During the past year-and-a-half, frustrated parents, students and teachers turned out in droves, fighting to save their Pittsburgh Public school at risk of closure.

But that fight, at least for some, has seemingly died down.

Over the past two weeks, fewer than 100 people turned up to speak at nine public hearings held at the district’s administration building for each of the nine schools proposed to close.

For some, four speakers showed up. The hearing for the closure of Miller PreK-5 only drew one person, who spoke virtually. Three hearings — including for the closure of the Friendship building, which houses Montessori PreK-5; Fulton PreK-5 and Woolslair PreK-5 — saw around 20.

Advertise with us

Three hearings took place last week with the remaining six occurring early this week. Most of the time two meetings fell per day, one at 5 p.m. and one at 7 p.m. Those wishing to speak could do so in person at the administration building or virtually.

“The schools that we expected to have high participation or higher participation did, and then some that have been a little bit more quiet or haven't really spoken up didn't,” school board President Gene Walker told the Post-Gazette on Thursday.

The state-required hearings, he said, went “fine. I don't think anybody said anything that we hadn't already heard or weren't expecting. Folks are passionate about their schools, about their kids, and that is completely understandable.”

The state-required hearings were the next step in the district potentially implementing the plan it has been working on since January 2024 when officials began searching for options in response to declining enrollments and a growing budget deficit.

The plan has taken several different forms over the past year-and-a-half. But now, nine schools are up for possible closure: Baxter (Student Achievement Center); Friendship (Montessori PreK-5); Fulton PreK-5; McKelvey (Miller PreK-5); Morrow primary; Schiller 6-8; Spring Hill PreK-5; Woolslair PreK-5; and Manchester PreK-8.

Advertise with us

Two schools could open — Northview PreK-5 and Sci-Tech 6-8 — while several others would undergo grade reconfigurations to follow a K-5, 6-8 and 9-12 model.

During the course of the past two weeks, comments ran the gamut: some pointed to equity issues surrounding the proposed closure of their schools. Many focused on how schools serve as community hubs in neighborhoods across the city. Others questioned data being used by the district. And most called on the board to save their school.

“Stand up for our students,” community member Allie Petonic said during last week’s hearing for Morrow. “Don’t close or displace them.”

Morrow was one of the several hearings that drew only a handful of speakers. Last week, the first hearing for the closer of the Baxter building, which houses the Student Achievement Center, drew seven people. Under the plan, services such as credit recovery would move feeder schools. But several people raised concerns about the impact the change could have on students.

The trend of few speakers continued at hearings for Manchester and Schiller, with four speakers showing up at each meeting to raise concerns about changing grade structure while questioning why the district would close a successful STEAM — science, technology, engineering, arts and math — program at Schiller, a STEAM magnet.

Advertise with us

But others drew crowds of people. Montessori parents, and even a 6-year-old student, pushed for the school to stay in its current building, citing its more central location while questioning the district’s figures for how much the Friendship building would cost to renovate.

That continued throughout this week, with more than 20 people speaking on behalf of Fulton and Woolslair. At Fulton, many raised questions around equity and pressed the board for answers as to why they would close a successful school.

Parent Shannon Striner called school closures “shortsighted” and “dangerous.”

At Woolslair, many pointed to the school model and said the school board should raise up its success and try to have other schools replicate its achievements. Many also questioned the district’s decision to eliminate all elementary magnets aside from Montessori. Woolslair is a partial STEAM magnet.

And while most spoke on behalf of their school buildings, many speakers also touched on the hearings themselves, questioning why they were held at the administration building rather than at individual schools. Some returned to frustrations voiced last year when a series of public input sessions were held over the summer, a choice that made it difficult for families to attend because of summer vacations and other obligations. And at least one school director asked that the state-required hearings not be held over the summer due to similar concerns.

Advertise with us

“The difference between what you want to do and what you’re legally obligated to do is stark,” Rebecca Maclean told directors during the hearing for Fulton.

Mr. Walker suggested “time is always an issue.”

“We could have waited, I guess, until the start of school, but then that would have presented some additional scheduling issues,” Mr. Walker said. “So I think we did what we thought was best and would help keep the process moving at a decent pace.”

Looking forward, Mr. Walker said Superintendent Wayne Walters will “take into account what we heard” during the hearings and that board members will ask questions based on the comments.

The board now has to wait three months before voting on school closures. In the meantime, district leaders will continue work on an implementation plan that will guide possible districtwide changes including proposed school closures.

“This is an ever changing and ever moving process that we continue to seek community input in as we go forward, and we'll continue to do that,” Mr. Walker said. “And while we might not end up doing everything that the community wants, I think by the end you will see a significant influence of what our community has asked for and requested in the final plan. And so for that I think we can feel pretty comfortable that we've done our job.”