Gov. Josh Shapiro is eyeing big changes to the state’s higher education system.
Among his ambitious proposals to transform Pennsylvania’s higher education landscape is a performance-based funding model that would tie public university funding to student performance metrics.
But would Mr. Shapiro’s plan to introduce such a model actually bring big change to Pennsylvania colleges?
A majority of states fund their public higher education institutions at least in part through performance-based funding models, which grew in popularity throughout the 2000s and 2010s in both Democrat- and Republican-led states.
And while these systems are “good politics” for governors aiming to please citizens seeking heightened accountability from their public colleges, their effectiveness is typically minimal at best, said Justin Ortagus, director of the Institute of Higher Education at the University of Florida.
On top of that, performance-based funding can have unintended negative consequences, he said.
Read More
“For a governor who may be interested in his own popularity and potentially [has] national ambition, it certainly makes sense to be someone who’s at the forefront, holding higher education accountable,” Mr. Ortagus said. “[But it’s important] to do so in ways that are mindful of some of the unintended consequences.”
Here’s what is known so far about Mr. Shapiro’s performance-funding plan — and how these models have played out in other states.
What is Mr. Shapiro proposing for Pa. colleges?
During his 2024-25 state budget address, Mr. Shapiro said he would like to see a “predictable, transparent, outcomes-based funding system” that applies to the 10 state system universities, community colleges and four state-related institutions, which include the University of Pittsburgh and Penn State.
Different outcomes analyzed could include schools’ first-generation enrollments, the share of graduates who stay in Pennsylvania, and the share of students who enter high-demand fields such as agriculture, education and nursing, Mr. Shapiro envisioned.
But the plan has been light on details. Mr. Shapiro has not laid out what specific metrics would be considered in such a funding model or the stake that performance would have in the schools’ funding.
Mr. Shapiro’s office did release an FAQ that said the funding formula would measure two sets of outcomes. One set would be “common” to Pennsylvania’s different public institutions, while the other would “recognize and reward” results that are “unique” to colleges’ specific missions.
The plan will also provide additional resources to schools that serve “students who require additional supports” — though it did not identify any specific student groups.
The idea has received support from Penn State President Neeli Bendapudi, who has repeatedly called on lawmakers to enact a performance-based model in the Keystone State. Ms. Bendapudi previously led the University of Louisville in Kentucky, which heavily relies on performance metrics to fund its universities.
“While this is just the first step in the state’s budget process, I am appreciative of Gov. Shapiro’s proposal to increase funding for the state-related universities, and for his support of performance-based funding as a means to grow the state’s investment in higher education,” Ms. Bendapudi said in a February news release.
It makes sense that Ms. Bendapudi would throw her weight behind such a plan, said Mr. Ortagus. As a large institution with high student success rates, Penn State would receive more state dollars under such a model.
“It's absolutely a good thing for the Penn States of the world who are more selective and are enrolling high-achieving students,” Mr. Ortagus said. “Where the challenges typically come are for community colleges, public regional institutions, and those that are enrolling students who may not be as prepared on day one to succeed in college.”
How do performance-based models work in other states?
Most states use some form of performance-based policies to provide funding to their public higher education institutions.
But the extent to which performance plays a role in funding varies greatly.
As of 2021, performance-based funding made up over 90% of the operating budgets of public colleges in four states: Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky and North Dakota.
In contrast, this funding comprised less than 1% of funding in five states: North Carolina, Illinois, Massachusetts, Kansas and Hawaii.
And states vary in what metrics they consider when measuring performance. In Ohio, for instance, outcomes evaluated include degree completion and course completion.
Meanwhile, Tennessee — which became the first state to introduce performance-based funding metrics to its public universities 45 years ago — currently weighs degree progress, degree completion and research funding in its evaluation. About 80% of the funding at the state’s public institutions is based on performance metrics, said Robert Kelchen, head of the Department of Educational Leadership and Policy Studies at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville
“To really simplify it … colleges get a certain amount of money for each degree [earned],” Mr. Kelchen said. “Essentially, the better you do, the more money you get.”
In Pennsylvania, the 10 state universities previously received some of their funds through a performance-based model that measured degree attainment and achievement gaps, among other measures. As of 2022, the system’s board of governors allocates funds based on core operational needs and enrollment.
Is performance-based funding effective?
Though performance-based funding models sound promising, experts agree these formulas have little to no effect in their states.
Graduation and retention rates are barely impacted, if at all. Under these models, some colleges begin offering more short-term certificates, while “not actually moving the needle” in terms of degree attainment, Mr. Ortagus said.
Other drawbacks include widened resource gaps between colleges that enroll larger numbers of low-income students and schools that primarily enroll wealthier students, a 2020 study co-authored by Mr. Ortagus and Mr. Kelchen shows.
“Do colleges that serve students who are less likely to succeed … get the resources they need? Because if you're trying to educate students who need significant remediation [and] went to an under-resourced high school, for example — they're going to need more money to be able to finish,” Mr. Kelchen said. “If [colleges] are not getting money for that, then they are going to end up getting less money because they'll produce fewer degrees relative to everyone else.”
But there are some positives. For starters, performance-based funding can make schools more aware of student outcomes, Mr. Kelchen said.
“It's changed behavior, at least some,” Mr. Kelchen said. “[There’s] a strong focus on student outcomes — but quite a bit was already there.”
These funding models can also provide an opportunity for public colleges to receive the funds they require from the state.
And politically, performance-based funding can boost public trust in higher education, said Mr. Ortagus.
“They do address this growing public skepticism related to higher education by holding colleges and universities accountable for the outcomes [that] the state prioritizes,” Mr. Ortagus said.
If Pennsylvania adopts a performance-based funding model, Mr. Ortagus said a 1-2% funding stake in performance “isn’t going to move the needle.” He also believes the state should directly tie funding to supporting students who face greater disadvantages, such as first-generation and low-income students.
Ultimately, it could bolster the state’s higher education landscape, he believes.
“This could lead to more funding for all Pennsylvania colleges and universities because this is the way to ensure public trust [and] address public skepticism,” Mr. Ortagus said. “It's good politics for governors and state legislatures.
“And if it's going to lead to more funding, that's an unmitigated win for higher education, even if performance funding formulas haven't been shown to work super well, historically.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.