When Pine-Richland parents packed a school board meeting in the fall of 2023 to argue over whether 14 novels should stay in district libraries, it wasn’t just a local fight. It was part of a nationwide surge in book challenges and bans.
During the 2024-25 school year, there were 6,870 instances of book bans across 23 states and 87 public school districts, according to a report from PEN America, a free-expression advocacy organization. That’s 22,800 cases of book bans across 45 states and 451 districts since 2021 when a national book ban campaign began, the report found.
What that shows, Sabrina Baêta, senior program manager of PEN America’s Freedom to Read initiative, told the Post-Gazette, is that book bans are becoming normalized.
“Teachers and educators are now preparing themselves for inevitably when they have to face book bans or pushback on what materials they're including within their curriculum,” Ms. Baêta said. “Something that felt just very un-American, Orwellian, a few years ago continues to be a rampant crisis.”
PEN America defines a school book ban as any action taken against a book based on its content. As a result of challenges, administrative decisions or direct or threatened action by government officials, the book is either completely removed from student access or its availability is restricted or diminished.
The top five banned books in 2024-25 included: “A Clockwork Orange” by Anthony Burgess with 23 bans; “Sold” by Patricia McCormick, 20 bans; “Breathless” by Jennifer Niven, 20 bans; “Last Night at the Telegraph Club” by Malinda Lo, 19 bans; and “A Court of Mist and Fury” by Sarah J. Mass, 18 bans.
Read More
The top five banned authors include: Stephen King, with 206 bans across 87 unique titles; Ellen Hopkins, 167 bans across 18 titles; Sarah J. Mass, 162 bans across 21 titles; Jodi Picoult, 62 bans across 23 titles; and Yūsei Matsui, 54 bans across 22 titles.
Jodi Picoult’s book “Nineteen Minutes” has been challenged in the Blackhawk Area School District and at the Pine-Richland School District.
Pine-Richland was most recently at the center of controversy surrounding library books. School directors in March passed major amendments to a library book policy to include changes to the reconsideration process if a book is challenged. It also increased the timeline for purchasing books and added language regarding parental rights.
The changed policy came after 14 books in the middle and high school libraries were challenged in October 2023. The challenges launched a review of the novels. By April 2024 Superintendent Brian Miller determined the books could remain in libraries.
After that determination was made, board members chose to review the policy, ultimately making major changes. But it led to intense board meetings that lasted for hours and where residents, and at times school directors, would argue.
The Blackhawk Area School District in Beaver County also saw 12 books challenged in 2023.
The challenges launched a review of the district’s library book policy and changes were made to the book review process while allowing students and parents to challenge books that are not compatible with “their values or fundamental religious beliefs,” the policy read. The policy was eventually reverted back to its original form.
Here are three key points from the report:
National debate
PEN America attributed book bans over the past four years to a “misleading campaign” aimed at protecting children while advocating for parental rights.
That idea, the report reads, “has been weaponized to diminish students’ First Amendment rights in schools, sow distrust in librarians and educators, and diminish the ability of authors and illustrators to connect with their intended audiences. In this upside-down world, any rights of young people as students are somehow subservient to the absolute rights of their parents.”
Today, states such as Florida, Texas and Tennessee are leading the way in book removals and challenges.
Florida in the 2023-24 school year saw over 700 books “removed or discontinued” from school districts, Central Florida Public Media reported, citing a release from the Florida Department of Education. That’s an increase of almost 400 books from the previous school year.
In Texas, legislators recently passed a new law that gives school boards, not librarians, the final say over what materials are allowed in school libraries, The Texas Tribune reported. The law went into effect Sept. 1.
And in Tennessee, the Age-Appropriate Materials Act broadly restricts books if they contain nudity, sexual abuse, sexual content or “excessive violence,” WBIR reported in May. That’s led to hundreds of books being removed from school libraries.
Oftentimes, the report found, books are removed over the fear of laws. PEN America identified 2,520 book ban cases where the bans were influenced by pressure imposed by the presence or threat of state laws. Of those, only 3% were triggered by a law requiring a book to be removed. The rest came from fear districts had of being out of compliance.
PEN America also pointed to federal efforts. President Donald Trump’s executive orders aimed at “ending radical indoctrination” in K-12 schools, defending women’s sports and ending diversity, equity and inclusion efforts in the government “were used as justification” in July for the removal of almost 600 books from Department of Defense Education Activity schools on military bases, the report reads.
How do book bans impact schools?
According to the report, book bans can decrease student engagement in reading, discourage their critical thinking and interfere with an educator's ability to teach.
The efforts add additional strain to a system already facing teacher shortages, funding cuts, chronic absenteeism and pandemic-related learning loss. Teachers and librarians are now forced to spend more time cataloging books and overseeing processes to comply with legislation and providing parents with alternative options.
At the same time, the report pointed to book fairs, book donations and scholarships being challenged for content, as well as textbooks and curricula. The report cited an instance in Florida last year where a biology textbook was formally challenged due to concerns over climate change, evolution, the pandemic and masking.
“The onslaught of these campaigns upon public schools attacks the very purpose of public education — to educate all students, to generate empathy and understanding for an informed citizenry, and to serve as a great equalizer for students from all backgrounds,” the report reads.
Is there pushback?
For the first time since PEN America began tracking book bans, the organization logged “the robust network of advocates fighting back publicly against censorship,” the report reads.
Of the 87 districts impacted by book bans this year, 70 contained evidence of a public response against censorship. Local districts including Pine-Richland have also seen intense pushback to policy changes, with many residents pushing for all books to be available to students.
“It just goes to show that communities want these books,” Ms. Baêta said. “Communities want these books to be available for their students and for their communities, and that there's a lot of people who are fighting really hard to make sure that those books return to shelves.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.