Since Monday, Brian Sanders has watched as his children wake up at 4 a.m., giving them enough time to get ready before arriving at a Pittsburgh Regional Transit bus stop by 5:15 a.m.

The morning routine is new this school year after the Penn Hills School District announced that several charter school students living in the district will take public transit, including Mr. Sanders’ kids who attend Westinghouse Arts Academy.

The decision is expected to save the district nearly $411,000 in transportation costs. But it has been unpopular among some parents who worry about their children taking public transportation.

“You only care about yourselves,” Mr. Sanders told school directors Wednesday. “You’re the ones that messed up the budget. Why do my kids got to suffer for it? This is child endangerment.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Sanders was one of several parents who showed up at Wednesday’s school board meeting to express concerns about the decision, including worries about their children getting to and from the bus stop, long commutes and safety issues while riding the bus.

The meeting came after Penn Hills announced that 80 students in sixth through 12th grade who attend Environmental Charter middle and high school and Westinghouse Arts Academy would be given a district-purchased bus pass to get to and from school starting this school year. Students attending Propel Andrew Street High School, Propel Braddock Hills middle and high school and LIFE Male STEAM Academy were originally expected to have to take public transportation but they are no longer impacted by the changes. Districts are required by state law to transport students to private and charter schools.

District officials said discussions around the changes started in May when Penn Hills officially exited Pennsylvania’s financial recovery program. Penn Hills at the time was incurring higher transportation costs than most other Allegheny County schools, and in 2022 had spent $7.4 million to transport more than 3,000 students.

And according to Daniel Matsook, the district’s chief recovery officer, part of the exit petition submitted to the state to leave financial recovery included monitoring costs related to charter schools and transportation.

Because of that, Penn Hills conducted an analysis of all district bus routes with the goal of determining if any cost savings could occur from adjusting bus schedules.

Advertise with us

Officials ultimately chose to outsource transportation for students at the three schools, a decision, officials said at the time, that will help efficiently manage taxpayer funds while addressing an ongoing bus driver shortage that has plagued districts since the start of the pandemic.

“If we do not pay strict attention to these big major expenses in our budget you can expect, as sure as we’re sitting here this evening, that the district will experience a very slow boil back into recovery status and that’s something we don’t want to do,” Mr. Matsook said.

In all, K-12 students attending one of the district’s schools will ride a traditional school bus, operated by Krise Transportation. All students in grades K-5 will also ride a district bus regardless of if they attend a Penn Hills school or a charter school.

For sixth through 12th graders attending one of the impacted charter schools, monthly Pittsburgh Regional Transit bus passes will be distributed, which can be used to get to and from school and to attend events such as after-school activities or work. If a student in grades 6-12 has a younger sibling who rides the district bus, the older student may ride the bus with them.

Despite financial aspects laid out by the district, several parents remained unhappy with the decision.

Advertise with us

“What you guys have done is really wrong,” Corinne Carroll said Wednesday.

Ms. Carroll’s daughter started her freshman year at Westinghouse Arts Academy this week. But according to Ms. Carroll, to get there her daughter has to walk a mile and a half to the bus stop, where she has to be by 5:30 a.m. Once she’s on the bus, Ms. Carroll said, her daughter has two transfers. It takes her over two hours to get to school and home each day.

“You would not want that for your kid,” Ms. Carroll repeated, pointing to each person sitting on the board. “None of you would want this for your children.”

Katharine Sanchez’s daughter also attends Westinghouse Arts Academy. Like Ms. Carroll, Ms. Sanchez’s daughter has to walk along a busy road where cars often fly past PRT buses.

“I don’t really understand what came into everybody’s minds when you were choosing which children deserve to have a bus and be safe and which children did not,” Ms. Sanchez said. “What were the qualifications?”

Advertise with us

While Erin Martin is not directly impacted by the busing change, she said she watches as her close friend struggles to balance work with getting her child to the bus stop.

“If I had to guess about the conversation that took place right before this decision was made and finalized I would think it went something like ‘Well if they don’t want their kids to come to our district then they’re going to be responsible for getting them there,’” Ms. Martin said. “I just want to know who would be responsible if anything were to happen to one of these children. Who can be blamed?”

And Ron Wood, who moved to the district two years ago, said the board “could have found a middle ground” by contracting with smaller bus companies to take charter school kids to school.

While the board listened to concerns expressed by parents, Superintendent John Mozzocio prior to public comment said “The district has made tough decisions and will continue to make tough decisions. We will stay committed to using PRT bus passes. The board and administration has made a decision.”

Mr. Matsook added that the district is also in a five year monitoring period with the state, making it important to implement “viable strategies, whether it’s fare-based transportation or combining routes or reducing buses.”

He added that the district will “pay very very close attention so we don’t jeopardize the safety of students, we don’t do anything that’s illegal and that we are very responsive.”