After controversial payments made on the city’s credit cards last year prompted three separate investigations, an audit from Pittsburgh City Controller Rachael Heisler found that lax internal rules allowed workers to charge expenses that went beyond the cards’ intended uses.

The audit was sparked last May, when Ms. Heisler flagged thousands of dollars in payments to Mario Ashkar, who had been arrested the week prior on multiple charges including ethnic intimidation and criminal mischief after an alleged antisemitic incident in April 2023 in the Mexican War Streets. Records showed the city’s Department of Parks and Recreation had been paying him for working at farmers markets — and using the city’s p-card system rather than the normal contracting process.

Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration said their own internal investigation found no direct violations of the city’s p-card policy, but Ms. Heisler’s audit showed a disconnect between the policy and implementation.

Of 89 transactions between 2023 and 2024 that auditors reviewed, only eight were allowable expenses under the city’s existing policy. A key portion of the report calls on city lawmakers to tighten those rules to “help prevent waste, fraud and abuse,” Ms. Heisler said in a statement.

Advertise with us

A third investigation in the city’s use of the cards was launched by District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., who carried out a search warrant last August for records related to the Gainey administration’s own internal probe. The DA’s office did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The city’s Office of Management and Budget outlines what p-cards can and cannot be used to purchase. When interviewing members of the department, auditors found that many were not familiar with the rules governing their use.

The training is presented to staff at the beginning of each year.

The cards are supposed to be used for things like small-dollar food purchases, conference registrations and subscriptions. Professional services — such as what Ashkar was being paid for — “should never be put on a p-card,” according to the audit.

After the city’s payments to Ashkar came to light, the former employee agreed to a deal with the victims that included community service and participation in Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition, a program that allows people to have charges removed from their record.

Advertise with us

Legislation approved yearly by city council for nearly 40 years has given the parks department the ability to pay for professional services without going through the standard procurement process, which can often be lengthy. However it doesn’t specify that the vendors can be paid using the p-card.

One of the audit’s recommendations is that the Parks and Recreation department specifically include the usage of p-cards in that yearly legislation – which will make it explicitly clear that the department is permitted to pay for those services via payment cards.

The department is in the process of amending the 2025 legislation to include p-cards, according to the audit.

In a response to the audit, the parks department acknowledged the vagueness of the rules governing p-cards, and said it has begun working with the procurement team to clarify them.

“The City of Pittsburgh Code definition of ‘professional services’ leaves a lot up to interpretation,” the department’s response said. “We are committed to working with OMB to provide more clarity around this definition so that we can more confidently categorize our service providers.”

Advertise with us

When the Gainey administration released its own investigation’s findings, Jake Pawlak, the director of the Office of Management and Budget, said that Ashkar’s work did not constitute professional services because it was not a learned profession and didn’t require a “high level of training.”

That’s typical of parks department contractors, the bureau said in its response to Ms. Heisler’s audit.

“The vast majority of the services we require are non-technical and the providers do not need a college degree or special certification/expertise to engage in their practice,” the department wrote.

City policy says the cards shouldn’t be used to pay vendors more than $10,000 in any single year — a rule the parks department broke twice in 2023, according to the audit. One of those vendors was Ashkar, who was paid $18,000 in that year. Neither Ashkar nor the other vendor had a legal agreement with the city at the time they were paid, the controller’s office found.

Parks and Recreation staff told the controller’s office that some of these overpayments could have been due to a lack of communication within the department.

Advertise with us

After they received a copy of the audit’s findings, department leaders have been working to create an internal practice to better track spending on vendors, they wrote.

But the audit found deeper problems with the department’s internal communications, documentation and training programs that led to widespread misunderstanding among employees of the rules that govern how they can use city credit cards.

“Awareness of OMB's P-Card Policy was not consistent among the staff members,” auditors found.

The department said it agrees with the controller’s recommendations and noted that they have already started working to implement them.