As Pittsburgh officials scrambled to gather information after the arrest of a city contractor on ethnic intimidation charges, the director of parks and recreation stepped up and took the blame for hiring the former full-time city employee as a contractor.

That hiring later led to a city admission that the contractor, Mario Ashkar, had been paid via credit card, in violation of municipal policy. The revelations are contained in city emails the Post-Gazette obtained through a Right to Know Law request.

“At the end of the day, I did authorize Mario working for us and I am the only person to blame if there is a problem with our having worked with him,” wrote the parks and recreation director, Kathryn Vargas, in an email to Deputy Mayor Jake Pawlak, Chief Operating and Administrative Officer Lisa Frank, Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt and other city officials on May 13.

The Mayor’s office and Ms. Vargas declined to comment.

Advertise with us

Ashkar had been charged May 8 in connection with alleged antisemitic vandalism on the city’s North Side. Pittsburgh police charged Ashkar, 36, of Perry South, with ethnic intimidation, criminal mischief, theft by unlawful taking and disorderly conduct. He is accused of ripping an Israeli flag off of a home in the Mexican War Streets on April 19.

City Controller Rachael Heisler informed City Council and administration officials May 10, a Friday, about Ashkar’s affiliation with city government and the fact that Ashkar had been paid through the city’s p-card system; Ms. Heisler raised concerns about the propriety of those payments, which totaled more than $18,000.

In a letter, Ms. Heisler raised alarms that Ashkar had been receiving payment since June 2023 in the form of PayPal transactions.

“This would seem to be in violation of the State Ethics Act, which prohibits a former Public Employee from receiving compensation from their formal governmental body in any act of ‘representation,’ including working as an independent contractor within one year of leaving service,” the letter said.

City officials later admitted the payments violated city policy.

Advertise with us

At the time, administration officials emailed one another concerning Ms. Heisler’s findings. The responses by Mr. Pawlak and Deputy Solicitor Jesse Exilus were redacted in their entirety in copies of the emails that the city supplied to the Post-Gazette as part of its Right To Know request.

By that Monday morning, reporters were asking questions of city spokeswoman Ms. Montano, questions she shared with top city officials.

That’s when Ms. Vargas responded.

“I met Mario through the Farmers Markets so I don’t have any personal, social, or professional affiliation with him,” she wrote, according to documents from the Right to Know request..

Ms. Vargas noted that she was aware of Ashkar’s previous work for the city and of the dates of his previous employment. “I did not know much about him outside of that,” she wrote.

Advertise with us

According to documents supplied through the Right to Know request, Ashkar had been fired at the end of November 2022 -– after nearly six months of him working special events in public safety. The termination letter states: “As you know, since June 6, 2022, we have repeatedly discussed your performance and behavior deficiencies with you.” That letter was signed by Mr. Schmidt, the director of public safety.

Just five months later, Ms. Vargas emailed Ashkar and offered a $30-per-hour contracting job for organizing entertainment at city farmers markets, Ms. Vargas also wrote that she thought Ashkar would make a good city employee and offered to sent alerts about job openings.

“I absolutely welcome you applying for positions that are of interest in Citiparks,” Ms. Vargas wrote in an email to Ashkar on May 3, 2023. “I feel that you would be an awesome fit on our Community Enrichment Team because it’s like Special Events Meets Festivals and Arts.”

Ms. Vargas added, “I will let you know when I see opportunities coming up the pike.”

That enthusiasm apparently had cooled in the intervening year.

Advertise with us

In her email to administration officials after Ashkar’s arrest, Ms. Vargas informed them that “upon learning of the investigation,” she had terminated Ashkar “effective immediately” on April 24, but she added that Ashkar’s last day was going to be April 30, “regardless of the investigation.”

There was no indication why the city had decided not to continue contracting with Ashkar; a year earlier, Ms. Vargas had indicated that “we are likely to work with him again for the 2024 market season,” records show.