Tension crackled in the gym at Sunnyside PreK-8 as parents crowded around cafeteria tables, voices rising and hands shooting into the air on Wednesday night.

The hourslong discussion was fueled by frustration and concerns over Pittsburgh Public Schools’ controversial plan to close nine schools and redraw grade reconfigurations for several others.

Pittsburgh Public Schools has launched a series of community hearings this summer, branded as community conversations. These sessions are an addition to open state-required public hearings set to start July 21. Both will run through September and center on the district’s Future-Ready Facilities Plan, a proposed reorganization aimed at addressing two key issues: a growing budget deficit and declining enrollment. According to the district, schools are currently operating at half of their capacity.

“The number one reason why this plan was started was because there are students in our district who are not receiving the same quality of education as other students,” said Lamar Blackwell, chief of staff for the Pittsburgh Public Schools.

Advertise with us

The school board has been reviewing the plan since January. Among the schools being considered for closure are Baxter, which houses the Student Achievement Center; Friendship (Montessori PreK-5); Fulton PreK-5; McKelvey (Miller PreK-5); Morrow PreK-8; Schiller 6-8; Spring Hill PreK-5; Woolslair PreK-5; and Manchester PreK-8. The proposal also includes opening two schools: Northview PreK-5 and Sci Tech 6-8.

Out of a crowd of about 50 Wednesday night, most parents expressed frustration with the district’s shifting plans.

“I just see an enormous burden being placed on the teachers,” said Ikhana Hal Makina, whose four children went to Sunnyside. “Your reasoning for the closure doesn’t really make sense to me.”

Several parents said the plan felt backward and miscommunicated.

“It seems like we’re trying to shoehorn equity into the already decided facilities plan, which is completely out of the order of your own strategic plan that you put out to the public,” said Michael Cummins of Lawrenceville.

Advertise with us

In response, Mr. Blackwell explained the plan.

“Each and every school was evaluated based off of its capacity, based off of how many students it could hold,” Mr. Blackwell said in response.

Some people criticized the district’s agenda, arguing there are more important discussions.

“You have failed generations of students,” Nosakhere Griffin-El said. “When are we going to stop talking about facilities, programs and really get to what is the critical experience that these kids need to make sure that they maximize their human potential.”

District officials frequently described the plans using the word “equity,” but several parents questioned whether equal resources alone would truly serve students’ diverse needs.

Advertise with us

Others worried that the plan would continue to tie student outcomes to geography, rather than expand opportunity.

“In Pittsburgh, your ZIP code determines your outcomes, and you’re presenting to us a plan where ZIP code determines outcomes,” said Nathan VanHoudnos of Squirrel Hill.

Another issue parents had was that, according to the plan, both student achievement centers and the gifted center would be closed.

Mr. Blackwell said the leadership team is making a focused effort to ensure that each school is properly following the gifted education model and that all students are receiving the services they should.

“If it was as easy as ‘Let’s just put these things in these other schools,’ it would have already been done,” Mr. Blackwell said.

Advertise with us

Not every parent was opposed to the plan. Emily Cane of Morningside, who has three kids in the district said, “I loved that you were focused on bringing joy to our buildings and that the spirit of the outcomes you want to see in our buildings was emphasized in that plan.”

A May feasibility report from Superintendent Wayne Walters and his team projects yearly savings of approximately $8 million in school-based budgets and utility costs. Additionally, annual transportation savings are estimated at over $5 million.

The plan would be rolled out in three phases:

• Phase 1 begins in June 2026: 11 schools will close, including King K-8 and Miller PreK-5. Twelve schools will see changes in what grades are offered, including Morrow K-8, Colfax K-8 and Greenfield PreK-8. Northview will start a process of major renovations. Allegheny K-5 and Montessori PreK-5 will have relocated some of their buildings. Some magnet schools will also close, including Dilworth PreK-5 and Linden PreK-5. The Student Achievement Center closes.

• Phase 2, slated from summer to fall 2027, would involve closing the Gifted Center building and integrating gifted services into neighborhood schools.

Advertise with us

• Phase 3, projected for June 2028: Northview’s renovations will finish and Spring Hill PreK–5 will close. By fall 2028, Northview will reopen as a new K–5 elementary school.

The next community conversation session is scheduled for 6 p.m. July 24 at Pittsburgh King. The state-required hearings start July 21 at the district’s Oakland administration building.

After the public comment period concludes, the administration will present its final recommendations to the school board later this year. The school board vote will happen this fall.