the state Ethics Commission should review the matter, due to its expertise and independence from Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration.

Vargas acted alone, saw potential, dismissed prior firing

Emails obtained by the Post-Gazette through a Right-to-Know request showed that Ms. Vargas shouldered the blame for the improper p-card payments. Ms. Vargas wrote that she knew of Ashkar’s previous employment with the city, but didn’t know them personally or professionally outside of that.

Advertise with us

“At the end of the day, I did authorize Mario working for us and I am the only person to blame if there is a problem with our having worked with him,” Ms. Vargas wrote in an email to Mr. Pawlak, Chief Operating and Administrative Officer Lisa Frank, Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt and other city officials May 13.

Ashkar had been fired by the city’s Department of Public Safety in November 2022 after working six months in the Office of Special Events. Lee Schmidt, director of the department, cited Ashkar’s behavior and poor performance in a termination letter.

Information released Wednesday indicated that Ashkar “would call off unexpectedly or not show up for events” and that Ms. Vargas had “heard anecdotally about him not getting along with co-workers, reassigning himself without permission and not following the directives of management ... just a difficult person to manage.”

But Ms. Vargas emailed Ashkar signaling she thought that Ashkar would be a good fit for CitiParks jobs when openings came up.

Information released Wednesday shows that Ms. Vargas thought Ashkar’s firing was the fault of the Department of Public Safety.

Advertise with us

“I felt that it was a way for management to not deal with their own deficiencies in creating a supportive work culture,” she told investigators, “so I was disappointed because I felt that by letting go a new team member that was not thriving, it was also not addressing the real issue. It was nothing personal, had this decision been made around any staff I would have been equally disappointed.”

Mr. Pawlak was adamant that Ms. Vargas had no prior relationship with Ashkar and that she had not been influenced by anyone elsewhere in the administration to hire Ashkar.

Emails also showed that the last invoice Ashkar made to the city appears to have been altered. One shows that Ashkar worked 12 hours the week after the firing, while the other shows Ashkar worked no hours. Ms. Heisler has said it’s unclear why that invoice was revised, and who asked for the revision.

The OMI report released Wednesday indicated that Ashkar had appeared at a Winter Market in Greenfield on April 26 at the request of a city employee, after being terminated, and that accounts for the four-hour difference between the two invoices.

Mr. Pawlak did not immediately offer any explanation for the discrepancy on Wednesday.

Advertise with us

He added that Ms. Vargas and Ashkar initially met at a farmers market in the city when the special events office was transitioning from the Department of Public Safety to the Department of Parks and Recreation.

“They discussed these opportunities, but there was no outside [contact] other than in the context of that city work,” Mr. Pawlak said.

Concerning the overall p-card system in general, Mr. Pawlak said OMI’s investigation determined the policy is not the issue, but its implementation. City officials have started looking at long-term trends in transactions with single vendors, to see whether or not the p-card system should be used.

“Those are not necessarily violations, but they would indicate that it is likely more appropriate to have a contract of a different form in place, rather than making p-card payments,” Mr. Pawlak said.