When Cornell social studies teacher Amy Palo prepares a lesson these days, she sometimes thinks twice about what she’s going to say to her high school students.
“I am thinking … should I reword this? Do I need to provide further explanation so they understand this isn't me sub-tweeting current events?” she said.
Her caution reflects the tense political climate that seemingly reached its breaking point last month when conservative activist Charlie Kirk was shot and killed. The death of the 31-year-old has left educators across the region on edge, with many worrying lessons and online comments could be misconstrued.
Stories have swept the news in recent weeks of K-12 teachers and college professors being fired for remarks made in the wake of Kirk’s killing. And many instances have been reported of comments being taken out of context or online attacks targeting the wrong people.
“These tragic circumstances create a lot of [emotion] and you don't ever want anyone to misinterpret something that you’ve said or done,” Tom Ralston, University of Pittsburgh assistant professor and former Avonworth superintendent, said.
Mr. Ralston added that people are “thinking very purposefully about how they might be stating something,” or how they’re preparing a classroom lesson.
Read More
Even still, instances of misunderstanding are happening nationwide, including in Indiana County.
There, a Homer-Center school director faced scrutiny after she said a Facebook post she made the day Kirk was killed was taken out of context.
Some community members called for Misty Hunt’s resignation from the school board because of her post reading, “One down, hundreds to go.” The post was meant to be accompanied by a video of milkweed seeds blowing out her truck window, Ms. Hunt said during a September board meeting streamed by the Homer City-based WCCS Radio. But the video did not post, Ms. Hunt said.
She said she went about her day, not realizing Kirk had been killed or that the video had not been posted. After learning about the shooting, she checked social media and saw her post being shared, with most thinking it was made about Kirk.
“Had I known about Kirk’s assassination I certainly would have chosen my words much more carefully,” Ms. Hunt said during the meeting. “It was simply the wrong post at the wrong time.”
Ms. Hunt, who did not respond to an email seeking comment, decided to step back from the board for the months of October and November “and allow the community to decide if I should return in the November election.”
It’s a scene happening nationwide.
In South Carolina, a teacher's aide was allegedly fired over a post sharing a statement Kirk made where he said it’s “worth it to have a cost of, unfortunately, some gun deaths every single year,” to be able to have the right to bear arms, ABC News reported. The aide is now suing the Spartanburg County School District Five, the school board and superintendent.
A former teacher in Iowa also filed a lawsuit against Oskaloosa Schools and its superintendent after he was allegedly fired for posting “1 Nazi down” following the fatal shooting.
And following Kirk’s killing, school leaders in both Florida and Texas honed in on educators, with Texas leaders urging residents to report “reprehensible and inappropriate content on social media,” The Washington Post reported.
Locally, this isn’t the first time local school leaders have come under fire for social media posts.
In November, several local school leaders were called on by community members for social media posts made regarding election results.
And Mr. Ralston pointed to the 2020 murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis, which sparked Black Lives Matter protests nationwide that summer.
“It's really important during those times to be a really good listener and try your best to help them navigate through those situations,” Mr. Ralston said. “They're hard times and they really require a lot, especially out of school leaders, but also out of teachers, because they're dealing with it on the front line with their students and classrooms.”
Local reaction
For two and a half weeks in 2016, the Cornell School District found a firestorm. That year, a group of Cornell cheerleaders took a knee during the national anthem in protest of the treatment of Black people at a Friday night football game.
The event was attended by a group of area veterans.
Misinformation quickly spread and Superintendent Aaron Thomas was wrongfully accused of setting up the veterans by inviting them to serve as a color guard during the game when he knew the cheerleaders were planning a protest. Mr. Thomas told the Post-Gazette recently that he did not know about the protest.
The school leader fielded death threats, all from people out-of-state. He received thousands of emails and his phone was bombarded with calls. The district was forced to postpone homecoming. Spectators at football games were limited. And security was increased.
“It was such a wild situation that just got out of control,” Mr. Thomas recently said.
Eventually the criticism died down, although Mr. Thomas at times still receives messages from people upset about the incident.
But for those at Cornell during that time, the incident sticks with them today.
Ms. Palo, the high school social studies teacher, remembers the district receiving phone calls in 2016 where people claimed, “‘This is civics 101. Those kids can’t kneel.’”
But in reality, Ms. Palo said, “Civics 101 will tell you the exact opposite of that.” In response, Ms. Palo pursued the James Madison Fellowship through which she received her graduate degree in political science.
Fast forward to 2025 and Ms. Palo said everyone should have a “healthy bit of caution.”
Educators, Ms. Palo said, should be “informed about what's happening in your own community when you're deciding on what materials you might be using, or images you might be showing, or things that you might be discussing in class.”
At the Highlands School District, in Natrona Heights, things have been quiet, Superintendent Monique Mawhinney said. Teachers heavily follow all state academic standards as well as Common Core standards for English and math to ensure consistency across classrooms.
Back at Cornell, the district has taken steps to help combat misinformation about current events, including creating a news literacy program in 2023.
District leaders are also focused on providing students with “the best opportunities we can” while instilling kindness and open-mindedness, Mr. Thomas said.
“We're trying to educate kids to the best of our ability and have them have their own opinions and think for themselves, but also understand each other,” Mr. Thomas said.
“And, I'll be honest, usually the students are very open to that and receptive to that and respond in the appropriate manner. It's the adults that don't.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.