Leaders at Pittsburgh Public Schools are working to improve proficiency rates among students taking the Keystone biology exam for the first time after levels failed to meet district goals.
Last year, almost 31.2% of students scored proficient on the exam, which fell below the district’s 32.8% goal, Superintendent Wayne Walters said at Wednesday’s education committee meeting.
That’s a trend district officials have seen since 2022. That year, 24.5% of students scored proficient on the exam, which was below the 26.9% goal. By 2023, 27.2% of students were proficient, which was under the 29.8% goal.
The numbers come as Pittsburgh Public aims to have a 41.5% proficiency rate by 2026-27.
Still, despite not reaching overall goals, Mr. Walters noted that proficiency scores have continued to improve.
In addition to those overall numbers, the district also recorded disparities between different student groups including white students, English language learners, those who are economically disadvantaged, Black students and those with individualized education plans.
Read More
White students saw the highest proficiency rates at 57.3%. English language learners followed at 32.9%. Students who are economically disadvantaged saw proficiency rates at 19.2% and Black students saw rates around 12.6%. Students with IEPs had the lowest rates, coming in at 6%.
Given the rates, Mr. Walters pointed to several challenges facing the district, including chronic absenteeism — defined as the percentage of students missing at least 10% of a school year — something that has been plaguing districts since the pandemic.
“In every subgroup we see regular attenders having greater rates of proficiency compared to students who are chronologically absent,” Mr. Walters said. “This is significant as it elevates the old saying that when you miss school you miss out.”
And like schools across the state, Pittsburgh Public is also working to align science curriculum around new state standards. Pennsylvania’s Science, Technology & Engineering, Environmental Literacy & Sustainability, or PA STEELS, standards were first adopted by the state in July 2022 to shift students away from memorizing facts to instead conducting research and investigations. They go into effect next school year.
Given those changes and challenges, district leaders are taking steps to improve those scores.
The first strategy focuses on curriculum-based professional learning. Within that idea, officials will implement virtual and ongoing professional learning opportunities. Science supervisors will also conduct weekly classroom walkthroughs to collect data that will be shared with principals and assistant superintendents to monitor implementation trends.
The second goal is to provide access to standards-aligned resources. To do that, officials will focus on curriculum mapping, or providing a clear guide for teachers that aligns the biology curriculum with eligible content tested on the biology Keystone exam. They also will provide teachers with exam-based resources such as scoring rubrics and sample responses.
The final strategy looks at data-driven instruction to analyze student performance, identify learning gaps and provide targeted instructional supports.
That includes implementing data literacy training by equipping teachers with skills to analyze multiple data sources; focusing on comprehensive data analysis to inform instructional decisions tailored to diverse student needs; providing differentiated support, or using data for targeted interventions and enrichments; and creating instructional resources aligned to data insights including intervention guides and sample assessments.
Board President Gene Walker added that the district now needs to show students that the lessons are relevant to their daily lives.
The challenge, he said, is for educators to be able to teach “those subjects in a way that makes it relevant for students so that they can look at those subjects and say, ‘Yes, this makes sense. I can use this in some other form other than school.’ I don’t know if it’s just me, but I think the challenge is even greater when you’re talking about biology.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.