Katrina Shaahid often spent the summer months worrying her kids would fall behind academically. So when Pittsburgh Public Schools offered a free summer learning program in the years following the pandemic, she jumped at the opportunity.
And her kids flourished.
The mother of five, three of whom are current Pittsburgh Public students, said she has seen improvements in her children's academic performance. And they were more prepared for upcoming school years.
But the district last year announced the program was ending, citing inconsistent student attendance and the conclusion of pandemic relief funds used to cover program bills. The decision caused Ms. Shaahid, of Lincoln-Lemington, to scramble as she grappled with the loss of a free academic program while balancing the search for a new summer opportunity.
“It's disappointing, frustrating,” Ms. Shaahid said. “Because parents like myself who do work … rely on Summer B.O.O.S.T. to assist their children with some of the academic refreshers during the summer. [They] are extremely helpful to the student. It helps to prepare them for fall when school starts.”
The district in November first said it was considering shuttering the no-cost program that has been around since 2021. At the time, PPS officials said they used pandemic relief money — those funds ended in September — to cover the $2.4 million program bill. Superintendent Wayne Walters during a November meeting also said the program “had limited impact on student outcomes” and was plagued with inconsistent attendance.
Read More
A handful of parents at the time spoke against the move during a December budget hearing, suggesting the problem wasn’t the program, it was communication.
“There's a lot of programming that PPS has and a lot of things that they do that parents just aren't aware of,” Ghadah Makoshi, a Pittsburgh Public parent who works for the American Civil Liberties Union, told the Post-Gazette. “Communication seems to be something you heard from another parent or maybe the guidance counselor told you about it, but I don't think there was enough outreach about B.O.O.S.T.”
Summer B.O.O.S.T. — which stands for building positive relationships; opportunities for exploration; on track for your future; supporting academic success; and thriving in a fun environment — began as an effort to combat learning loss caused by the pandemic.
The program for students in grades K-7 was designed to build positive relationships and create opportunities for exploration “that put youth on track for their future academic success in a thriving and fun environment,” the district website reads.
It was one of many started by school districts across the region and country to help students rebound from online learning and other pandemic-related impacts, something Erik Peterson, senior vice president of policy at the Washington D.C.-based Afterschool Alliance, which advocates for public investment in after-school programs, called “super important.”
The programs, he said, gained popularity during the pandemic but have been around for years to help address the summer slide, or the loss of academic skills over the summer, particularly for students who are challenged academically or who come from low-income families.
But despite efforts in places such as Pennsylvania, which over the past two years has funneled millions of dollars to afterschool and summer programs, camps could disappear as organizations and schools struggle to find funding, Mr. Peterson said.
Nationwide, $2.4 billion of now-ended pandemic relief funding was spent on summer programs, an Afterschool Alliance analysis found. And President Donald Trump in his initial budget proposal called for consolidating and eliminating several federal education grants, NPR reported. And while things such as the 21st Century Community Learning Centers grant — which provides federal funding for community learning centers and enrichment opportunities — wasn’t specifically listed, the public radio said, advocates believe it could potentially be cut.
“That's the concern for sure,” Mr. Peterson said of programs possibly closing, “and seems to be sort of the trend but there's also a lot of momentum and a lot of recognition that if there's a way to find funding to keep these open that folks are going to try hard.”
At Pittsburgh Public, issues with Summer B.O.O.S.T. went beyond funding.
An analysis of the 2021 B.O.O.S.T. program conducted by Johns Hopkins University found that participants saw greater growth in reading and math for students without individualized education plans. English language learners also saw greater growth in math.
But that year the program experienced staffing shortages, which caused the program to start a week later than scheduled. About 1,000 students were cut after the district could not find enough employees to fully staff the program. Students who did participate in the program on average attended 17.6 sessions, but that varied by grade.
Attendance issues continued over the years and by 2023 about 70% of students attended all available programming days, another report by education consultant Gibson found. In anticipation of similar issues, staff in 2024 overenrolled students. But class sizes on average totaled 11.6 students rather than the anticipated 30.
By November, Mr. Walters issued a letter detailing the planned program closure.
“We know this news may be disappointing, but please rest assured that our commitment to providing high-quality learning experiences for our students remains steadfast,” Mr. Walters wrote. “Moving forward, we will explore new partnerships with the city and community organizations to support alternative summer programs.”
Community reaction
Linda Robinson-Walls said Summer B.O.O.S.T. “saved” her two great-granddaughters.
The girls had recently moved in with Ms. Robinson-Wells when they enrolled in the program, a move that gave them stability and the opportunity to meet new friends from other PPS schools.
“The girls loved it,” Ms. Robinson-Wells said. “They had so many activities. They met children from all over. It was a wonderful experience for them.”
Now, Ms. Robinson-Wells is searching for a new summer camp to enroll the girls in. But she faces financial and transportation barriers.
The district created a website listing summer camp opportunities across the city. Those include camps offered by the Pittsburgh Bureau of Fire and the nonprofit Each One Teach One. It also has activities such as a Carnegie Library reading partnership and a childcare finder.
At PPS, programs such as the Extended School Year, which works with qualifying students to ensure maintenance of individualized education plan goals and objectives are met during the school year break, will continue.
But Ms. Robinson-Wells called the decision to end B.O.O.S.T. “a shame.”
“It has made a serious impact on our lives, and I don't know where they're going to go,” Ms. Robinson-Wells said.
Ms. Makoshi, the PPS parent who works for the ACLU, said a major problem is the loss of a free program.
“For a great deal of PPS parents finding a camp that, one, can teach academic, incorporate it with social and with fun is not just hard to find, but it's out of reach financially for most parents,” Ms. Makoshi said. “And so this was an opportunity.”
Ms. Shaahid’s children — Justice, 7; Journee, 9; and Jenesis, 11 — participated in Summer B.O.O.S.T. the past three years. The program featured reading, math and science classes as well as art and music. She chose the program based on its “academic enrichment.”
And while her children didn’t enjoy getting up early during the summer, they had a good time meeting teachers and students from other PPS schools.
When she found out the program was ending, “I said, ‘You gotta be kidding me.’” But she noted that often her children would come home and tell her there were only six other kids in the class.
“I kind of figured it's funded and they're paying teachers, they're paying for the bus, and they're paying for all these set things for a certain amount of children and if those children aren't utilizing these sources we're kind of wasting money,” Ms. Shaahid said. “So I get it.”
Still, Ms. Shaahid is now searching for a new summer camp with no luck so far.
“It's unfortunate because I just don't know,” Ms. Shaahid said. “There's really nothing out there.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.