A little over one month before improper usage of Pittsburgh’s p-card program came to light, an employee was raising concerns internally, questioning payments to a city contractor who was later arrested regarding an unrelated matter, according to documents the Post-Gazette obtained through a Right-To-Know Law request.
In an email dated April 3, Sheila McKenzie, a finance administrator who works with the Parks and Recreation Department, sent an email to department Director Kathryn Vargas flagging payments made to Mario Ashkar, who had been hired as an independent contractor to work with the Parks and Recreation department on its farmers market program.
“It has just got me worried about overuse,” Ms. McKenzie wrote in the email. “Especially, since there aren’t any supporting documents other than an invoice (and your approval).”
In the email, she attached a screenshot of a portion of the city’s policy that expressly prohibits the use of p-card payments for “recurring transactions for the same vendor.”
Additionally, according to the documents, there were concerns that Ashkar had been paid more than the $10,000 limit the previous year and was on track to be overpaid again in 2024.
Ashkar had been receiving payments via p-card for almost a year, having started in the position in July 2023 and continuing until the city terminated the relationship in April after learning of pending criminal charges against Ashkar, who was arrested on May 9 on charges of ethnic intimidation. Police said they have video of Ashkar pulling down an Israeli flag from outside a North Side home.
Read More
Ms. McKenzie’s concern wasn’t the first time the arrangement had raised eyebrows. Nearly a year prior, Ms. McKenzie hinted at some confusion regarding the handling of the payments.
She wrote in an Aug. 22, 2023 email to Jen Lemasters, the city’s special events administrator, “I finally received some solid confirmation from Kathryn that you would take care of Farmers Market entertainment… with the exception of some stuff that comes from Mario Ashkar — whatever that is about …?”
The city regularly hires people to do things like make balloon animals or paint kids faces at the farmers markets, many of which are often paid via p-card.
Shortly after the arrest, City Controller Rachael Heisler sounded the alarm about Ashkar’s payments, which were made via p-card to a PayPal account, prompting an audit and an internal investigation.
Ms. Vargas, who in other documents recently obtained by the Post-Gazette took fault for the improper payments, responded to Ms. McKenzie and thanked her for flagging the situation.
“I do have a contract with Mario from 2023 that I will need to dig up …” Ms. Vargas wrote, referencing what would be a supporting document. However, she did not address Ms. McKenzie’s concerns about the p-card usage.
Throughout multiple records requests from the Post-Gazette, a contract for Ashkar has not turned up, and a previous statement from Ms. Heisler indicates that she also has not seen proof of that contract.
Newly obtained records reveal a number of other details about the payments, including that Ashkar’s final invoice to the city appears to have been altered.
Ms. Vargas said in one email that work with Ashkar had been terminated “effective immediately” on April 23, “upon learning about the pending charges.”
A Right-to-Know Law request of the city turned up two different invoices dated April 30, 2024. One showed Ashkar working a total of 48 hours for the month, including 12 hours the week of April 17-23 and 12 hours between April 24-28, which would have been after Ms. Vargas said she had terminated Ashkar’s employment.
The second invoice, also dated April 30, 2024, showed Ashkar working a total of 40 hours, including 12 hours between April 8-16 and 16 hours between April 17-23. No hours were shown for the final week of the month.
This invoice totaled $1,200, which matches the final payment approved by City Council members at the end of May. In total, Ashkar received close to $25,000 for their work.
Ms. Heisler said in a previous statement that there remains a number of unanswered questions, including why the invoice was revised and whether Ashkar was instructed to revise the invoice this way.
“Every step of this investigation seems to raise more questions than it answers. Most concerning to me right now is the fact that, according to news reports, this person may have back-dated and falsified an invoice to be paid for work that may not have been done,” Ms. Heisler’s statement said. “And that this may have been authorized by the person’s supervisor. If true, that is egregious and unacceptable.”
Ms. Heisler attempted to launch her own investigation into Ashkar’s payments but has said multiple times that Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration “refuses to cooperate.”
However, the controller has launched an audit of the parks department’s use of p-cards.
Mr. Gainey’s office referred the situation to the Office of Municipal Investigations, which handles citizen complaints of civil or criminal misconduct filed against non-elected city employees.
The mayor’s office declined to comment.
Other city officials have reiterated the claim that work with Ashkar was terminated once they were made aware of the criminal charges and that April 23 was their last day. However, Ashkar wasn’t arrested until May 9 for the incident that occurred on April 19.
Ms. Heisler is seeking further clarity on “when and why” the city determined it would terminate business with Ashkar.
Ashkar had previously been fired from city employment after about six months working special events in the public safety department.
Ashkar was fired in November 2022. Although no specific reasoning has been revealed, a termination letter signed by Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt said that the two had “repeatedly discussed” Ashkar’s “performance and behavior deficiencies.”
Shortly after termination, Ms. Vargas was included in an email from the public safety department informing her of Ashkar’s termination. That email noted the position Ashkar previously held would be moving into the Parks and Recreation Department.
Five months later, Ms. Vargas emailed Ashkar to offer them the farmers market job.
“I absolutely welcome you applying for positions that are of interest in Citiparks,” she wrote in an email to Ashkar on May 3, 2023. “I feel that you would be an awesome fit on our Community Enrichment Team because it’s like Special Events Meets Festivals and Arts.”
In an email to the Director of the Office of Management and Budget Jake Pawlak, Ms. Vargas wrote that she was the one who requested that the p-card be used to pay Ashkar.
“I did not know that we were not allowed to do that — and the reason had to do with the timelines of payments,” she wrote. “We do have artists and others that we do pay in this manner due to the fact that they are independent contractors and often need payment more immediately than our system allows.”
However, Ashkar’s first payment for their farmers market work was paid via an invoice, the proper channel for payment for independent contractors according to city policy. It’s still unclear why payments were then transitioned to p-cards after.
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.