City Controller Rachael Heisler is calling on Pittsburgh Public Schools to limit its use of procurement cards to help avoid potential fraud and non-compliant transactions.
As of June 30 Pittsburgh Public had 463 active p-cards, which are issued to certain employees to simplify financial processes and reduce labor costs, a Thursday report from Ms. Heisler found. That’s a change from 2021 when there were 738 active cards after the district opened 158 new ones and closed 433.
But between 2021 and 2024 the district had nearly 60,000 transactions totaling $11.6 million.
“PPS has made significant progress in assessing and improving the p-card system over the past few years, but our office believes there are still too many p-cards in use,” Ms. Heisler, who serves as controller for the city and school district, said in a statement.
The district in its own statement acknowledged accomplishments it’s made in recent years.
“We are encouraged that the report recognizes the significant progress PPS has made to enhance our p-card system,” the statement reads. “Key accomplishments include a 37.3% reduction in active p-cards, a 14% decrease in total p-card spending, and the expanded use of e-procurement platforms. These improvements reflect our continued dedication to reducing risks associated with p-card usage while maintaining the efficiency necessary to support the needs of our schools.”
Read More
But the problem, Ms. Heisler said, is that p-cards carry a greater risk of unauthorized and inappropriate purchases when compared to traditional purchasing methods. And carelessness with card information, fraud and missing out on preferred vendor pricing can potentially lead to financial losses for the district, the report reads.
By limiting the number of cards in use, the district can help mitigate potential fraud and non-compliant transactions while creating more manageable data for the controller to complete audits more regularly, Ms. Heisler said.
As things currently stand, the district’s operations department had the highest p-card transactions between 2021 and 2024, totaling $5.4 million, the report found. That was followed by school-based purchases, $3.5 million; instructional support, $1.6 million; technology, $608,000; and administrative, almost $384,000.
The majority of purchases are going toward facility maintenance. Following that is Amazon purchases, which between 2021 and 2024 added up to $2.2 million, or 23% of expenditures.
The addition of Amazon to PPS’s e-procurement process was an effort by the district to streamline the procurement process, the report reads. But between 2021 and June, $13,000 was spent on Amazon Prime subscriptions through district p-cards, which are redundant because the district has a Business Prime account. That account has certain benefits such as special pricing that may be going unused with Amazon p-card purchases, Ms. Heisler said.
Ms. Heisler has now asked the district to cancel all p-cards with Amazon Prime subscription charges. An emphasis, she said, should instead be placed on training and transitioning p-card holders to use the e-procurement process when making purchases from listed vendors, including Amazon.
“We understand that situations arise where same/next day delivery may be necessary, but this is an area where increased oversight can easily be attained for many purchases,” the report reads.
The other problem, Ms. Heisler found, is 39 cards are permitted to have transaction limits exceeding $500. Typically purchases made with p-cards cannot exceed $500 on the same day with the same vendor based on district policy.
According to the report, increased limits are approved by the Department of Finance for one-time emergency purchases and for cardholders that need sustained access to same-day purchases such as plumbers and electricians.
But audits of those p-cards “routinely show a high-volume of findings for transactions over $500,” the report reads, which is in violation of written guidelines.
“While the Finance Department authorizes certain cardholders to exceed the $500 transaction limit, these transactions still conflict with procurement card usage policies,” the report reads. “If it has been determined that certain cardholders necessitate a higher purchasing capacity, a more formal process should be put in place. Increased limits should be very selective, and based on job responsibilities and purchase patterns.”
Because of the increased risk that coincides with heightened transition limits, Ms. Heisler is prioritizing audits of p-cards with transaction limits over $500 annually. The change, she said, could also be accompanied with advanced monthly oversight.
Ms. Heisler’s report comes months after the city of Pittsburgh faced controversy over the use of a credit card to pay a contractor who was later arrested for his alleged role in an antisemitic incident.
The occurrence led to Pittsburgh’s Office of Municipal Investigations finding that the payments did not violate city code, calling it instead an “honest mistake.”
The investigation found no widespread misuse.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.