Parents and community members came out Monday evening in a seemingly last-ditch effort to persuade Pittsburgh Public School leaders to hold off on a proposed school closure plan.
More than 50 people spoke during a public hearing at the district’s Oakland administration building, many of whom also participated in a rally held by the advocacy group 412 Justice, calling for school directors to hold off on a vote to open state-required public hearings for the possible permanent closure of nine school buildings while expressing frustration over the situation they’re in as parents.
“We as parents on one hand don’t want our precious school communities to close for a half-baked plan but we are also in a situation where we’re unable to plan for our children’s future more than 12 months in advance,” Meredith Knight, a Fulton parent, said. “So here we are, not knowing whether it’s better to ask you to yes vote or to no vote.”
School directors on Wednesday will consider a resolution to open state-required public hearings for the potential closure of Baxter, which houses the Student Achievement Center; Friendship, which houses Montessori PreK-5; Fulton PreK-5; McKelvey, which houses Miller PreK-5; Morrow PreK-8; Schiller 6-8; Spring Hill PreK-5; Woolslair PreK-5; and Manchester PreK-8.
It is part of a school closure plan the board has been considering over the past year-and-a-half based on a growing budget deficit and declining enrollments.
In that time the proposed plan has changed several times, the most recent being in March when officials temporarily postponed a vote to open the hearings. The decision came after parents and residents again called on the board to hold off on a vote and some directors asked for more information related to finances, transportation and capital improvement costs before moving forward.
Read More
At the time, the board was considering opening hearings to shutter 10 schools: Friendship; Fulton PreK-5; Miller PreK-5; Spring Hill PreK-5; Woolslair PreK-5; King PreK-8; Morrow PreK-8; Schiller 6-8; Conroy, a special education school; and the Student Achievement Center.
Following the postponement, administrators in May presented an updated feasibility study, dropping the number of proposed school closures from 14 to 12 including Arsenal PreK-5, Fulton PreK-5, King PreK-8, Linden PreK-5, Manchester PreK-8, Miller PreK-5, Spring Hill K-5, Woolslair PreK-5, Allegheny 6-8, South Brook 6-8, South Hills 6-8 and Milliones 6-12.
Now, the hearings are back on the table.
“Whether you like it or not, we’ve been on a nightmare roller coaster together for the past 15 months and a yes vote on Wednesday isn’t going to get us off that nightmare roller coaster because a yes vote would be more of the same — whiplash and churn and confusion,” parent Holly Munson said. “Student outcomes don’t change until adult behaviors change.”
Ms. Munson called on the board to change its approach moving forward by withdrawing the resolution until a find-my-school tool is released, Superintendent Wayne Walters is held accountable to put together an “actual plan,” and the plan fosters equity.
Equity was a key point for parent Elizabeth Cummins, who suggested the proposal has little detail about how the changes will deliver more equitable outcomes for students.
Defining what equity looks like, Ms. Cummins, said, should have been a starting point.
“Our district can’t survive another wave of closures that results in further enrollment loss and even fewer resources for the students who remain,” Ms. Cummins said. “We have to get it right this time.”
Many throughout the more than two-hour meeting would cheer for speakers, including those with 412 Justice who held the rally prior to the hearing.
Throughout the rally chants from nearly 30 people filled the air including “Whose schools? Our schools” and “Kids love their schools.” Many held signs reading “Closing schools is not ‘brave or courageous.’ It’s lazy!” while questioning “How are you saving money by closing schools?”
“We will not shrink back,” 412 Justice member Paulette Foster said at the rally. “For two years, we have been coming before the board of directors in regards to school closures, in regards to the feasibility plan, the nontransparent conversation we have been fighting.”
Those at the rally, Ms. Foster said, want to know what the plan will look like before the board moves forward, a common theme heard throughout the public hearing.
Billy Hileman, president of the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers, questioned during the public hearing why the district is proposing to make the majority of changes once the school year wraps up in June 2026. As things currently stand, the majority of schools would undergo renovations over the summer and then reopen in the fall of that year. The district’s timeline, Mr. Hileman said, strays from a plan presented by district-hired consultants that instead proposed a phased approach.
“Your employees are stressed out,” Mr. Hileman said. “They are approaching what may be the most difficult year in memory. They are your greatest asset. The teachers, counselors, [paraprofessionals], custodial, food staff — they don’t see your vision. They don’t see what’s on the other side of this plan.”
Others also questioned the timeline, especially when it came to magnet schools. The questions echoed a petition created recently calling on PPS to allow all current magnet school students in grades K-3 to remain at their school until completion of the final grade level offered.
The petition has garnered more than 550 signatures.
“We are unified in our message that these children deserve stability, dignity and an education they were promised,” Dilworth parent Ashley Rooths said. “Please reconsider your decision and the harm it will cause students, families and the broader community.”
Under the plan, Ms. Rooths said her daughter would be forced to switch schools for her fifth grade year and then again in sixth grade. Dilworth, Ms. Rooths said, has benefitted her daughter, allowing her to better foster relationships.
“If something works well you don’t bulldoze it, you replicate it,” Ms. Rooths said.
Those thoughts were echoed by Stephen McClain, who said the proposed plan is not feasible for his family, or the 500 others who signed the petition.
“Even if the district moves forward with phasing out magnet programs, doing so in just one year is not a true phase-out; it’s a rushed decision,” Mr. McClain said. “The goal of making all schools equitable cannot be achieved overnight or within a single school year. I urge the district to honor its commitment to current magnet students in grades K-3 by allowing them to complete their elementary education where they began, surrounded by stability, relationships and support they’ve come to depend on.”
Parent Rachel Canning, who also spoke at the rally, added that the board could have spent the past year-and-a-half working with the city and legislators to figure out other ways to fund public education.
The board, she said, hasn’t done everything in its power to protect public education.
“This feels like chaos by design,” Ms. Canning said. “No implementation budget, no staffing road map, no transportation plan. That’s making people panic.”
The board will vote on the resolution during Wednesday’s legislative session. The meeting will be held in the Oakland administration building.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.