University of Pittsburgh leaders outlined what they would like to see from a state funding formula based on school performance during a Wednesday morning hearing as officials continue ironing out the details of the incoming model.
Pennsylvania’s Performance-Based Funding Council held its fourth and final hearing on the proposed model on Pitt’s campus. Previous hearings occurred in recent weeks in Harrisburg and at Penn State and Temple University, the two other schools that would be impacted by the formula.
During the Oakland hearing, Pitt Chief Financial Officer Dwayne Pinkney advocated for a funding formula based on metrics such as graduation, retention and job placement rates.
Mr. Pinkney pushed the council to create a model that would award new dollars to universities, rather than reallocate existing funds. Pennsylvania’s 2024-25 budget allocated $151 million to Pitt and $242 million to Penn State — dollar amounts that have remained stagnant for years and are used to lower tuition costs for in-state students.
Mr. Pinkney also said Pitt wants institutions to compete against their past performances, and would like the model to acknowledge areas in which schools are already succeeding.
The CFO expressed optimism that this model could restore trust in Pennsylvania’s state-related universities among prospective students and families who are becoming increasingly skeptical of higher education.
Read More
“Such a model would be transparent, predictable and simple while driving quicker, more impactful and least disruptive outcomes for higher education in the commonwealth,” Mr. Pinkney told the council, whose voting members include interim acting state Secretary of Education Angela Fitterer and four state lawmakers.
Any increased funds that universities receive could potentially be used to lower tuition costs for in-state students, council members indicated on Wednesday.
The council intends to work out details of the model — including which metrics will be used — by the end of April. At a Penn State hearing last month, Penn State administrators pushed for enrollment, retention rates, degree completion rates, and the share of Pell Grant-recipients and first-generation students to determine a university’s success.
Gov. Josh Shapiro commissioned the council in 2024 to study performance-based university funding, which is already implemented in 31 states.
During an interview with the Post-Gazette this week, Mr. Shapiro said he hopes the model will bolster the state’s workforce and encourage more students to stay in the Keystone State after they graduate.
“I think this is a novel way to fund higher ed, and it's a way that the taxpayers of Pennsylvania can know that their dollars are going to outcomes,” Mr. Shapiro said. “They're going to benefit all of us and lift up the entire commonwealth.”
Experts have indicated that the effectiveness of performance-based funding formulas is minimal at best, though these models can please taxpayers and improve the favorability of politicians.
When Mr. Shapiro first floated the idea of creating a performance-based funding system in 2024, he indicated that Pennsylvania’s state system universities and community colleges could also be judged by these metrics.
But as the plans now stand, only three Pennsylvania institutions — state-related universities Pitt, Penn State and Temple — would be subject to performance-based review.
Also at Wednesday’s hearing, council members heard from a Pitt nursing student; Kellie Kane, Pitt’s associate vice provost for enrollment; Emilia Mattucci, executive director of the Pennsylvania School Counselors Association; and Tim Jones, CFO for the board of governors of Florida’s state university system.
Mr. Jones gave a report to the council on the metrics and operations of Florida’s performance-based funding system, which was developed more than a decade ago.
At the conclusion of the hearing, council chairman and state Rep. Jesse Topper, R-Bedford, expressed hope that a performance-based funding model could bring positive workforce and demographic changes to the Keystone State.
“We need more families to stay here. We need more families to come here,” Mr. Topper said. “We need our institutions to be ones of great academic rigor that support not just our economy, but that support the students.”
Christopher Carter contributed to this report.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.