A miscalculation in college students’ financial aid information means that over 200,000 borrowers’ information needs to be recalculated — and some Pittsburgh-area students are among those affected.
Officials at Penn State, Slippery Rock University and Point Park University confirmed the miscalculation impacts a small number of their students and prospective students.
The error has not impacted Duquesne University, the Indiana University of Pennsylvania and Carlow University, officials said.
And the University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon University and Chatham University did not specify whether the error has directly impacted their students and prospective students. Pennsylvania Western University and Robert Morris University did not provide comment.
This error specifically impacts some students who reported financial assets such as investments, savings and total cash. A vendor working for the U.S. Department of Education forgot to factor those assets into their calculation of students’ FAFSA forms.
Students impacted by the miscalculation will now wait even longer to receive financial aid offers from schools, said Karen McCarthy, vice president of public policy and federal relations at National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators.
Read More
That could have a heightened impact on incoming freshmen who are still deciding where to attend college.
“For the roughly 200,000 students impacted by this miscalculation, it means having to wait even longer before receiving their aid offer, likely also delaying their ability to make a decision on college enrollment,” Ms. McCarthy said in an email. “It’s important that students have a clear understanding of what college will cost before making that decision.”
The miscalculation is yet another bump in the road for students, families and colleges grappling with the Department of Education’s shaky launch of the revamped FAFSA.
When the new application launched at the end of December, it was riddled with technology issues and limited time frames to actually complete the application. These challenges were heightened when the Department of Education announced in February that it wouldn’t begin transferring financial information to colleges until March — a month later than initially anticipated.
Schools in the Pittsburgh region began receiving these data in mid-to-late March.
The messy launch has led schools to push back their freshman commitment deadlines.
And it has caused colleges to see declines in the number of students who have completed the form. In mid-March, the National College Attainment Network reported that FAFSA applications were down roughly 29% in Allegheny County, 28% statewide and 34% nationally compared to last year’s data.
Anecdotally, Pitt spokesman Jared Stonesifer said the university has received 9,000 FAFSA information files — “which is far fewer than what we historically have received in the spring.” Mr. Stonesifer said the university plans to send out financial aid offers to undergraduate students the week of April 22.
That will give prospective students less than a month to decide if they want to commit to Pitt.
University officials are cognizant of the stress this can put on students and their families. Marlin Collingwood, vice president of enrollment at Point Park University, called the updated FAFSA launch “an unfortunate situation.”
“This has been a really unfortunate situation for all schools and students across the country,” Mr. Collingwood said. “There’s real concern that some of the students who are likely to get some of the biggest awards may make a decision that it’s taking too long [to receive financial aid offers].”
Joel Bauman, Duquesne’s senior vice president of enrollment management, echoed this sentiment.
“Our concern is that some other issue may emerge — regardless that it affects a smaller number — and reinforce perceptions of a “broken system" and deter families from filling out their forms in a timely fashion,” Mr. Bauman said in an email. “For those families affected, they should maintain contact with their admissions representatives.”
The revamped FAFSA arrives four years after Congress approved the FAFSA Simplification Act in 2020.
Key changes to the form include a shortened question pool — it asks around 50 questions rather than over 100 — and a streamlined process for government access to the financial information of applicants and their families. Beginning in the 2024-25 award year, a new interface will allow the government to directly receive federal tax information from the Internal Revenue Service when determining a student's needs and grant eligibility.
But these improvements could be overshadowed by continuous issues with the new form. Ms. McCarthy, of NASFAA, said she believes the situation has harmed the public’s trust in the Department of Education.
“With any overhaul of this size, bugs, glitches, and minor errors are to be expected,” she said. “But the frequency and severity of the errors we’ve seen, coupled with a lack of timely communication and unclear plans for resolution, has certainly eroded the public’s trust in the department.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.